9 recorded contributions
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Alcohol consumption, Theatre
I rise today to speak about Motion M207 and to raise what I believe is a fundamental
issue of fairness, of consistency and common sense in the government's approach to
liquor policy in British Columbia. That is why removing the word "independent" levels
the playing field for all movie theatres across British Columbia. Why not let the
owners decide whether they want to serve liquor or not in their theatres instead of
government restricting certain theatres from doing it? This bill proposes allowing liquor services during mixed-age movie screening for small
and independent theatres. While supporters of the bill argue this is about helping
local cinemas survive, the legislation creates more questions than answers. The central
issue is this. If responsible liquor service during mixed-age movie screenings is
appropriate public policy, then why would the government not apply it to small and
independent theatres instead of all theatres? Why restrict it? Why create another arbitrary distinction? Why would some theatres
be trusted while others are restricted under the exact same circumstances? That's
why removing the word "independent" is clear, and it is fair. Either adults can responsibly consume alcohol while attending a movie with minors
present under regulated provincial laws or not. The standard should not change based
on the size of the building, the number of screens or the business model of the theatre
operator. Who decides these distinctions? Public safety rules should be based on behaviour and standards, not on square footage.
Yet this bill proposes exactly that. One set of rules for some theatres, another set
of rules for others. That is not fairness; that is selective policy-making. That's
why removing the word "independent" is an important legislative change. We already allow liquor services in countless mixed-age environments across British
Columbia. Adults can consume alcohol at restaurants where families dine together.
Adults can drink at concerts attended by minors, at sporting events, at community
festivals, at bowling alleys, at live theatre productions, at conference centres,
at airports. All of those places responsible adults are trusted to consume alcohol
under regulated conditions while minors are present. Importantly, those venues are
not divided into small or large categories before government decides whether liquor
services are acceptable. The rule applies equally. But not to allow small and independent theatres? Why not include all theatres? Removing
the word "independent" clarifies this inconsistency, so why are movie theatres treated
differently? And why does Motion M207 deepen the inconsistency instead of solving
it? This bill risks creating an uneven, distorted playing field across British Columbia's
entertainment industry. A theatre with two or three screens may qualify for expanded liquor permission, while
other theatres with four or five screens down the road remain restricted, despite
serving the same community, operating under the same provincial liquor laws and employing
trained staff allowing the same rules. How does that make sense? How is that fair
competition? And perhaps, most Perhaps, most importantly, where exactly does government draw the line? If a theatre
expands and becomes successful, does it lose its privilege? If a theatre has different
ownership, does it lose its licence? There are problems with legislation built around
arbitrary classifications rather than consistent principles across the board. Businesses across the province are exhausted by government's constant creative carve-outs,
exceptions, pilot projects and selective rules instead of establishing one fair, transparent
framework for all. This bill continues that trend. Instead of modernizing our liquor
policy for all theatres in British Columbia, government proposes another narrow exemption
targeting one category of business.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Seniors
Growing our economy on whose backs? Basic cable, landline phones and yarn — what do
they have in common? These are the new luxury items worthy of being taxed by this
government. Seniors crocheting blankets for their grandchildren. Seniors using the
only phone they have, which is a landline, now have to find money elsewhere, with
the little savings they have left, in order to survive. Why is this government pinching pennies from B.C. seniors?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Volunteer work
I would just like to ask some constituents in my riding to please stand. They're good
friends of my wife and myself — Grant and Judy Gaudet. They have served the community
of Abbotsford for many, many years, volunteering, sitting on boards, committees, etc. Would the House make them feel really welcome.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Alcoholic beverages, Beverages, Businesses
I rise today to speak about Motion M207 and to raise what I believe is a fundamental
issue of fairness, of consistency and common sense in the government's approach to
liquor policy in British Columbia. That is why removing the word "independent" levels
the playing field for all movie theatres across British Columbia. Why not let the
owners decide whether they want to serve liquor or not in their theatres instead of
government restricting certain theatres from doing it? This bill proposes allowing liquor services during mixed-age movie screening for small
and independent theatres. While supporters of the bill argue this is about helping
local cinemas survive, the legislation creates more questions than answers. The central
issue is this. If responsible liquor service during mixed-age movie screenings is
appropriate public policy, then why would the government not apply it to small and
independent theatres instead of all theatres? Why restrict it? Why create another arbitrary distinction? Why would some theatres
be trusted while others are restricted under the exact same circumstances? That's
why removing the word "independent" is clear, and it is fair. Either adults can responsibly consume alcohol while attending a movie with minors
present under regulated provincial laws or not. The standard should not change based
on the size of the building, the number of screens or the business model of the theatre
operator. Who decides these distinctions? Public safety rules should be based on behaviour and standards, not on square footage.
