7 recorded contributions
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Businesses, Fundraising
I definitely want to stand up in support of the motion, as well as the amendment.
In my riding, I only have small independent theatres. I appreciate that the member
for Kootenay-Monashee is looking to level the playing field. In my region, I have the Gem Theatre in Grand Forks, as well as the Oliver Theatre
in Oliver. Honestly, they're not competing with other large theatres, so the amendment
doesn't have a lot of impact in my riding, which is why I support it. We should be
enabling businesses in every single way we can to make businesses successful in British
Columbia. If it allows liquor to be served in large theatres in certain circumstances
now, why wouldn't we just make it level? The rules are the same for everybody. The one thing I do want to say is that I don't really understand why this came forward
as a motion. I wish the member had brought it forward as a bill that was actually
going to make change. This motion is kind of a temperature check of the House. I find
it a little hard to see how this is going to impact change and why we're arguing,
unnecessarily, semantics around why the government themselves would be opposed to
just saying "all theatres" and why there's such strong opposition to that in a motion
where we're just checking the temperature in the room. I believe that all businesses need equal rules. When we start trying to figure out
who's small and independent, is it somebody who has three theatres? Are they still
small and independent? What makes them become a not independent theatre? I think just
having a straight "all theatres" rule makes sense to me. I wanted to share that I had a fundraising event in Vernon at the Vernon Towne Theatre
many years ago. It was for the Lumby Mabel Lake Snowmobile Association. They were
doing a screening of a local snowmobile movie. One of the challenges we had at that
particular theatre was getting people to attend, getting the 20- to 25-year-olds to
come out and participate in a fundraising event when we weren't able to provide any
alcohol at the event. We ended up having to rent the entire theatre and get a liquor
license and having to do it as a special event venue. I do support the member's motion in removing those barriers. I definitely feel like....
Like I said, I just wish it had come forward as a bill that was actually going to
make an impact for my theatres in my region. Doing this temperature check, to me,
feels kind of.... I wish it was more. I guess, I'll say that. I wish that we were actually
making a change for my theatres. I do appreciate that Kootenay-Monashee is probably in a similar position to me, where he has only independent theatres,
and I believe that's probably why there is the wording of his motion the way it is.
But I don't see omitting "all theatres" like we have in the amendment as a negative.
I think it just creates a temperature check in the room that we support small business,
and we support all small business and large business in British Columbia on an even
playing field. I do think that whether alcohol should be served or not is kind of a non-issue. I
believe that we have laws and rules in British Columbia. We've had other members speak
to being able to lawfully drink in hockey arenas and other venues. I know that in
Oliver, regularly, in their arts theatre, they are able to serve some great Oliver,
B.C., wine as part of their showing and as part of your evening out on those particular
events. I believe that this isn't about whether drinking is responsible or not. I believe
that we have the laws in place and we have precedents all over the place. The fact
that these independent theatres have not been able to take advantage of that, I think,
is why this member has brought forward this motion. I also think that we I believe that this isn't about whether drinking is responsible or not. I believe
that we have the laws in place, and we have precedents all over the place. The fact
that these independent theatres have not been able to take advantage of that, I think,
is why this member has brought forward this motion. I also think that we just want to ensure that there's flexibility in the business
model for all businesses. I agree with the other member that this gets people out.
