4 recorded contributions · Small sample
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Legal issues
I'm pleased to rise in this House to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and
Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. At the outset, I wanted to say this plainly: access to information is not a courtesy
that government extends when it's convenient. It is not a favour. It's not a privilege
reserved for those who know how to navigate bureaucracy, hire experts or wait months
on end while their request disappears into the machinery of government. Access to information is a democratic right. It's one of the few practical tools ordinary
people have to hold government accountable between elections. That is why Bill 9 matters.
And that is why the government's framing of this bill is so difficult to accept. We are told that this legislation is about efficiency. We are told it's about modernization.
We are told it's about improving the experience of British Columbians engaging with
government. Those are fine words. They sound polished. They sound reassuring. But
when one looks past the talking points and reads the actual text of the bill, a different
picture emerges. What this bill really does, in several important respects, is make it easier for government
to delay, easier for government to reject and easier for government to charge people
for access to information that should, by all reason and principle, remain accessible.
That is not transparency. That is not modernization. It's certainly not accountability. Freedom-of-information legislation exists because government records do not belong
to the government of the day in any moral sense. Those records are created using public
dollars by public bodies in the course of public administration. Ministers may sit
on those benches for a few years. Staff may rotate in and out. When a resident wants to know how a decision was made, when a journalist wants to
investigate waste, when a researcher wants to understand government process, when
a municipality wants answers, when a family wants records tied to an issue affecting
their lives, they should not be met with more obstacles. They should not be met with
more discretion in the hands of the very institutions they are trying to scrutinize.
They should not be priced out of information. They should not be treated as a burden
simply for asking questions. But that is the direction Bill 9 takes us. Let us begin with one of the clearest examples of the bill. That's clause 3. Clause
3 changes the obligation on a public body to respond to an access request without
delay and replaces it with a duty to respond without unreasonable delay. Now, on first
hearing, some may say that's only a small wording change, but members of this House
know full well that legislation wording is never casual. Words are chosen carefully
because words create standards, and standards shape behaviour. "Without delay" is a firm expectation. It is clear. It tells the public body that
time matters. It tells the applicant that the law recognizes urgency. It tells everyone
involved that records should not simply sit idle because government is busy, disorganized
or politically uncomfortable with disclosure. "Without unreasonable delay" is softer. It's more elastic. It leaves far more room
for justification, more room for interpretation, more room for excuses. What is unreasonable
to the applicant may appear entirely reasonable to an office already accustomed to
backlog. What is unreasonable to the public may appear acceptable to a government
that has grown comfortable with delay. That is the problem. British Columbians are already frustrated by slow response times
in the FOI system. They are already dealing with a process that can feel distant,
drawn out and opaque. The answer to that problem is not to lower the legal standard owed to them. The answer
is to improve performance. The answer is to ensure proper staffing, clear procedures
and a culture that treats disclosure as the rule, not the exception. Government should
be working to speed up the system, not legislate the slowdown into more acceptable
language. Then we come to clause 2, which is also deeply concerning. Clause 2 changes section
5 so that an FOI request must, in the opinion of the head of the public body, provide
enough detail to enable an experienced employee, with reasonable effort in a reasonable
amount of time, to identify the record sought. Again, that wording matters. "In the opinion of the head of the public body," "reasonable
effort," "reasonable amount of time" — who defines those things? Who decides when
the request is detailed enough? Who decides when the amount of time spent searching
is too much? Who decides whether the request is sufficiently precise, especially when
the applicant may not know exactly what records exist in the first place? This House should remember that many people file FOI requests precisely because they
do not already have a full picture. They're seeking clarity. They're trying to identify
what happened, who said what, what records exist, what advice was given, what emails
or briefing materials are on file. They're not always in a position to provide a perfectly
narrow or tailored request on the first attempt, nor should they be expected to know
the internal filing systems, terminology or administrative practices of every ministry,
agency and public body in the province. That is why the law should lean toward helping the applicant, not screening them out.
But this bill leans the other way. It shifts more discretion towards the institution.
It makes the opinion of the public body's head more central. It introduces vague standards
that can easily become barriers. It increases the chances that a request can be pushed
back, narrowed, delayed or treated as defective before the applicant has even had
a fair chance to obtain the records. And what will this mean in practice? It'll mean more frustration for people who are
already trying to navigate an intimidating process. It'll mean more correspondence
back and forth over wording instead of substance. It will mean more opportunities
for delay. And when people see that happening over and over again, their confidence
in the system deteriorates. Our freedom-of-information regime only works if people
believe it is A freedom-of-information regime only works if people believe it is real. It only works
if they believe that when they ask a legitimate question, they will receive fair treatment
and a lawful disclosure. Once people begin to suspect that every ambiguity in the
law will be read in favour of government convenience, then the right still exists
on paper but becomes weaker in practice. That is why clause 13 is so significant. Clause 13 expands the grounds upon which
the commissioner may authorize a public body to disregard a request. It adds the behaviour
of the applicant being abusive or malicious and broadens the language concerning requests
that would unreasonably interfere with the operations of the public body or the government
of British Columbia. It also refers to requests that are repetitive, systematic, or
excessively broad. Now, let us be careful here. No one is arguing that truly bad-faith conduct should
be tolerated. No system can function properly if it is deliberately weaponized against
public servants or used as a means of harassment. There must be safeguards against
genuine abuse. But safeguards must be clear, narrow and carefully constrained. This clause is not that. Instead, it introduces broad language without meaningful
definition in the bill itself. Once again, that should concern every member of this
House, because vague terms can become elastic terms, and elastic terms are very often
used to the advantage of those already holding power. What is abusive? What is malicious? Does that mean a request that is angry in tone?
A request filed after months of government silence? A request by someone who has asked
too many uncomfortable questions? A request by a journalist following a story government
wishes to go away? And what about unreasonable interference with operations of government? That is a
particularly troubling phrase. Would a broad request into the Premier's office be
said to interfere with operations? Would multiple requests into major procurement
decisions be deemed systematic? Would opposition researchers, journalists, advocacy
organizations or municipal leaders be told their efforts amount to a burden on government
rather than an exercise in democratic oversight? These are not far-fetched questions. They are the obvious questions that arise when
legislation uses broad language and leaves the boundaries unclear. If the government
wanted merely to target truly vexatious conduct, it would have drafted narrow, well-defined
provisions. Instead, it has chosen language that opens the door much wider. That is
the concern. And British Columbians are right to be concerned when a government that
already struggles with transparency seeks broader authority to disregard requests. Accountability is often inconvenient. That is simply the nature of accountability.
It takes time to answer questions. It takes effort to gather records. It requires
a willingness to endure scrutiny. But inconvenience to government is not the same
thing as abuse by the applicant. The right to ask hard questions is not an administrative flaw. It is one of the essential
features of a functioning democracy. If government finds public scrutiny burdensome,
the answer is not to weaken access rights. The answer is to govern in a way that can
withstand scrutiny. I also want to speak to clause 21, because it represents one of the clearest examples
of this government taking something that should be easier and making it harder. Clause
21 allows the head of a public body to require a person who asks for a copy of a record
that is otherwise available under protective disclosure to pay a fee. That is astonishing. These are records that government itself says should be available
without a formal access request. That is the whole point of proactive disclosure.