Yet this bill proposes exactly that. One set of rules for some theatres, another set
of rules for others. That is not fairness; that is selective policy-making. That's
why removing the word "independent" is an important legislative change. We already allow liquor services in countless mixed-age environments across British
Columbia. Adults can consume alcohol at restaurants where families dine together.
Adults can drink at concerts attended by minors, at sporting events, at community
festivals, at bowling alleys, at live theatre productions, at conference centres,
at airports. All of those places responsible adults are trusted to consume alcohol
under regulated conditions while minors are present. Importantly, those venues are
not divided into small or large categories before government decides whether liquor
services are acceptable. The rule applies equally. But not to allow small and independent theatres? Why not include all theatres? Removing
the word "independent" clarifies this inconsistency, so why are movie theatres treated
differently? And why does Motion M207 deepen the inconsistency instead of solving
it? This bill risks creating an uneven, distorted playing field across British Columbia's
entertainment industry. A theatre with two or three screens may qualify for expanded liquor permission, while
other theatres with four or five screens down the road remain restricted, despite
serving the same community, operating under the same provincial liquor laws and employing
trained staff allowing the same rules. How does that make sense? How is that fair
competition? And perhaps, most Perhaps, most importantly, where exactly does government draw the line? If a theatre
expands and becomes successful, does it lose its privilege? If a theatre has different
ownership, does it lose its licence? There are problems with legislation built around
arbitrary classifications rather than consistent principles across the board. Businesses across the province are exhausted by government's constant creative carve-outs,
exceptions, pilot projects and selective rules instead of establishing one fair, transparent
framework for all. This bill continues that trend. Instead of modernizing our liquor
policy for all theatres in British Columbia, government proposes another narrow exemption
targeting one category of business.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public finance, Taxes
Growing our economy on whose backs? Basic cable, landline phones and yarn — what do
they have in common? These are the new luxury items worthy of being taxed by this
government. Seniors crocheting blankets for their grandchildren. Seniors using the
only phone they have, which is a landline, now have to find money elsewhere, with
the little savings they have left, in order to survive. Why is this government pinching pennies from B.C. seniors?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Privacy, Public access, Public administration
It's always a privilege to rise in this house to speak. I never take that for granted.
Not only do I represent the citizens of Abbotsford but, I believe, in many ways, the
residents across this province. Please forgive me ahead of time. I've got a head cold, so I'll be coughing and gagging
in between. I rise today to speak to the motion for second reading of Bill 9, entitled Freedom
of Information Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, be amended by deleting the
word "now" and substituting "six months hence." Therefore, it's called the "hoist." The need to pause Bill 9 introduced by the opposition is paramount to getting this
cornerstone legislation to our democracy right. There's a saying, a true saying, that
said there's nothing new under the sun. It's very interesting that on the other side
of the planet, in Australia, they went through the same process here in March. I just want to read this article for you. It's a short couple of brief notes from
it. "A win for democracy: Labor abandons freedom of information laws change that would
have reduced transparency. The Labor government has dumped its controversial changes
to the freedom of information request system, which would have imposed new fees and
further reduced transparency." As we are going through this process, so is the government in Australia going through
the same process. But they saw the light of day. They saw the light of day, and they
pulled it before we got to this point where we're asking to delay it for six months
hence. "The government's changes to the FOI system would have imposed tighter rules
on accessing information, including new grounds to refuse requests based on cabinet
confidentiality" — sounds familiar — "banning anonymous requests" — sounds familiar
— and "rules to deter what the government characterized as vexatious and frivolous
requests." That is why we need to delay implementation of Bill 9 as it stands in order to get
it right this time around, because the bill amends one of the most important statutes
in our province. The act is not administrative housekeeping, as what has been stated.