It gets them.... They go out for dinner. They make it an evening. They might actually
do something else while they're out. In small towns, quite often, once we get home,
not much is open. We end up tending to kind of find at-home pursuits. So I support
anything that gets people outside in their community and being part of their community. But I do support the amendment and want all businesses to be on an equal playing field.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Budgets, Public finance
This government has a dismal record and already has the most projects with cost overruns
in B.C.'s history, yet this Finance Minister has decided to try and balance her budget
by taxing her own government. Applying PST to provincial infrastructure projects doesn't
balance the budget, and it doesn't make these projects any more affordable for British
Columbians. A simple question to the minister. Did government exempt themselves from their own
PST expansion, yes or no?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Negotiations
I appreciate the opportunity to rise today to speak to this motion to refer Bill 20,
the K'ómoks Treaty Act, to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I was very excited when I was appointed to that committee when I first came to this
building and was equally disappointed when I realized that they have not met in over
20-something years. At a time in this province where Indigenous relations is at an
all-time high, you would think that this cross-party committee would be doing the
important work needed for British Columbians. Similar to my first speech, I want to be clear that I support treaty. I do believe
it is the way forward. I shared in that speech how I felt disappointed in the treaty,
the way it came forward and some of the language that was chosen to be included in
that treaty. I think that this motion allows us to go away and correct that, to allow
the people of K'ómoks, who have invested 30 years — as the member for Nechako shared, generations — into getting to this day. But we can't stand here today and pretend that this treaty is operating in isolation
of other things happening in our province. We have a Premier who has had five plans
in five weeks about what he's doing with DRIPA. We have legal challenges. We have
U.S. tribes that are pushing in. We have all of these happening at the same time that
this government has chosen this moment in time to bring these treaties forward in
that landscape. To me, it was a disservice to the people of K'ómoks, Kitselas, and Kitsumkalum eventually. I believe that this is.... Nechako mentioned it is an olive branch. I think this is
the olive branch. I think this is an opportunity for us to come together across party
lines and find a durable solution forward. Yes, I did use the word "durable," which
has been driving me nuts all week, but I will use it in this particular case. The reason that it's important is because Bill 20 is not an ordinary bill. This is
a treaty. It brings into force the modern treaty. This is not the modern treaties
that we've seen to date. There's language included in these treaties that is new and
different than any treaty we've seen before, specifically the fact that it is a living
agreement and that that living agreement demands some scrutiny. When I did my first speech here on this particular bill, I spoke about how I felt
I had a responsibility, that Wei Wai Kum and other members of the Island brought forward their concerns. I agreed during that
ceremony to bring those concerns forward and read them into the record, which I did.
I believe that I did honour that commitment. But by using the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs, it allows them to
read their own story into the record. It's not me reading it into the record for them.
It allows us to hear from those nations, to understand the concerns. It allows us
to have discussions around governance, around land harvesting rights, around resource
development and how that has impacts on neighbouring nations and what that looks like
going forward. It allows that testimony to come in as evidence. It allows public submissions. It
allows direct testimony from affected parties on all sides. It allows us to have detailed
questions and conversations, and it creates that transparent public record. While there was extensive consultation done in the Comox area, around the K'ómoks treaty, the fact that this treaty is new and different sets the precedent for all other
treaties in the province. I believe that other British Columbians want to participate
and have a say in what these treaties look like going forward. For me, this isn't about being obstructive. It is not about For me, this isn't about being obstructive. It's not about standing here and filibustering.
For me, it's about due diligence, and I believe that this committee allows us to do
that due diligence to come to a solution. I think, frankly, if government feels confident
in both the treaty and the process that got us here today, they should welcome this
opportunity to make it public and not be seen as a threat. It should be viewed as
an opportunity. I think that opportunity is to strengthen public confidence to try to undo some of
the damage this government has done in creating any Indigenous sentiment across this
province. It allows us to go and work in a cross-party way to find solutions for this
treaty and the future treaties that will follow. I think they will succeed, because we have to have confidence in the process, and
to date, I don't think that confidence exists, and that is why people are looking
for a new way forward. That's why this motion was brought forward to send it to the
Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I look forward to being part of that
committee, and I look forward to being part of that work. I have spoken previously in this chamber about why treaties matter, and I want to
be equally clear again today that I support modern treaties, but there is language
in these treaties that I cannot support. That really, really hurts my heart for both
the K'ómoks People, who have put so much time and energy into it, and the other nations that will
follow with future treaties. I support that treaties are supposed to create greater certainty for Indigenous nations,
governments, communities and British Columbians, and that has always been my position.