It's supposed to mean less friction, fewer obstacles, more openness and easier public
access. It's supposed to reduce the need for formal FOI filings by making records
accessible up front. But under this bill, government can now say: "Yes, the record is available, but you
may have to pay for it." That is not proactive disclosure in any meaningful public
sense. That is restricted access dressed up in a modern language. Let us be honest about who feels these kinds of changes most. It's not the large institution
with in-house counsel, not the ministry with taxpayer-funded staff, not the government
with all the records and all the procedural leverage. It is the ordinary person. It
is the local journalist on a tight budget. It is the resident trying to get information
about a matter affecting their family or community. It's the volunteer group. It's the student researcher. It is the taxpayer who already
paid once for the creation of the record and is now being asked to pay again to receive
it. The government may say these fees are modest, but a barrier does not have to be enormous
to be effective. Sometimes all it takes is one more step The government may say these fees are modest, but a barrier does not have to be enormous
to be effective. Sometimes all it takes is one more step, one more charge, one more
discouragement, and people walk away. That is especially true in a system that is
already slow and already difficult for many people to navigate. I would remind this House that that is not happening in a vacuum. British Columbians
have seen this government move before in ways that reduce access to information rather
than expand it. So when this bill arrives with new fees, broader refusal grounds and
weaker timing language, people notice the pattern. They notice that "free" is generally
being taken out of "freedom of information." This government speaks often about trust. It speaks often about service delivery.
It speaks often about people-centred systems. Those are nice phrases, but trust is
not built through slogans. It is built through conduct. It is built when government
answers questions instead of dodging them. It is built when disclosure is timely,
instead of delayed. It is built when access is broad, instead of narrow. It is built
when rights are strengthened, instead of qualified away. On that test, Bill 9 does
not meet that standard. There's another feature of this bill that deserves careful examination. That is the
growing use of information-sharing powers and centralized service mechanisms without
sufficient public explanation. Clause 12 permits the commissioner to exchange information
and enter into information-sharing agreements with commissioners in other jurisdictions.
What jurisdictions? Clause 20 establishes what is called a "connected services provider" and authorizes
the minister to designate a public body for that role, with powers relating to online
platforms, data sharing between public bodies, identifying services for which a person
may be eligible, and other services the minister considers appropriate. Now, no one in this chamber is opposed to technology being used wisely. No one is
opposed to making public services easier to navigate. If a resident can access multiple
services through one platform, that may be beneficial. If systems can be modernized
responsibly, that may be beneficial. If duplication can be reduced while privacy is
preserved, that may be also beneficial. Legislation must be judged not by aspiration
alone but by powers it grants. What powers are being granted here? The minister may designate a connected services
provider. The minister may direct what type and quantity of personal information is
shared. The minister may direct formats of sharing. The minister may determine sources
of data. The minister may issue different directions for different classes of persons,
public bodies or categories of personal information. Those are substantial powers. When government centralizes information flows and expands the movement of personal
information across institutions, the public deserves detailed safeguards, clear limits
and confidence that privacy rights are not being eroded under the banner of convenience.
British Columbians live in an age of data breaches, cyberthreats, identity theft and
increasing concern over who holds their personal information. They are asked for more
information than ever before to access basic services. They are told to trust systems
they often cannot see and cannot inspect. Against that backdrop, government should proceed with humility and caution. Instead,
Bill 9 gives broad enabling authority first and leaves many practical questions unanswered.
How long is data retained? Who has access? What auditing mechanisms will exist? How
will consent be managed? How will errors be corrected when multiple systems rely on
shared data? What happens when a mistake in one database is replicated across several
agencies? How are vulnerable people protected from bureaucratic harm caused by incorrect
information? These are not technical afterthoughts. They are central questions of public trust.
If government wishes to expand such powers, it should welcome rigorous scrutiny rather
than expect automatic confidence. Clause 15 also merits attention. It permits the commissioner to extend the timeline
for a review, beyond the current 90-day requirement, by specifying a later date and
notifying relevant parties. Again, government may say this is practical administration.
Perhaps, in some circumstances, flexibility is needed, but let us consider the broader
pattern of this bill. The duty to respond becomes softer. Requests become easier to challenge for lack of
detail. Grounds to disregard become broader. Fees may be charged for certain available
records. Review times become more open-ended. At some point, these cannot be dismissed
as isolated housekeeping measures. They point in one direction: away from timely public
access At some point, these cannot be dismissed as isolated housekeeping measures. They point
in one direction, away from timely public access and toward administrative convenience
for the state. This is what concerns so many people when they look at this legislation. Accountability often dies not through dramatic scandal but through routine delay.
A request is unanswered. An extension is granted. A clarification is requested. Another
review is pending. Another deadline moves. Months pass. The news cycle moves on. The
issue fades. When records finally released no longer carry the same public value. Anyone who has observed access-to-information systems across Canada knows this pattern.
Delay itself can become a form of denial. Information released too late may satisfy
a legal check box while defeating the purpose of public scrutiny. That is why timing
matters so deeply. That is why weakening timing language matters. It is why open-ended
extensions matter. It is why a government serious about transparency would focus first
on response capacity rather than on new refusal mechanisms. I also wish to address the philosophical question at the centre of this debate. Who
does government work for? That may sound simple, but legislation like Bill 9 tests
whether this House still answers it properly. If government works for itself, then
public requests are interruptions. They are annoyances. They interfere with operations.
They consume time better spent elsewhere. They must be managed, filtered, narrowed,
discouraged and sometimes priced. But if government works for the public, then requests are legitimate acts of democratic
participation. They are how citizens supervise institutions larger than themselves.
They are how journalists investigate. They are how opposition members test claims.
They are how communities seek fairness. They are how truth is often assembled from
paper trails. I know which view I hold, and I believe most British Columbians know which view they
hold as well. They know instinctively that asking government questions should not
feel like trespassing. They know instinctively that public records should not be treated
as private possessions. They know instinctively that transparency delayed is transparency
diminished. There is another issue that cannot be ignored, and that is trust. Trust in institutions
has declined across much of the democratic world. People feel that discussions are
made far from them, explained poorly and shielded away from scrutiny. Whether one
agrees with every sentiment expressed publicly or not, that broader erosion of trust
is very real. When trust is fragile, government should respond by opening windows, not drawing curtains.
They should disclose more, not less. They should simplify access, not complicate it.
They should narrow discretion, not broaden it. They should make it easier for citizens
to see how decisions are made. Instead, Bill 9 risks sending the opposite message:
trust us more while we show you less. That is not a wise message for any government
to send. I do not doubt that some officials involved in drafting this legislation believe portions
of it are sensible. I do not doubt there are genuine administrative frustrations inside
ministries dealing with large volumes of requests. I do not doubt that systems need
updating. But inconvenience inside government cannot be the primary lens through which public
rights are viewed. Rights are often inconvenient. Elections are inconvenient. Question
period is inconvenient. Independent audits are inconvenient. Judicial review is inconvenient.
Freedom of information is inconvenient. Yet we maintain all of these because free
societies require institutions to answer to the people, not merely to themselves.
That is the balance government seems to forget. If government truly wished to improve the FOI system, there are many constructive
paths available. Increase staffing and access offices. Set enforceable service standards.