It is not procedural fine print. It is not bureaucratic technicality. The reason a six-month hence is required because this bill is the backbone of government
transparency and the legal guardian of citizens' privacy rights in British Columbia.
It is the mechanism by which journalists uncover waste. That's why we need six months
to look at and say: "Is this the right bill? Is this going to increase transparency,
or is this going to limit transparency?" It is the tool citizens use to hold government to account. We need a delay to look
at this. It is the safeguard that ensures personal information is not casually collected,
casually shared or casually exposed. Today, Bill 9 weakens both transparency and privacy
at the very same time, and that is precisely why a six-month extension would allow
for a more careful, responsible approach to getting this legislation right. We need a pause of this bill as it stands today because it is not modernization. It
is a shift, a complete shift, a lane change in power. Well, another reason for six months hence is because the B.C. Freedom of Information
and Privacy Association has sent the alarm, and it's reached deaf ears on the other
side. We want to make sure that the delay of six months minimum would allow these people
who understand freedom of information.... Many of these people who crafted the original
document, have deep concerns. Here's one. They're warning that weakens access rights
at a time when government has failed to meaningfully implement its own recordkeeping
law, and that fails to address need for reforms to the act. That is why six months hence is absolutely necessary. That is why six months hence is absolutely necessary. We need to look at those people
and talk to those people who understand freedom of information and say: the amendments,
do they go far enough? Are the amendments too restrictive? How does this change the
intent of the original document to the point where it's ineffective? Number 2, the government has framed the bill as modernization effort to improve digital
service delivery. However, FIPPA notes that the real source of FOI delays is upstream.
It's inconsistent record creation. So it's basically saying here that the amendments
put forth in Bill 9 actually aren't the issue. The issue is record creation, record
classification, record retention and digitization practices across the ministries.
We need to delay this bill in order to review the government's handling of this file
in its entirety. They also say.... "Access delays are often a symptom of recordkeeping failure," said
FIPPA Executive Director Jason Woywada. We cannot fix the system's information management problems by weakening public access
to rights. Another reason for pausing this bill. And we're not talking for an infinite amount of time. It's six months. Would it kill
the bill? We'll see. There are also some glaring absences in Bill 9 that is deeply
flawed because of what it does not include. FIPPA says the bill ignores the work of
the last special legislative committee that reviewed FIPPA back in 2022. That is four
years ago. The report entitled FIPPA for the Future listed 34 recommendations. So, the reason for a six-month hence is to look at how
many of these 34 recommendations were actually thought through or implemented in this
bill. We have rushed this through. We need to slow it down. We need to look at it
again. To improve and modernize access to information and privacy rules in British
Columbia public sector, Bill 9 represents a failure to act on these recommendations.
That's what FIPPA says. So we must delay to look at how the implementation of these
34 recommendations would either strengthen or weaken this legislation. They also bring forward.... "This is the worst than missing the opportunity," said FIPPA
President Mike Larsen. It reflects a pattern of successive governments receiving clear
advice on gaps in the act and then completely disregarding this guidance. Six months
hence allows us to go back to the drawing table and say to these people: "Okay, what
are we missing? How are we missing it? What would make it clearer? What would make
it better?" I think here is a comment they make, which is kind of alarming. Why after the Legislature
wood splitter scandal and the subsequent joint recommendations by B.C. independent
regulators does Bill 9 not extend FIPPA to cover the administrative offices of the
Legislative Assembly? We need to delay in order to ask these questions to review this
document so it makes it stronger.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Regulations
I rise today to speak about Motion M207 and to raise what I believe is a fundamental
issue of fairness, of consistency and common sense in the government's approach to
liquor policy in British Columbia. That is why removing the word "independent" levels
the playing field for all movie theatres across British Columbia. Why not let the
owners decide whether they want to serve liquor or not in their theatres instead of
government restricting certain theatres from doing it? This bill proposes allowing liquor services during mixed-age movie screening for small
and independent theatres. While supporters of the bill argue this is about helping
local cinemas survive, the legislation creates more questions than answers. The central
issue is this. If responsible liquor service during mixed-age movie screenings is
appropriate public policy, then why would the government not apply it to small and
independent theatres instead of all theatres? Why restrict it? Why create another arbitrary distinction? Why would some theatres
be trusted while others are restricted under the exact same circumstances? That's
why removing the word "independent" is clear, and it is fair. Either adults can responsibly consume alcohol while attending a movie with minors
present under regulated provincial laws or not. The standard should not change based
on the size of the building, the number of screens or the business model of the theatre
operator. Who decides these distinctions? Public safety rules should be based on behaviour and standards, not on square footage.