I have always said that I believe treaties are the way forward. I shared in my last
speech.... I shared with somebody that I really hoped that these treaties were something
I could get behind, because this is what I want for the future of British Columbia. But these treaties have language in them that is very concerning. It is clear that
there is work still to be done. There are unclear overlaps between neighbouring nations
that have brought that forward. I think that we have the ability, through the standing
committee, to hear those voices, implement them into the decision and find a direction
forward. I feel like it will create an avenue to bring forward legitimate concerns that I feel,
today, perhaps have been unheard. I think that it will increase transparency in the
treaty process and engage British Columbians in a direction forward. I believe that
it could prevent us from just going back to court. While we are trying to do a treaty with K'ómoks and we're creating certainty for K'ómoks, at the same time, we're creating uncertainty with neighbouring nations. There has
been very strong language used by the neighbouring nations around their concerns that
they've brought forward. Those court challenges could just tie us up even further. The Premier has shared,
though he has yet to name, the 20 court cases that exist today. Are we looking to
add to that number, or are we looking to find solutions? By moving this to a standing committee, we can find solutions. It doesn't just shift
that uncertainty into the future, onto a different nation. It allows the playing fields
to level. We're not, as a legislature, being forced to pick one nation over another
and trying to validate whether those claims are valid or not. Their claims need to
be on the record, and the select standing committee provides that opportunity for
them to come onto the record. I think that we need to find a way, and thank you to the member for Langley–Walnut Grove that brought this motion forward, because I think the standing committee is the way,
and it is a way for us to move forward. I think it creates a process for the concerns
to be heard, and I believe that it provides an opportunity for all of this to come
onto the record in public. I don't have to stand here and read other people's concerns
into the record for them. They can come and share their concerns themselves. I think we need to be really clear that Bill 20 is not regular legislation. This is,
honestly, life-changing legislation for K'ómoks, but it could be life-changing for the neighbouring nations as well. It could permanently
pull them down in a way that they can't get back up. We need to figure out a way forward,
and we need to hear those concerns, and the select standing committee would provide
that opportunity. If this agreement took decades to negotiate, which we know it did.... I shared this
before. Why is the Legislature now rushing to get this to the finish line? We have
eight days left in the legislation, and I think it is our role to get that to the
finish line. I think the select standing committee will do that, and I hope that the
members on all sides of the House will support I think the select standing committee will do that, and I hope that the members on
all sides of the House will support this motion to move this to a select standing
committee.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Small businesses, Tourism
I rise today to speak about something I'm hearing with increasing frequency from across
British Columbia. That's from small business owners, tourism operators, ranchers,
tenure holders, resource users and ordinary British Columbians simply trying to navigate
government. That is this. The Ministry of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship appears increasingly frozen in place, not because staff do not care and not because
applicants are failing to do the work but because government has created a system
where staff themselves seem unclear on what the rules actually are. British Columbians are trying to renew land tenures. They're applying for foreshore
leases. They're advancing their water licence applications. They're moving projects
forward that should be straightforward. Instead, they find themselves trapped in a
bureaucratic purgatory. Months become years. Files sit untouched. Applicants receive
vague responses like "more engagement required," "further information needed," "additional
studies may be necessary." But there's no clear pathway to resolution, no certainty,
no timelines and no actual decision-making. Increasingly, what I hear is this. If you don't arrive with letters of support already
in hand from every potentially affected First Nation, your file will simply just sit
there — not because legislation clearly says that, not because a formal decision has
been made, but because staff no longer seem confident in what standard applies. Is
it consultation? Is it consent? Is it something else entirely? Because of that uncertainty,
files are simply left to drift. That is not reconciliation, and that is not transparency.
It certainly is not good governance. So let me be clear. Meaningful consultation with Indigenous communities matters. Respectful
engagement matters. Strong relationships matter. But what does not serve anyone, including
First Nations, is a provincial government that refuses to provide clear direction
to its own public service. What happens when government staff are left without clarity? Applicants are sent chasing
their tails, more reports are commissioned, more studies are required, and more procedural
hoops are created. When frustration inevitably grows, government quietly allows the
perception to form that Indigenous consultation is the cause for this delay. That
is deeply unfair because in many of these cases, the real issue is not consultation That is deeply unfair, because in many of these cases, the real issue is not consultation.
It is provincial indecision. It is a ministry that no longer appears confident in
its own authority to make decisions. We have watched this shift over time from consultation
to discussions around consent and now increasingly towards a model that is true co-governance. Whether members support that evolution or not, one thing should be obvious. Government
has a responsibility to clearly define how British Columbia continues to function,
how business continues, how applications move, how decisions get made, what the timelines
are. Because right now, that clarity does not exist, and sectors are feeling it. During estimates this year, we heard directly that stakeholders in the adventure tourism
sector, operators whose livelihoods depend on access, renewal and predictable approvals,
are stalled. And the solution? A dedicated single window process just for them to
navigate government dysfunction. Think about that. An entire sector now believes that the only way to survive is to
create a special access point into government that goes around the regular system
that no longer functions. Surprisingly, government has agreed to this. They've stood
up the mechanisms to do just that — help one sector try to move while thousands of
other applicants will remain stuck in the same broken queue. Small operators, farmers, community groups, businesses, families, people trying to
renew what they already hold. People are simply asking for a decision — not special
treatment, just a decision. This is becoming a competitiveness issue, an affordability
issue and a true survival issue for small businesses in British Columbia. Uncertainty
kills investment, and bureaucratic paralysis destroys trust. British Columbians should
not need consultants, political intervention or insider navigation just to get a basic
government file processed. At the narrows in Sicamous, one applicant has spent years and hundreds of thousands
of dollars just trying to rebuild his dock that sits amongst hundreds of other docks.