Publish more contracts, reports, calendars and briefing materials proactively. Reduce
unnecessary redactions. Create plain-language portals for applicants. Improve communication
with requesters. Invest in records management so searches are faster. Strengthen penalties
for deliberate obstruction. Report publicly on ministry performance. Those reforms would deserve support. Those reforms would align with the language of
efficiency and transparency. But this bill instead spends too much effort empowering
the institution rather than empowering the citizen. That is why we oppose it. I wish to speak directly to public servants who may hear this debate. This criticism
is not aimed at the many hard-working professionals across government who process I wish to speak directly to public servants who may hear this debate. This criticism
is not aimed at the many hard-working professionals across government who process
requests, manage records and try to serve the public under difficult conditions. Many
of them do excellent work with limited resources and under heavy pressure. They often
inherit systems and workloads not of their making. Our concern is with the policy direction set by government. When front-line staff
are overburdened, the solution is support. When systems are outdated, the solution
is investment. When demand rises, the solution is capacity. The solution should not
be fewer rights for the public. Future governments of every stripe should pay attention.
Powers created for one administration are inherited by the next. Precedents accepted
today become tomorrow's tools. That is why opposition to measures like these should
not be viewed narrowly or temporarily. This House should legislate with constitutional maturity. Members should not ask merely:
will my side benefit from this now? They should ask: would I accept this power in
the hands of my opponents later? That test often clarifies matters quickly. If members
opposite would object to these provisions under a different government, then they
should reconsider supporting them under this one. Democracy depends not only on voting day but on the thousands of ordinary acts by
which citizens remain informed between elections. A parent asking for records, a reporter
following expenses, a research or tracing policy development, a community group seeking
environmental data, an opposition caucus testing government claims. These are not
hostile acts. They are signs of a healthy society. They are evidence that people still
care enough to ask. Government should meet that care with respect, not resistance. Bill 9 does not do enough of that. Instead, it normalizes a mindset that public inquiry
is a burden to be managed. It treats access too often as a problem rather than a principle.
It moves the dial, however politely, towards less openness. Those incremental moves
matter. I return to where I began. Access to information is not a favour. It is not a public
relations option. It is not something government may celebrate in speeches while constraining
in statute. It is a democratic safeguard. It is one of the few tools that equalizes
the relationship between the citizen and the state. Without it, power grows darker.
With it, power remains answerable. For those reasons, I cannot support Bill 9 in its present form. I urge government
to withdraw the restrictive provisions, remove the free fee barriers, tighten the
vague refusal clauses, restore stronger timelines and return to this House with legislation
that genuinely advances openness while protecting privacy. British Columbians deserve
a government confident enough to be examined, mature enough to be questioned and honest
enough to know that transparency is not a threat. It is the price of public power.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Emergency preparedness
Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural
development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments
if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and
their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding
this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast
province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians
who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought
by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another
massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of
broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look
for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,
transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often
they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,
Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.
It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into
account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate
resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But
none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The
people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it
in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether
highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges
are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers
can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or
access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,
my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake
down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no
food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about
connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure
strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large
urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,
aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our
prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,
industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called
on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor
is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,
tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and
northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement
priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,
deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities
deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed
and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure
further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak
as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents
continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate
telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,
health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional
infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire
seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single
transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides
insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,
slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British
Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural
taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally
distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern
and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,
tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers
and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British
Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is
fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,
it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions
about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,
deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences
of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract
policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that
deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do
not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency
and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning
and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the
fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.
Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major
rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete
list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Information
I'm pleased to rise in this House to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and
Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. At the outset, I wanted to say this plainly: access to information is not a courtesy
that government extends when it's convenient. It is not a favour. It's not a privilege
reserved for those who know how to navigate bureaucracy, hire experts or wait months
on end while their request disappears into the machinery of government. Access to information is a democratic right. It's one of the few practical tools ordinary
people have to hold government accountable between elections. That is why Bill 9 matters.
And that is why the government's framing of this bill is so difficult to accept. We are told that this legislation is about efficiency. We are told it's about modernization.
We are told it's about improving the experience of British Columbians engaging with
government. Those are fine words. They sound polished. They sound reassuring. But
when one looks past the talking points and reads the actual text of the bill, a different
picture emerges. What this bill really does, in several important respects, is make it easier for government
to delay, easier for government to reject and easier for government to charge people
for access to information that should, by all reason and principle, remain accessible.
That is not transparency. That is not modernization. It's certainly not accountability. Freedom-of-information legislation exists because government records do not belong
to the government of the day in any moral sense. Those records are created using public
dollars by public bodies in the course of public administration. Ministers may sit
on those benches for a few years. Staff may rotate in and out. When a resident wants to know how a decision was made, when a journalist wants to
investigate waste, when a researcher wants to understand government process, when
a municipality wants answers, when a family wants records tied to an issue affecting
their lives, they should not be met with more obstacles. They should not be met with
more discretion in the hands of the very institutions they are trying to scrutinize.
They should not be priced out of information. They should not be treated as a burden
simply for asking questions. But that is the direction Bill 9 takes us. Let us begin with one of the clearest examples of the bill. That's clause 3. Clause
3 changes the obligation on a public body to respond to an access request without
delay and replaces it with a duty to respond without unreasonable delay. Now, on first
hearing, some may say that's only a small wording change, but members of this House
know full well that legislation wording is never casual. Words are chosen carefully
because words create standards, and standards shape behaviour. "Without delay" is a firm expectation. It is clear. It tells the public body that
time matters. It tells the applicant that the law recognizes urgency. It tells everyone
involved that records should not simply sit idle because government is busy, disorganized
or politically uncomfortable with disclosure. "Without unreasonable delay" is softer. It's more elastic. It leaves far more room
for justification, more room for interpretation, more room for excuses. What is unreasonable
to the applicant may appear entirely reasonable to an office already accustomed to
backlog. What is unreasonable to the public may appear acceptable to a government
that has grown comfortable with delay. That is the problem. British Columbians are already frustrated by slow response times
in the FOI system. They are already dealing with a process that can feel distant,
drawn out and opaque. The answer to that problem is not to lower the legal standard owed to them. The answer
is to improve performance. The answer is to ensure proper staffing, clear procedures
and a culture that treats disclosure as the rule, not the exception. Government should
be working to speed up the system, not legislate the slowdown into more acceptable
language. Then we come to clause 2, which is also deeply concerning. Clause 2 changes section
5 so that an FOI request must, in the opinion of the head of the public body, provide
enough detail to enable an experienced employee, with reasonable effort in a reasonable
amount of time, to identify the record sought. Again, that wording matters. "In the opinion of the head of the public body," "reasonable
effort," "reasonable amount of time" — who defines those things? Who decides when
the request is detailed enough? Who decides when the amount of time spent searching
is too much? Who decides whether the request is sufficiently precise, especially when
the applicant may not know exactly what records exist in the first place? This House should remember that many people file FOI requests precisely because they
do not already have a full picture. They're seeking clarity. They're trying to identify
what happened, who said what, what records exist, what advice was given, what emails
or briefing materials are on file. They're not always in a position to provide a perfectly
narrow or tailored request on the first attempt, nor should they be expected to know
the internal filing systems, terminology or administrative practices of every ministry,
agency and public body in the province. That is why the law should lean toward helping the applicant, not screening them out.
But this bill leans the other way. It shifts more discretion towards the institution.