Yet this bill proposes exactly that. One set of rules for some theatres, another set
of rules for others. That is not fairness; that is selective policy-making. That's
why removing the word "independent" is an important legislative change. We already allow liquor services in countless mixed-age environments across British
Columbia. Adults can consume alcohol at restaurants where families dine together.
Adults can drink at concerts attended by minors, at sporting events, at community
festivals, at bowling alleys, at live theatre productions, at conference centres,
at airports. All of those places responsible adults are trusted to consume alcohol
under regulated conditions while minors are present. Importantly, those venues are
not divided into small or large categories before government decides whether liquor
services are acceptable. The rule applies equally. But not to allow small and independent theatres? Why not include all theatres? Removing
the word "independent" clarifies this inconsistency, so why are movie theatres treated
differently? And why does Motion M207 deepen the inconsistency instead of solving
it? This bill risks creating an uneven, distorted playing field across British Columbia's
entertainment industry. A theatre with two or three screens may qualify for expanded liquor permission, while
other theatres with four or five screens down the road remain restricted, despite
serving the same community, operating under the same provincial liquor laws and employing
trained staff allowing the same rules. How does that make sense? How is that fair
competition? And perhaps, most Perhaps, most importantly, where exactly does government draw the line? If a theatre
expands and becomes successful, does it lose its privilege? If a theatre has different
ownership, does it lose its licence? There are problems with legislation built around
arbitrary classifications rather than consistent principles across the board. Businesses across the province are exhausted by government's constant creative carve-outs,
exceptions, pilot projects and selective rules instead of establishing one fair, transparent
framework for all. This bill continues that trend. Instead of modernizing our liquor
policy for all theatres in British Columbia, government proposes another narrow exemption
targeting one category of business.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues
Growing our economy on whose backs? Basic cable, landline phones and yarn — what do
they have in common? These are the new luxury items worthy of being taxed by this
government. Seniors crocheting blankets for their grandchildren. Seniors using the
only phone they have, which is a landline, now have to find money elsewhere, with
the little savings they have left, in order to survive. Why is this government pinching pennies from B.C. seniors?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Legal issues
It's always a privilege to rise in this house to speak. I never take that for granted.
Not only do I represent the citizens of Abbotsford but, I believe, in many ways, the
residents across this province. Please forgive me ahead of time. I've got a head cold, so I'll be coughing and gagging
in between. I rise today to speak to the motion for second reading of Bill 9, entitled Freedom
of Information Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, be amended by deleting the
word "now" and substituting "six months hence." Therefore, it's called the "hoist." The need to pause Bill 9 introduced by the opposition is paramount to getting this
cornerstone legislation to our democracy right. There's a saying, a true saying, that
said there's nothing new under the sun. It's very interesting that on the other side
of the planet, in Australia, they went through the same process here in March. I just want to read this article for you. It's a short couple of brief notes from
it. "A win for democracy: Labor abandons freedom of information laws change that would
have reduced transparency. The Labor government has dumped its controversial changes
to the freedom of information request system, which would have imposed new fees and
further reduced transparency." As we are going through this process, so is the government in Australia going through
the same process. But they saw the light of day. They saw the light of day, and they
pulled it before we got to this point where we're asking to delay it for six months
hence. "The government's changes to the FOI system would have imposed tighter rules
on accessing information, including new grounds to refuse requests based on cabinet
confidentiality" — sounds familiar — "banning anonymous requests" — sounds familiar
— and "rules to deter what the government characterized as vexatious and frivolous
requests." That is why we need to delay implementation of Bill 9 as it stands in order to get
it right this time around, because the bill amends one of the most important statutes
in our province. The act is not administrative housekeeping, as what has been stated.