Its own staff doesn't appear to have the proper training, understand the proper process,
and it owes applicants clear expectations. I believe that it owes First Nations a process that is respectful, transparent and
not its political cover for provincial dysfunction. Because right now what we're seeing
is not leadership; it is paralysis, and British Columbians are paying the price.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Provincial governments
This government has a dismal record and already has the most projects with cost overruns
in B.C.'s history, yet this Finance Minister has decided to try and balance her budget
by taxing her own government. Applying PST to provincial infrastructure projects doesn't
balance the budget, and it doesn't make these projects any more affordable for British
Columbians. A simple question to the minister. Did government exempt themselves from their own
PST expansion, yes or no?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Provincial governments, Public administration, Public service, Regulations
I rise today to speak about something I'm hearing with increasing frequency from across
British Columbia. That's from small business owners, tourism operators, ranchers,
tenure holders, resource users and ordinary British Columbians simply trying to navigate
government. That is this. The Ministry of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship appears increasingly frozen in place, not because staff do not care and not because
applicants are failing to do the work but because government has created a system
where staff themselves seem unclear on what the rules actually are. British Columbians are trying to renew land tenures. They're applying for foreshore
leases. They're advancing their water licence applications. They're moving projects
forward that should be straightforward. Instead, they find themselves trapped in a
bureaucratic purgatory. Months become years. Files sit untouched. Applicants receive
vague responses like "more engagement required," "further information needed," "additional
studies may be necessary." But there's no clear pathway to resolution, no certainty,
no timelines and no actual decision-making. Increasingly, what I hear is this. If you don't arrive with letters of support already
in hand from every potentially affected First Nation, your file will simply just sit
there — not because legislation clearly says that, not because a formal decision has
been made, but because staff no longer seem confident in what standard applies. Is
it consultation? Is it consent? Is it something else entirely? Because of that uncertainty,
files are simply left to drift. That is not reconciliation, and that is not transparency.
It certainly is not good governance. So let me be clear. Meaningful consultation with Indigenous communities matters. Respectful
engagement matters. Strong relationships matter. But what does not serve anyone, including
First Nations, is a provincial government that refuses to provide clear direction
to its own public service. What happens when government staff are left without clarity? Applicants are sent chasing
their tails, more reports are commissioned, more studies are required, and more procedural
hoops are created. When frustration inevitably grows, government quietly allows the
perception to form that Indigenous consultation is the cause for this delay. That
is deeply unfair because in many of these cases, the real issue is not consultation That is deeply unfair, because in many of these cases, the real issue is not consultation.
It is provincial indecision. It is a ministry that no longer appears confident in
its own authority to make decisions. We have watched this shift over time from consultation
to discussions around consent and now increasingly towards a model that is true co-governance. Whether members support that evolution or not, one thing should be obvious. Government
has a responsibility to clearly define how British Columbia continues to function,
how business continues, how applications move, how decisions get made, what the timelines
are. Because right now, that clarity does not exist, and sectors are feeling it. During estimates this year, we heard directly that stakeholders in the adventure tourism
sector, operators whose livelihoods depend on access, renewal and predictable approvals,
are stalled. And the solution? A dedicated single window process just for them to
navigate government dysfunction. Think about that. An entire sector now believes that the only way to survive is to
create a special access point into government that goes around the regular system
that no longer functions. Surprisingly, government has agreed to this. They've stood
up the mechanisms to do just that — help one sector try to move while thousands of
other applicants will remain stuck in the same broken queue. Small operators, farmers, community groups, businesses, families, people trying to
renew what they already hold. People are simply asking for a decision — not special
treatment, just a decision. This is becoming a competitiveness issue, an affordability
issue and a true survival issue for small businesses in British Columbia. Uncertainty
kills investment, and bureaucratic paralysis destroys trust. British Columbians should
not need consultants, political intervention or insider navigation just to get a basic
government file processed. At the narrows in Sicamous, one applicant has spent years and hundreds of thousands
of dollars just trying to rebuild his dock that sits amongst hundreds of other docks.