It makes the opinion of the public body's head more central. It introduces vague standards
that can easily become barriers. It increases the chances that a request can be pushed
back, narrowed, delayed or treated as defective before the applicant has even had
a fair chance to obtain the records. And what will this mean in practice? It'll mean more frustration for people who are
already trying to navigate an intimidating process. It'll mean more correspondence
back and forth over wording instead of substance. It will mean more opportunities
for delay. And when people see that happening over and over again, their confidence
in the system deteriorates. Our freedom-of-information regime only works if people
believe it is A freedom-of-information regime only works if people believe it is real. It only works
if they believe that when they ask a legitimate question, they will receive fair treatment
and a lawful disclosure. Once people begin to suspect that every ambiguity in the
law will be read in favour of government convenience, then the right still exists
on paper but becomes weaker in practice. That is why clause 13 is so significant. Clause 13 expands the grounds upon which
the commissioner may authorize a public body to disregard a request. It adds the behaviour
of the applicant being abusive or malicious and broadens the language concerning requests
that would unreasonably interfere with the operations of the public body or the government
of British Columbia. It also refers to requests that are repetitive, systematic, or
excessively broad. Now, let us be careful here. No one is arguing that truly bad-faith conduct should
be tolerated. No system can function properly if it is deliberately weaponized against
public servants or used as a means of harassment. There must be safeguards against
genuine abuse. But safeguards must be clear, narrow and carefully constrained. This clause is not that. Instead, it introduces broad language without meaningful
definition in the bill itself. Once again, that should concern every member of this
House, because vague terms can become elastic terms, and elastic terms are very often
used to the advantage of those already holding power. What is abusive? What is malicious? Does that mean a request that is angry in tone?
A request filed after months of government silence? A request by someone who has asked
too many uncomfortable questions? A request by a journalist following a story government
wishes to go away? And what about unreasonable interference with operations of government? That is a
particularly troubling phrase. Would a broad request into the Premier's office be
said to interfere with operations? Would multiple requests into major procurement
decisions be deemed systematic? Would opposition researchers, journalists, advocacy
organizations or municipal leaders be told their efforts amount to a burden on government
rather than an exercise in democratic oversight? These are not far-fetched questions. They are the obvious questions that arise when
legislation uses broad language and leaves the boundaries unclear. If the government
wanted merely to target truly vexatious conduct, it would have drafted narrow, well-defined
provisions. Instead, it has chosen language that opens the door much wider. That is
the concern. And British Columbians are right to be concerned when a government that
already struggles with transparency seeks broader authority to disregard requests. Accountability is often inconvenient. That is simply the nature of accountability.
It takes time to answer questions. It takes effort to gather records. It requires
a willingness to endure scrutiny. But inconvenience to government is not the same
thing as abuse by the applicant. The right to ask hard questions is not an administrative flaw. It is one of the essential
features of a functioning democracy. If government finds public scrutiny burdensome,
the answer is not to weaken access rights. The answer is to govern in a way that can
withstand scrutiny. I also want to speak to clause 21, because it represents one of the clearest examples
of this government taking something that should be easier and making it harder. Clause
21 allows the head of a public body to require a person who asks for a copy of a record
that is otherwise available under protective disclosure to pay a fee. That is astonishing. These are records that government itself says should be available
without a formal access request. That is the whole point of proactive disclosure.
It's supposed to mean less friction, fewer obstacles, more openness and easier public
access. It's supposed to reduce the need for formal FOI filings by making records
accessible up front. But under this bill, government can now say: "Yes, the record is available, but you
may have to pay for it." That is not proactive disclosure in any meaningful public
sense. That is restricted access dressed up in a modern language. Let us be honest about who feels these kinds of changes most. It's not the large institution
with in-house counsel, not the ministry with taxpayer-funded staff, not the government
with all the records and all the procedural leverage. It is the ordinary person. It
is the local journalist on a tight budget. It is the resident trying to get information
about a matter affecting their family or community. It's the volunteer group. It's the student researcher. It is the taxpayer who already
paid once for the creation of the record and is now being asked to pay again to receive
it. The government may say these fees are modest, but a barrier does not have to be enormous
to be effective. Sometimes all it takes is one more step The government may say these fees are modest, but a barrier does not have to be enormous
to be effective. Sometimes all it takes is one more step, one more charge, one more
discouragement, and people walk away. That is especially true in a system that is
already slow and already difficult for many people to navigate. I would remind this House that that is not happening in a vacuum. British Columbians
have seen this government move before in ways that reduce access to information rather
than expand it. So when this bill arrives with new fees, broader refusal grounds and
weaker timing language, people notice the pattern. They notice that "free" is generally
being taken out of "freedom of information." This government speaks often about trust. It speaks often about service delivery.
It speaks often about people-centred systems. Those are nice phrases, but trust is
not built through slogans. It is built through conduct. It is built when government
answers questions instead of dodging them. It is built when disclosure is timely,
instead of delayed. It is built when access is broad, instead of narrow. It is built
when rights are strengthened, instead of qualified away. On that test, Bill 9 does
not meet that standard. There's another feature of this bill that deserves careful examination. That is the
growing use of information-sharing powers and centralized service mechanisms without
sufficient public explanation. Clause 12 permits the commissioner to exchange information
and enter into information-sharing agreements with commissioners in other jurisdictions.
What jurisdictions? Clause 20 establishes what is called a "connected services provider" and authorizes
the minister to designate a public body for that role, with powers relating to online
platforms, data sharing between public bodies, identifying services for which a person
may be eligible, and other services the minister considers appropriate. Now, no one in this chamber is opposed to technology being used wisely. No one is
opposed to making public services easier to navigate. If a resident can access multiple
services through one platform, that may be beneficial. If systems can be modernized
responsibly, that may be beneficial. If duplication can be reduced while privacy is
preserved, that may be also beneficial. Legislation must be judged not by aspiration
alone but by powers it grants. What powers are being granted here? The minister may designate a connected services
provider. The minister may direct what type and quantity of personal information is
shared. The minister may direct formats of sharing. The minister may determine sources
of data. The minister may issue different directions for different classes of persons,
public bodies or categories of personal information. Those are substantial powers. When government centralizes information flows and expands the movement of personal
information across institutions, the public deserves detailed safeguards, clear limits
and confidence that privacy rights are not being eroded under the banner of convenience.
British Columbians live in an age of data breaches, cyberthreats, identity theft and
increasing concern over who holds their personal information. They are asked for more
information than ever before to access basic services. They are told to trust systems
they often cannot see and cannot inspect. Against that backdrop, government should proceed with humility and caution. Instead,
Bill 9 gives broad enabling authority first and leaves many practical questions unanswered.
How long is data retained? Who has access? What auditing mechanisms will exist? How
will consent be managed? How will errors be corrected when multiple systems rely on
shared data? What happens when a mistake in one database is replicated across several
agencies? How are vulnerable people protected from bureaucratic harm caused by incorrect
information? These are not technical afterthoughts. They are central questions of public trust.
If government wishes to expand such powers, it should welcome rigorous scrutiny rather
than expect automatic confidence. Clause 15 also merits attention. It permits the commissioner to extend the timeline
for a review, beyond the current 90-day requirement, by specifying a later date and
notifying relevant parties. Again, government may say this is practical administration.