It is not procedural fine print. It is not bureaucratic technicality. The reason a six-month hence is required because this bill is the backbone of government
transparency and the legal guardian of citizens' privacy rights in British Columbia.
It is the mechanism by which journalists uncover waste. That's why we need six months
to look at and say: "Is this the right bill? Is this going to increase transparency,
or is this going to limit transparency?" It is the tool citizens use to hold government to account. We need a delay to look
at this. It is the safeguard that ensures personal information is not casually collected,
casually shared or casually exposed. Today, Bill 9 weakens both transparency and privacy
at the very same time, and that is precisely why a six-month extension would allow
for a more careful, responsible approach to getting this legislation right. We need a pause of this bill as it stands today because it is not modernization. It
is a shift, a complete shift, a lane change in power. Well, another reason for six months hence is because the B.C. Freedom of Information
and Privacy Association has sent the alarm, and it's reached deaf ears on the other
side. We want to make sure that the delay of six months minimum would allow these people
who understand freedom of information.... Many of these people who crafted the original
document, have deep concerns. Here's one. They're warning that weakens access rights
at a time when government has failed to meaningfully implement its own recordkeeping
law, and that fails to address need for reforms to the act. That is why six months hence is absolutely necessary. That is why six months hence is absolutely necessary. We need to look at those people
and talk to those people who understand freedom of information and say: the amendments,
do they go far enough? Are the amendments too restrictive? How does this change the
intent of the original document to the point where it's ineffective? Number 2, the government has framed the bill as modernization effort to improve digital
service delivery. However, FIPPA notes that the real source of FOI delays is upstream.
It's inconsistent record creation. So it's basically saying here that the amendments
put forth in Bill 9 actually aren't the issue. The issue is record creation, record
classification, record retention and digitization practices across the ministries.
We need to delay this bill in order to review the government's handling of this file
in its entirety. They also say.... "Access delays are often a symptom of recordkeeping failure," said
FIPPA Executive Director Jason Woywada. We cannot fix the system's information management problems by weakening public access
to rights. Another reason for pausing this bill. And we're not talking for an infinite amount of time. It's six months. Would it kill
the bill? We'll see. There are also some glaring absences in Bill 9 that is deeply
flawed because of what it does not include. FIPPA says the bill ignores the work of
the last special legislative committee that reviewed FIPPA back in 2022. That is four
years ago. The report entitled FIPPA for the Future listed 34 recommendations. So, the reason for a six-month hence is to look at how
many of these 34 recommendations were actually thought through or implemented in this
bill. We have rushed this through. We need to slow it down. We need to look at it
again. To improve and modernize access to information and privacy rules in British
Columbia public sector, Bill 9 represents a failure to act on these recommendations.
That's what FIPPA says. So we must delay to look at how the implementation of these
34 recommendations would either strengthen or weaken this legislation. They also bring forward.... "This is the worst than missing the opportunity," said FIPPA
President Mike Larsen. It reflects a pattern of successive governments receiving clear
advice on gaps in the act and then completely disregarding this guidance. Six months
hence allows us to go back to the drawing table and say to these people: "Okay, what
are we missing? How are we missing it? What would make it clearer? What would make
it better?" I think here is a comment they make, which is kind of alarming. Why after the Legislature
wood splitter scandal and the subsequent joint recommendations by B.C. independent
regulators does Bill 9 not extend FIPPA to cover the administrative offices of the
Legislative Assembly? We need to delay in order to ask these questions to review this
document so it makes it stronger.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Telephones
Growing our economy on whose backs? Basic cable, landline phones and yarn — what do
they have in common? These are the new luxury items worthy of being taxed by this
government. Seniors crocheting blankets for their grandchildren. Seniors using the
only phone they have, which is a landline, now have to find money elsewhere, with
the little savings they have left, in order to survive. Why is this government pinching pennies from B.C. seniors?Open source reference