Its own staff doesn't appear to have the proper training, understand the proper process,
and it owes applicants clear expectations. I believe that it owes First Nations a process that is respectful, transparent and
not its political cover for provincial dysfunction. Because right now what we're seeing
is not leadership; it is paralysis, and British Columbians are paying the price.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public service
I would also like to make a few comments about the report. The committee's spring meeting with statutory officers was a really important opportunity
to receive operational updates from each of the offices and hear about what their
key priorities and focus areas are going to be for the coming year. This year, the committee also asked for updates regarding the corporate shared services The committee's spring meeting with statutory officers was a really important opportunity
to receive operational updates from each of the offices and hear about what their
key priorities and focus areas are going to be for the coming year. This year the
committee also asked for updates regarding the corporate shared service agreements,
office space and lease agreements and grants that were being administered by the offices. Committee members continue to encourage our statutory officers to examine these areas
of focus and other areas to find savings and efficiencies as they prepare for their
budget requests for this fall. I'd like to extend my appreciation to all the statutory officers for taking the time
to meet with us and for their valuable work for all British Columbians. I would also
like to acknowledge the members of the committee for their hard work and the staff
of the Parliamentary Committees Office for supporting our work, as well as Hansard. In closing, I would like to thank all of the committee for their work, and I look
forward to heading out for public consultation on this year's coming budget.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Theatre
I definitely want to stand up in support of the motion, as well as the amendment.
In my riding, I only have small independent theatres. I appreciate that the member
for Kootenay-Monashee is looking to level the playing field. In my region, I have the Gem Theatre in Grand Forks, as well as the Oliver Theatre
in Oliver. Honestly, they're not competing with other large theatres, so the amendment
doesn't have a lot of impact in my riding, which is why I support it. We should be
enabling businesses in every single way we can to make businesses successful in British
Columbia. If it allows liquor to be served in large theatres in certain circumstances
now, why wouldn't we just make it level? The rules are the same for everybody. The one thing I do want to say is that I don't really understand why this came forward
as a motion. I wish the member had brought it forward as a bill that was actually
going to make change. This motion is kind of a temperature check of the House. I find
it a little hard to see how this is going to impact change and why we're arguing,
unnecessarily, semantics around why the government themselves would be opposed to
just saying "all theatres" and why there's such strong opposition to that in a motion
where we're just checking the temperature in the room. I believe that all businesses need equal rules. When we start trying to figure out
who's small and independent, is it somebody who has three theatres? Are they still
small and independent? What makes them become a not independent theatre? I think just
having a straight "all theatres" rule makes sense to me. I wanted to share that I had a fundraising event in Vernon at the Vernon Towne Theatre
many years ago. It was for the Lumby Mabel Lake Snowmobile Association. They were
doing a screening of a local snowmobile movie. One of the challenges we had at that
particular theatre was getting people to attend, getting the 20- to 25-year-olds to
come out and participate in a fundraising event when we weren't able to provide any
alcohol at the event. We ended up having to rent the entire theatre and get a liquor
license and having to do it as a special event venue. I do support the member's motion in removing those barriers. I definitely feel like....
Like I said, I just wish it had come forward as a bill that was actually going to
make an impact for my theatres in my region. Doing this temperature check, to me,
feels kind of.... I wish it was more. I guess, I'll say that. I wish that we were actually
making a change for my theatres. I do appreciate that Kootenay-Monashee is probably in a similar position to me, where he has only independent theatres,
and I believe that's probably why there is the wording of his motion the way it is.
But I don't see omitting "all theatres" like we have in the amendment as a negative.
I think it just creates a temperature check in the room that we support small business,
and we support all small business and large business in British Columbia on an even
playing field. I do think that whether alcohol should be served or not is kind of a non-issue. I
believe that we have laws and rules in British Columbia. We've had other members speak
to being able to lawfully drink in hockey arenas and other venues. I know that in
Oliver, regularly, in their arts theatre, they are able to serve some great Oliver,
B.C., wine as part of their showing and as part of your evening out on those particular
events. I believe that this isn't about whether drinking is responsible or not. I believe
that we have the laws in place and we have precedents all over the place. The fact
that these independent theatres have not been able to take advantage of that, I think,
is why this member has brought forward this motion. I also think that we I believe that this isn't about whether drinking is responsible or not. I believe
that we have the laws in place, and we have precedents all over the place. The fact
that these independent theatres have not been able to take advantage of that, I think,
is why this member has brought forward this motion. I also think that we just want to ensure that there's flexibility in the business
model for all businesses. I agree with the other member that this gets people out.