Perhaps, in some circumstances, flexibility is needed, but let us consider the broader
pattern of this bill. The duty to respond becomes softer. Requests become easier to challenge for lack of
detail. Grounds to disregard become broader. Fees may be charged for certain available
records. Review times become more open-ended. At some point, these cannot be dismissed
as isolated housekeeping measures. They point in one direction: away from timely public
access At some point, these cannot be dismissed as isolated housekeeping measures. They point
in one direction, away from timely public access and toward administrative convenience
for the state. This is what concerns so many people when they look at this legislation. Accountability often dies not through dramatic scandal but through routine delay.
A request is unanswered. An extension is granted. A clarification is requested. Another
review is pending. Another deadline moves. Months pass. The news cycle moves on. The
issue fades. When records finally released no longer carry the same public value. Anyone who has observed access-to-information systems across Canada knows this pattern.
Delay itself can become a form of denial. Information released too late may satisfy
a legal check box while defeating the purpose of public scrutiny. That is why timing
matters so deeply. That is why weakening timing language matters. It is why open-ended
extensions matter. It is why a government serious about transparency would focus first
on response capacity rather than on new refusal mechanisms. I also wish to address the philosophical question at the centre of this debate. Who
does government work for? That may sound simple, but legislation like Bill 9 tests
whether this House still answers it properly. If government works for itself, then
public requests are interruptions. They are annoyances. They interfere with operations.
They consume time better spent elsewhere. They must be managed, filtered, narrowed,
discouraged and sometimes priced. But if government works for the public, then requests are legitimate acts of democratic
participation. They are how citizens supervise institutions larger than themselves.
They are how journalists investigate. They are how opposition members test claims.
They are how communities seek fairness. They are how truth is often assembled from
paper trails. I know which view I hold, and I believe most British Columbians know which view they
hold as well. They know instinctively that asking government questions should not
feel like trespassing. They know instinctively that public records should not be treated
as private possessions. They know instinctively that transparency delayed is transparency
diminished. There is another issue that cannot be ignored, and that is trust. Trust in institutions
has declined across much of the democratic world. People feel that discussions are
made far from them, explained poorly and shielded away from scrutiny. Whether one
agrees with every sentiment expressed publicly or not, that broader erosion of trust
is very real. When trust is fragile, government should respond by opening windows, not drawing curtains.
They should disclose more, not less. They should simplify access, not complicate it.
They should narrow discretion, not broaden it. They should make it easier for citizens
to see how decisions are made. Instead, Bill 9 risks sending the opposite message:
trust us more while we show you less. That is not a wise message for any government
to send. I do not doubt that some officials involved in drafting this legislation believe portions
of it are sensible. I do not doubt there are genuine administrative frustrations inside
ministries dealing with large volumes of requests. I do not doubt that systems need
updating. But inconvenience inside government cannot be the primary lens through which public
rights are viewed. Rights are often inconvenient. Elections are inconvenient. Question
period is inconvenient. Independent audits are inconvenient. Judicial review is inconvenient.
Freedom of information is inconvenient. Yet we maintain all of these because free
societies require institutions to answer to the people, not merely to themselves.
That is the balance government seems to forget. If government truly wished to improve the FOI system, there are many constructive
paths available. Increase staffing and access offices. Set enforceable service standards.
Publish more contracts, reports, calendars and briefing materials proactively. Reduce
unnecessary redactions. Create plain-language portals for applicants. Improve communication
with requesters. Invest in records management so searches are faster. Strengthen penalties
for deliberate obstruction. Report publicly on ministry performance. Those reforms would deserve support. Those reforms would align with the language of
efficiency and transparency. But this bill instead spends too much effort empowering
the institution rather than empowering the citizen. That is why we oppose it. I wish to speak directly to public servants who may hear this debate. This criticism
is not aimed at the many hard-working professionals across government who process I wish to speak directly to public servants who may hear this debate. This criticism
is not aimed at the many hard-working professionals across government who process
requests, manage records and try to serve the public under difficult conditions. Many
of them do excellent work with limited resources and under heavy pressure. They often
inherit systems and workloads not of their making. Our concern is with the policy direction set by government. When front-line staff
are overburdened, the solution is support. When systems are outdated, the solution
is investment. When demand rises, the solution is capacity. The solution should not
be fewer rights for the public. Future governments of every stripe should pay attention.
Powers created for one administration are inherited by the next. Precedents accepted
today become tomorrow's tools. That is why opposition to measures like these should
not be viewed narrowly or temporarily. This House should legislate with constitutional maturity. Members should not ask merely:
will my side benefit from this now? They should ask: would I accept this power in
the hands of my opponents later? That test often clarifies matters quickly. If members
opposite would object to these provisions under a different government, then they
should reconsider supporting them under this one. Democracy depends not only on voting day but on the thousands of ordinary acts by
which citizens remain informed between elections. A parent asking for records, a reporter
following expenses, a research or tracing policy development, a community group seeking
environmental data, an opposition caucus testing government claims. These are not
hostile acts. They are signs of a healthy society. They are evidence that people still
care enough to ask. Government should meet that care with respect, not resistance. Bill 9 does not do enough of that. Instead, it normalizes a mindset that public inquiry
is a burden to be managed. It treats access too often as a problem rather than a principle.
It moves the dial, however politely, towards less openness. Those incremental moves
matter. I return to where I began. Access to information is not a favour. It is not a public
relations option. It is not something government may celebrate in speeches while constraining
in statute. It is a democratic safeguard. It is one of the few tools that equalizes
the relationship between the citizen and the state. Without it, power grows darker.
With it, power remains answerable. For those reasons, I cannot support Bill 9 in its present form. I urge government
to withdraw the restrictive provisions, remove the free fee barriers, tighten the
vague refusal clauses, restore stronger timelines and return to this House with legislation
that genuinely advances openness while protecting privacy. British Columbians deserve
a government confident enough to be examined, mature enough to be questioned and honest
enough to know that transparency is not a threat. It is the price of public power.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Telecommunications
Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural
development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments
if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and
their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding
this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast
province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians
who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought
by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another
massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of
broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look
for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,
transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often
they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,
Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.
It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into
account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate
resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But
none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The
people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it
in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether
highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges
are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers
can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or
access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,
my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake
down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no
food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about
connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure
strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large
urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,
aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our
prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,
industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called
on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor
is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,
tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and
northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement
priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,
deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities
deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed
and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure
further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak
as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents
continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate
telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,
health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional
infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire
seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single
transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides
insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,
slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British
Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural
taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally
distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern
and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,
tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers
and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British
Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is
fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,
it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions
about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,
deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences
of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract
policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that
deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do
not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency
and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning
and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the
fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.
Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major
rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete
list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Rural communities
Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural
development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments
if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and
their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding
this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast
province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians
who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought
by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another
massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of
broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look
for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,
transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often
they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,
Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.
It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into
account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate
resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But
none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The
people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it
in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether
highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges
are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers
can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or
access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,
my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake
down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no
food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about
connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure
strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large
urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,
aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our
prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,
industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called
on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor
is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,
tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and
northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement
priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,
deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities
deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed
and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure
further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak
as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents
continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate
telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,
health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional
infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire
seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single
transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides
insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,
slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British
Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural
taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally
distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern
and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,
tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers
and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British
Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is
fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,
it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions
about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,
deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences
of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract
policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that
deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do
not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency
and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning
and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the
fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.
Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major
rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete
list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Budgets, Public finance, Rural development
Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural
development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments
if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and
their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding
this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast
province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians
who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought
by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another
massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of
broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look
for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,
transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often
they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,
Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.
It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into
account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate
resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But
none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The
people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it
in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether
highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges
are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers
can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or
access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,
my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake
down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no
food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about
connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure
strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large
urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,
aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our
prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,
industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called
on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor
is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,
tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and
northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement
priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,
deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities
deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed
and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure
further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak
as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents
continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate
telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,
health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional
infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire
seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single
transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides
insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,
slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British
Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural
taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally
distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern
and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,
tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers
and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British
Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is
fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,
it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions
about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,
deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences
of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract
policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that
deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do
not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency
and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning
and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the
fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.
Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major
rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete
list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Rural environment
Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural
development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments
if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and
their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding
this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast
province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians
who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought
by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another
massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of
broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look
for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,
transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often
they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,
Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.
It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into
account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate
resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But
none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The
people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it
in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether
highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges
are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers
can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or
access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,
my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake
down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no
food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about
connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure
strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large
urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,
aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our
prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,
industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called
on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor
is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,
tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and
northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement
priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,
deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities
deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed
and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure
further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak
as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents
continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate
telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,
health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional
infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire
seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single
transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides
insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,
slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British
Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural
taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally
distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern
and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,
tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers
and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British
Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is
fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,
it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions
about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,
deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences
of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract
policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that
deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do
not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency
and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning
and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the
fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.
Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major
rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete
list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public administration
I'm pleased to rise in this House to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and
Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. At the outset, I wanted to say this plainly: access to information is not a courtesy
that government extends when it's convenient. It is not a favour. It's not a privilege
reserved for those who know how to navigate bureaucracy, hire experts or wait months
on end while their request disappears into the machinery of government. Access to information is a democratic right. It's one of the few practical tools ordinary
people have to hold government accountable between elections. That is why Bill 9 matters.
And that is why the government's framing of this bill is so difficult to accept. We are told that this legislation is about efficiency. We are told it's about modernization.
We are told it's about improving the experience of British Columbians engaging with
government. Those are fine words. They sound polished. They sound reassuring. But
when one looks past the talking points and reads the actual text of the bill, a different
picture emerges. What this bill really does, in several important respects, is make it easier for government
to delay, easier for government to reject and easier for government to charge people
for access to information that should, by all reason and principle, remain accessible.
That is not transparency. That is not modernization. It's certainly not accountability. Freedom-of-information legislation exists because government records do not belong
to the government of the day in any moral sense. Those records are created using public
dollars by public bodies in the course of public administration. Ministers may sit
on those benches for a few years. Staff may rotate in and out. When a resident wants to know how a decision was made, when a journalist wants to
investigate waste, when a researcher wants to understand government process, when
a municipality wants answers, when a family wants records tied to an issue affecting
their lives, they should not be met with more obstacles. They should not be met with
more discretion in the hands of the very institutions they are trying to scrutinize.
They should not be priced out of information. They should not be treated as a burden
simply for asking questions. But that is the direction Bill 9 takes us. Let us begin with one of the clearest examples of the bill. That's clause 3. Clause
3 changes the obligation on a public body to respond to an access request without
delay and replaces it with a duty to respond without unreasonable delay. Now, on first
hearing, some may say that's only a small wording change, but members of this House
know full well that legislation wording is never casual. Words are chosen carefully
because words create standards, and standards shape behaviour. "Without delay" is a firm expectation. It is clear. It tells the public body that
time matters. It tells the applicant that the law recognizes urgency. It tells everyone
involved that records should not simply sit idle because government is busy, disorganized
or politically uncomfortable with disclosure. "Without unreasonable delay" is softer. It's more elastic. It leaves far more room
for justification, more room for interpretation, more room for excuses. What is unreasonable
to the applicant may appear entirely reasonable to an office already accustomed to
backlog. What is unreasonable to the public may appear acceptable to a government
that has grown comfortable with delay. That is the problem. British Columbians are already frustrated by slow response times
in the FOI system. They are already dealing with a process that can feel distant,
drawn out and opaque. The answer to that problem is not to lower the legal standard owed to them. The answer
is to improve performance. The answer is to ensure proper staffing, clear procedures
and a culture that treats disclosure as the rule, not the exception. Government should
be working to speed up the system, not legislate the slowdown into more acceptable
language. Then we come to clause 2, which is also deeply concerning. Clause 2 changes section
5 so that an FOI request must, in the opinion of the head of the public body, provide
enough detail to enable an experienced employee, with reasonable effort in a reasonable
amount of time, to identify the record sought. Again, that wording matters. "In the opinion of the head of the public body," "reasonable
effort," "reasonable amount of time" — who defines those things? Who decides when
the request is detailed enough? Who decides when the amount of time spent searching
is too much? Who decides whether the request is sufficiently precise, especially when
the applicant may not know exactly what records exist in the first place? This House should remember that many people file FOI requests precisely because they
do not already have a full picture. They're seeking clarity. They're trying to identify
what happened, who said what, what records exist, what advice was given, what emails
or briefing materials are on file. They're not always in a position to provide a perfectly
narrow or tailored request on the first attempt, nor should they be expected to know
the internal filing systems, terminology or administrative practices of every ministry,
agency and public body in the province. That is why the law should lean toward helping the applicant, not screening them out.
But this bill leans the other way. It shifts more discretion towards the institution.
It makes the opinion of the public body's head more central. It introduces vague standards
that can easily become barriers. It increases the chances that a request can be pushed
back, narrowed, delayed or treated as defective before the applicant has even had
a fair chance to obtain the records. And what will this mean in practice? It'll mean more frustration for people who are
already trying to navigate an intimidating process. It'll mean more correspondence
back and forth over wording instead of substance. It will mean more opportunities
for delay. And when people see that happening over and over again, their confidence
in the system deteriorates. Our freedom-of-information regime only works if people
believe it is A freedom-of-information regime only works if people believe it is real. It only works
if they believe that when they ask a legitimate question, they will receive fair treatment
and a lawful disclosure. Once people begin to suspect that every ambiguity in the
law will be read in favour of government convenience, then the right still exists
on paper but becomes weaker in practice. That is why clause 13 is so significant. Clause 13 expands the grounds upon which
the commissioner may authorize a public body to disregard a request. It adds the behaviour
of the applicant being abusive or malicious and broadens the language concerning requests
that would unreasonably interfere with the operations of the public body or the government
of British Columbia. It also refers to requests that are repetitive, systematic, or
excessively broad. Now, let us be careful here. No one is arguing that truly bad-faith conduct should
be tolerated. No system can function properly if it is deliberately weaponized against
public servants or used as a means of harassment. There must be safeguards against
genuine abuse. But safeguards must be clear, narrow and carefully constrained. This clause is not that. Instead, it introduces broad language without meaningful
definition in the bill itself. Once again, that should concern every member of this
House, because vague terms can become elastic terms, and elastic terms are very often
used to the advantage of those already holding power. What is abusive? What is malicious? Does that mean a request that is angry in tone?