It gets them.... They go out for dinner. They make it an evening. They might actually
do something else while they're out. In small towns, quite often, once we get home,
not much is open. We end up tending to kind of find at-home pursuits. So I support
anything that gets people outside in their community and being part of their community. But I do support the amendment and want all businesses to be on an equal playing field.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Hockey, Sports, Sports events
I rise today to recognize the incredible playoff run of our Princeton Posse. Over
the past few weeks, the excitement has been building. Our community watched with pride
as this team fought its way to the Kootenay International Junior A Hockey League finals,
then carried our region all the way to game seven to a double-overtime finish. That's
not just hockey. That is heart, that is resilience, and that is what small communities
do best. On behalf of myself and the member for Columbia River–Revelstoke, I want to extend a congratulations to the Kimberley Dynamiters on a win they truly
earned. Over the last few weeks, we've enjoyed connecting after every game to cheer
our teams on in a little fun. But kidding aside, a game seven double-overtime finish
reflects the determination and the skill of both teams, and it was a series worth
watching to the very end. The Princeton Posse represented Princeton and the entire Boundary-Similkameen region with determination and class right to the final shift. They carried forward
a proud hockey tradition in a town where our arena remains a gathering place for our
whole community. Runs like this don't happen by accident. They happen because of coaches who led, volunteers
who organized, billets who opened their homes, families who travel thousands of kilometres
and get up early, early hours, donations that help pay the bills and put gas on the
bus and fans who packed the arena to believe in their team. But most of all, they
happen because of players who chose to represent a small town with big pride. To the Princeton Posse, thank you. I am proud to stand here today and say that across
Boundary-Similkameen, we are all proud of how you represented our region with grit, with heart and with
everything that defines small-town British Columbia.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Parks
A few weeks ago, the Minister of Environment said: "We're going to continue to make
sure that our B.C. parks have access for everyone." Since then, she has announced
that Joffre Lakes Provincial Park will be closedOpen source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Indigenous affairs
I appreciate the opportunity to rise today to speak to this motion to refer Bill 20,
the K'ómoks Treaty Act, to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I was very excited when I was appointed to that committee when I first came to this
building and was equally disappointed when I realized that they have not met in over
20-something years. At a time in this province where Indigenous relations is at an
all-time high, you would think that this cross-party committee would be doing the
important work needed for British Columbians. Similar to my first speech, I want to be clear that I support treaty. I do believe
it is the way forward. I shared in that speech how I felt disappointed in the treaty,
the way it came forward and some of the language that was chosen to be included in
that treaty. I think that this motion allows us to go away and correct that, to allow
the people of K'ómoks, who have invested 30 years — as the member for Nechako shared, generations — into getting to this day. But we can't stand here today and pretend that this treaty is operating in isolation
of other things happening in our province. We have a Premier who has had five plans
in five weeks about what he's doing with DRIPA. We have legal challenges. We have
U.S. tribes that are pushing in. We have all of these happening at the same time that
this government has chosen this moment in time to bring these treaties forward in
that landscape. To me, it was a disservice to the people of K'ómoks, Kitselas, and Kitsumkalum eventually. I believe that this is.... Nechako mentioned it is an olive branch. I think this is
the olive branch. I think this is an opportunity for us to come together across party
lines and find a durable solution forward. Yes, I did use the word "durable," which
has been driving me nuts all week, but I will use it in this particular case. The reason that it's important is because Bill 20 is not an ordinary bill. This is
a treaty. It brings into force the modern treaty. This is not the modern treaties
that we've seen to date. There's language included in these treaties that is new and
different than any treaty we've seen before, specifically the fact that it is a living
agreement and that that living agreement demands some scrutiny. When I did my first speech here on this particular bill, I spoke about how I felt
I had a responsibility, that Wei Wai Kum and other members of the Island brought forward their concerns. I agreed during that
ceremony to bring those concerns forward and read them into the record, which I did.
I believe that I did honour that commitment. But by using the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs, it allows them to
read their own story into the record. It's not me reading it into the record for them.
It allows us to hear from those nations, to understand the concerns. It allows us
to have discussions around governance, around land harvesting rights, around resource
development and how that has impacts on neighbouring nations and what that looks like
going forward. It allows that testimony to come in as evidence. It allows public submissions. It
allows direct testimony from affected parties on all sides. It allows us to have detailed
questions and conversations, and it creates that transparent public record. While there was extensive consultation done in the Comox area, around the K'ómoks treaty, the fact that this treaty is new and different sets the precedent for all other
treaties in the province. I believe that other British Columbians want to participate
and have a say in what these treaties look like going forward. For me, this isn't about being obstructive. It is not about For me, this isn't about being obstructive. It's not about standing here and filibustering.
For me, it's about due diligence, and I believe that this committee allows us to do
that due diligence to come to a solution. I think, frankly, if government feels confident
in both the treaty and the process that got us here today, they should welcome this
opportunity to make it public and not be seen as a threat. It should be viewed as
an opportunity. I think that opportunity is to strengthen public confidence to try to undo some of
the damage this government has done in creating any Indigenous sentiment across this
province. It allows us to go and work in a cross-party way to find solutions for this
treaty and the future treaties that will follow. I think they will succeed, because we have to have confidence in the process, and
to date, I don't think that confidence exists, and that is why people are looking
for a new way forward. That's why this motion was brought forward to send it to the
Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I look forward to being part of that
committee, and I look forward to being part of that work. I have spoken previously in this chamber about why treaties matter, and I want to
be equally clear again today that I support modern treaties, but there is language
in these treaties that I cannot support. That really, really hurts my heart for both
the K'ómoks People, who have put so much time and energy into it, and the other nations that will
follow with future treaties. I support that treaties are supposed to create greater certainty for Indigenous nations,
governments, communities and British Columbians, and that has always been my position.
I have always said that I believe treaties are the way forward. I shared in my last
speech.... I shared with somebody that I really hoped that these treaties were something
I could get behind, because this is what I want for the future of British Columbia. But these treaties have language in them that is very concerning. It is clear that
there is work still to be done. There are unclear overlaps between neighbouring nations
that have brought that forward. I think that we have the ability, through the standing
committee, to hear those voices, implement them into the decision and find a direction
forward. I feel like it will create an avenue to bring forward legitimate concerns that I feel,
today, perhaps have been unheard. I think that it will increase transparency in the
treaty process and engage British Columbians in a direction forward. I believe that
it could prevent us from just going back to court. While we are trying to do a treaty with K'ómoks and we're creating certainty for K'ómoks, at the same time, we're creating uncertainty with neighbouring nations. There has
been very strong language used by the neighbouring nations around their concerns that
they've brought forward. Those court challenges could just tie us up even further. The Premier has shared,
though he has yet to name, the 20 court cases that exist today. Are we looking to
add to that number, or are we looking to find solutions? By moving this to a standing committee, we can find solutions. It doesn't just shift
that uncertainty into the future, onto a different nation. It allows the playing fields
to level. We're not, as a legislature, being forced to pick one nation over another
and trying to validate whether those claims are valid or not. Their claims need to
be on the record, and the select standing committee provides that opportunity for
them to come onto the record. I think that we need to find a way, and thank you to the member for Langley–Walnut Grove that brought this motion forward, because I think the standing committee is the way,
and it is a way for us to move forward. I think it creates a process for the concerns
to be heard, and I believe that it provides an opportunity for all of this to come
onto the record in public. I don't have to stand here and read other people's concerns
into the record for them. They can come and share their concerns themselves. I think we need to be really clear that Bill 20 is not regular legislation. This is,
honestly, life-changing legislation for K'ómoks, but it could be life-changing for the neighbouring nations as well. It could permanently
pull them down in a way that they can't get back up. We need to figure out a way forward,
and we need to hear those concerns, and the select standing committee would provide
that opportunity. If this agreement took decades to negotiate, which we know it did.... I shared this
before. Why is the Legislature now rushing to get this to the finish line? We have
eight days left in the legislation, and I think it is our role to get that to the
finish line. I think the select standing committee will do that, and I hope that the
members on all sides of the House will support I think the select standing committee will do that, and I hope that the members on
all sides of the House will support this motion to move this to a select standing
committee.Open source reference