A request filed after months of government silence? A request by someone who has asked
too many uncomfortable questions? A request by a journalist following a story government
wishes to go away? And what about unreasonable interference with operations of government? That is a
particularly troubling phrase. Would a broad request into the Premier's office be
said to interfere with operations? Would multiple requests into major procurement
decisions be deemed systematic? Would opposition researchers, journalists, advocacy
organizations or municipal leaders be told their efforts amount to a burden on government
rather than an exercise in democratic oversight? These are not far-fetched questions. They are the obvious questions that arise when
legislation uses broad language and leaves the boundaries unclear. If the government
wanted merely to target truly vexatious conduct, it would have drafted narrow, well-defined
provisions. Instead, it has chosen language that opens the door much wider. That is
the concern. And British Columbians are right to be concerned when a government that
already struggles with transparency seeks broader authority to disregard requests. Accountability is often inconvenient. That is simply the nature of accountability.
It takes time to answer questions. It takes effort to gather records. It requires
a willingness to endure scrutiny. But inconvenience to government is not the same
thing as abuse by the applicant. The right to ask hard questions is not an administrative flaw. It is one of the essential
features of a functioning democracy. If government finds public scrutiny burdensome,
the answer is not to weaken access rights. The answer is to govern in a way that can
withstand scrutiny. I also want to speak to clause 21, because it represents one of the clearest examples
of this government taking something that should be easier and making it harder. Clause
21 allows the head of a public body to require a person who asks for a copy of a record
that is otherwise available under protective disclosure to pay a fee. That is astonishing. These are records that government itself says should be available
without a formal access request. That is the whole point of proactive disclosure.
It's supposed to mean less friction, fewer obstacles, more openness and easier public
access. It's supposed to reduce the need for formal FOI filings by making records
accessible up front. But under this bill, government can now say: "Yes, the record is available, but you
may have to pay for it." That is not proactive disclosure in any meaningful public
sense. That is restricted access dressed up in a modern language. Let us be honest about who feels these kinds of changes most. It's not the large institution
with in-house counsel, not the ministry with taxpayer-funded staff, not the government
with all the records and all the procedural leverage. It is the ordinary person. It
is the local journalist on a tight budget. It is the resident trying to get information
about a matter affecting their family or community. It's the volunteer group. It's the student researcher. It is the taxpayer who already
paid once for the creation of the record and is now being asked to pay again to receive
it. The government may say these fees are modest, but a barrier does not have to be enormous
to be effective. Sometimes all it takes is one more step The government may say these fees are modest, but a barrier does not have to be enormous
to be effective. Sometimes all it takes is one more step, one more charge, one more
discouragement, and people walk away. That is especially true in a system that is
already slow and already difficult for many people to navigate. I would remind this House that that is not happening in a vacuum. British Columbians
have seen this government move before in ways that reduce access to information rather
than expand it. So when this bill arrives with new fees, broader refusal grounds and
weaker timing language, people notice the pattern. They notice that "free" is generally
being taken out of "freedom of information." This government speaks often about trust. It speaks often about service delivery.
It speaks often about people-centred systems. Those are nice phrases, but trust is
not built through slogans. It is built through conduct. It is built when government
answers questions instead of dodging them. It is built when disclosure is timely,
instead of delayed. It is built when access is broad, instead of narrow. It is built
when rights are strengthened, instead of qualified away. On that test, Bill 9 does
not meet that standard. There's another feature of this bill that deserves careful examination. That is the
growing use of information-sharing powers and centralized service mechanisms without
sufficient public explanation. Clause 12 permits the commissioner to exchange information
and enter into information-sharing agreements with commissioners in other jurisdictions.
What jurisdictions? Clause 20 establishes what is called a "connected services provider" and authorizes
the minister to designate a public body for that role, with powers relating to online
platforms, data sharing between public bodies, identifying services for which a person
may be eligible, and other services the minister considers appropriate. Now, no one in this chamber is opposed to technology being used wisely. No one is
opposed to making public services easier to navigate. If a resident can access multiple
services through one platform, that may be beneficial. If systems can be modernized
responsibly, that may be beneficial. If duplication can be reduced while privacy is
preserved, that may be also beneficial. Legislation must be judged not by aspiration
alone but by powers it grants. What powers are being granted here? The minister may designate a connected services
provider. The minister may direct what type and quantity of personal information is
shared. The minister may direct formats of sharing. The minister may determine sources
of data. The minister may issue different directions for different classes of persons,
public bodies or categories of personal information. Those are substantial powers. When government centralizes information flows and expands the movement of personal
information across institutions, the public deserves detailed safeguards, clear limits
and confidence that privacy rights are not being eroded under the banner of convenience.
British Columbians live in an age of data breaches, cyberthreats, identity theft and
increasing concern over who holds their personal information. They are asked for more
information than ever before to access basic services. They are told to trust systems
they often cannot see and cannot inspect. Against that backdrop, government should proceed with humility and caution. Instead,
Bill 9 gives broad enabling authority first and leaves many practical questions unanswered.
How long is data retained? Who has access? What auditing mechanisms will exist? How
will consent be managed? How will errors be corrected when multiple systems rely on
shared data? What happens when a mistake in one database is replicated across several
agencies? How are vulnerable people protected from bureaucratic harm caused by incorrect
information? These are not technical afterthoughts. They are central questions of public trust.
If government wishes to expand such powers, it should welcome rigorous scrutiny rather
than expect automatic confidence. Clause 15 also merits attention. It permits the commissioner to extend the timeline
for a review, beyond the current 90-day requirement, by specifying a later date and
notifying relevant parties. Again, government may say this is practical administration.
Perhaps, in some circumstances, flexibility is needed, but let us consider the broader
pattern of this bill. The duty to respond becomes softer. Requests become easier to challenge for lack of
detail. Grounds to disregard become broader. Fees may be charged for certain available
records. Review times become more open-ended. At some point, these cannot be dismissed
as isolated housekeeping measures. They point in one direction: away from timely public
access At some point, these cannot be dismissed as isolated housekeeping measures. They point
in one direction, away from timely public access and toward administrative convenience
for the state. This is what concerns so many people when they look at this legislation. Accountability often dies not through dramatic scandal but through routine delay.
A request is unanswered. An extension is granted. A clarification is requested. Another
review is pending. Another deadline moves. Months pass. The news cycle moves on. The
issue fades. When records finally released no longer carry the same public value. Anyone who has observed access-to-information systems across Canada knows this pattern.
Delay itself can become a form of denial. Information released too late may satisfy
a legal check box while defeating the purpose of public scrutiny. That is why timing
matters so deeply. That is why weakening timing language matters. It is why open-ended
extensions matter. It is why a government serious about transparency would focus first
on response capacity rather than on new refusal mechanisms. I also wish to address the philosophical question at the centre of this debate. Who
does government work for? That may sound simple, but legislation like Bill 9 tests
whether this House still answers it properly. If government works for itself, then
public requests are interruptions. They are annoyances. They interfere with operations.
They consume time better spent elsewhere. They must be managed, filtered, narrowed,
discouraged and sometimes priced. But if government works for the public, then requests are legitimate acts of democratic
participation. They are how citizens supervise institutions larger than themselves.
They are how journalists investigate. They are how opposition members test claims.
They are how communities seek fairness. They are how truth is often assembled from
paper trails. I know which view I hold, and I believe most British Columbians know which view they
hold as well. They know instinctively that asking government questions should not
feel like trespassing. They know instinctively that public records should not be treated
as private possessions. They know instinctively that transparency delayed is transparency
diminished. There is another issue that cannot be ignored, and that is trust. Trust in institutions
has declined across much of the democratic world. People feel that discussions are
made far from them, explained poorly and shielded away from scrutiny. Whether one
agrees with every sentiment expressed publicly or not, that broader erosion of trust
is very real. When trust is fragile, government should respond by opening windows, not drawing curtains.
They should disclose more, not less. They should simplify access, not complicate it.
They should narrow discretion, not broaden it. They should make it easier for citizens
to see how decisions are made. Instead, Bill 9 risks sending the opposite message:
trust us more while we show you less. That is not a wise message for any government
to send. I do not doubt that some officials involved in drafting this legislation believe portions
of it are sensible. I do not doubt there are genuine administrative frustrations inside
ministries dealing with large volumes of requests. I do not doubt that systems need
updating. But inconvenience inside government cannot be the primary lens through which public
rights are viewed. Rights are often inconvenient. Elections are inconvenient. Question
period is inconvenient. Independent audits are inconvenient. Judicial review is inconvenient.
Freedom of information is inconvenient. Yet we maintain all of these because free
societies require institutions to answer to the people, not merely to themselves.
That is the balance government seems to forget. If government truly wished to improve the FOI system, there are many constructive
paths available. Increase staffing and access offices. Set enforceable service standards.
Publish more contracts, reports, calendars and briefing materials proactively. Reduce
unnecessary redactions. Create plain-language portals for applicants. Improve communication
with requesters. Invest in records management so searches are faster. Strengthen penalties
for deliberate obstruction. Report publicly on ministry performance. Those reforms would deserve support. Those reforms would align with the language of
efficiency and transparency. But this bill instead spends too much effort empowering
the institution rather than empowering the citizen. That is why we oppose it. I wish to speak directly to public servants who may hear this debate. This criticism
is not aimed at the many hard-working professionals across government who process I wish to speak directly to public servants who may hear this debate. This criticism
is not aimed at the many hard-working professionals across government who process
requests, manage records and try to serve the public under difficult conditions. Many
of them do excellent work with limited resources and under heavy pressure. They often
inherit systems and workloads not of their making. Our concern is with the policy direction set by government. When front-line staff
are overburdened, the solution is support. When systems are outdated, the solution
is investment. When demand rises, the solution is capacity. The solution should not
be fewer rights for the public. Future governments of every stripe should pay attention.
Powers created for one administration are inherited by the next. Precedents accepted
today become tomorrow's tools. That is why opposition to measures like these should
not be viewed narrowly or temporarily. This House should legislate with constitutional maturity. Members should not ask merely:
will my side benefit from this now? They should ask: would I accept this power in
the hands of my opponents later? That test often clarifies matters quickly. If members
opposite would object to these provisions under a different government, then they
should reconsider supporting them under this one. Democracy depends not only on voting day but on the thousands of ordinary acts by
which citizens remain informed between elections. A parent asking for records, a reporter
following expenses, a research or tracing policy development, a community group seeking
environmental data, an opposition caucus testing government claims. These are not
hostile acts. They are signs of a healthy society. They are evidence that people still
care enough to ask. Government should meet that care with respect, not resistance. Bill 9 does not do enough of that. Instead, it normalizes a mindset that public inquiry
is a burden to be managed. It treats access too often as a problem rather than a principle.
It moves the dial, however politely, towards less openness. Those incremental moves
matter. I return to where I began. Access to information is not a favour. It is not a public
relations option. It is not something government may celebrate in speeches while constraining
in statute. It is a democratic safeguard. It is one of the few tools that equalizes
the relationship between the citizen and the state. Without it, power grows darker.
With it, power remains answerable. For those reasons, I cannot support Bill 9 in its present form. I urge government
to withdraw the restrictive provisions, remove the free fee barriers, tighten the
vague refusal clauses, restore stronger timelines and return to this House with legislation
that genuinely advances openness while protecting privacy. British Columbians deserve
a government confident enough to be examined, mature enough to be questioned and honest
enough to know that transparency is not a threat. It is the price of public power.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Health care, Mental health, Suicide
A constituent of mine has been on a wait-list for a psychiatrist since 2023. And I
think if the minister keeps promising help, she's going to have to hire a psychiatrist
for that help, because we're not seeing it. Across the province and especially in
the North, health care is lacking everywhere. She was diagnosed with a mental illness and had been sober for 20 years, but without
access to proper psychiatric care, she relapsed. Since then, she has attempted to
take her own life, cycled through emergency care. Today there is no psychiatrist in
Houston or Smithers. To the minister, how does this government expect people to maintain recovery when
they cannot even access psychiatric care that they need to stay well?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Community infrastructures, Infrastructures
Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural
development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments
if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and
their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding
this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast
province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians
who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought
by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another
massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of
broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look
for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,
transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often
they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,
Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.
It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into
account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate
resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But
none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The
people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it
in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether
highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges
are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers
can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or
access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,
my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake
down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no
food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about
connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure
strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large
urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,
aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our
prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,
industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called
on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor
is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,
tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and
northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement
priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,
deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities
deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed
and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure
further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak
as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents
continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate
telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,
health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional
infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire
seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single
transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides
insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,
slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British
Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural
taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally
distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern
and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,
tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers
and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British
Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is
fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,
it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions
about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,
deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences
of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract
policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that
deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do
not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency
and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning
and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the
fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.
Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major
rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete
list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues, Funding, Public funding
Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural
development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments
if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and
their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding
this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast
province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians
who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought
by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another
massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of
broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look
for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,
transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often
they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,
Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.
It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into
account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate
resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But
none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The
people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it
in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether
highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges
are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers
can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or
access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,
my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake
down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no
food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about
connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure
strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large
urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,
aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our
prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,
industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called
on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor
is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,
tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and
northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement
priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,
deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities
deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed
and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure
further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak
as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents
continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate
telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,
health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional
infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire
seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single
transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides
insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,
slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British
Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural
taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally
distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern
and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,
tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers
and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British
Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is
fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,
it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions
about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,
deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences
of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract
policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that
deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do
not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency
and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning
and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the
fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.
Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major
rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete
list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Road networks
Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural
development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments
if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and
their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding
this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast
province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians
who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought
by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another
massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of
broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look
for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,
transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often
they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,
Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.
It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into
account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate
resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But
none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The
people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it
in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether
highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges
are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers
can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or
access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,
my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake
down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no
food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about
connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure
strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large
urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,
aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our
prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,
industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called
on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor
is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,
tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and
northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement
priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,
deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities
deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed
and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure
further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak
as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents
continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate
telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,
health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional
infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire
seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single
transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides
insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,
slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British
Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural
taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally
distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern
and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,
tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers
and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British
Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is
fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,
it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions
about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,
deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences
of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract
policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that
deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do
not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency
and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning
and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the
fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.
Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major
rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete
list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?Open source reference