Heather Maahs · 2026-05

3 recorded contributions · Small sample

Back to media pack

Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required

Governance: 1 contributions
2026-05-06 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Public administration

I'm very pleased to speak to this hoist motion today, not simply to oppose Bill 9
               but to defend one of the most important democratic principles we have in British Columbia:
               the principle that government must remain accountable to the people it serves. I rise to defend the principle that information does not belong to politicians, ministers,
               bureaucrats or governments. It belongs to the people. I rise today in support of the
               hoist motion And I rise today in support of the hoist motion before this House, because the concerns
               surrounding Bill 9 are too serious, too numerous and too unresolved for this legislation
               to proceed without a pause, because this is not a routine amendment. It is not a harmless
               administrative update. It is not simply modernization, no matter how many times the
               government repeats that word. Bill 9 fundamentally changes the relationship between citizens and their government.
               It changes the balance between transparency and control, which is why the hoist motion
               is so necessary. When legislation carries consequences of this magnitude, this Legislature
               has a responsibility to stop, to reflect and scrutinize and, at the very least, reconsider. This is precisely why a hoist motion exists, and this is precisely why this House
               needs to support a six-month pause on Bill 9. A hoist motion is not obstruction. A
               hoist motion is responsibility. It is a parliamentary mechanism designed specifically
               for situations where legislation raises profound concerns that require deeper public
               examination before moving forward. Bill 9 unquestionably meets that threshold, because
               opposition to this bill is not isolated. The concerns surrounding Bill 9 are broad,
               serious and credible. Former architects of British Columbia's freedom-of-information legislation have raised
               alarms. Journalists have raised alarms. Transparency advocates have raised alarms.
               And when legislation designed to govern access to information generates this level
               of concern about transparency itself, this House has an obligation to proceed with
               caution, not speed. This is why a hoist motion matters, because legislation affecting
               democratic accountability deserves more scrutiny, not less. Let us remember why freedom-of-information legislation exists in the first place.
               The original FOI legislation was introduced in British Columbia in the 1990s and was
               built on a very simple but powerful principle. Government information belongs to the
               public. That principle shaped the legislation as it was originally written. The law was designed
               not to protect government from scrutiny but to protect the public's right to scrutinize
               government. It was designed to ensure that citizens could understand decisions made
               in their name and with their tax dollars. It was designed to ensure accountability.
               It was designed to ensure transparency, and it was designed with the understanding
               that democracy cannot function properly when information is hidden from the people. That original vision matters, because Bill 9 moves us away from it. And one of the
               strongest reasons to support the hoist motion is to allow this House the opportunity
               to reconsider whether legislation remains faithful to the original principles of the
               freedom of information as it was conceived in the 1990s. A former architect of British Columbia's freedom-of-information system warned us that
               this bill risks turning FOI into freedom from information. We heard that today from
               the MLA for Saanich North and the Islands. This is not partisan rhetoric. In the Times Colonist , it was argued that this government appears to no longer care about access to information.
               Again, those are not casual criticisms. Those are fundamental warnings about the direction
               this legislation takes us. When warnings of that magnitude are raised, the responsible response is not to rush
               the legislation forward. The responsible response is to pause, to listen and to reconsider,
               to hoist the bill for six months so that the public can fully examine what is being
               proposed. The irony here is impossible to ignore. A bill dealing with access to information
               is itself being pushed forward without sufficient openness and scrutiny. That should
               concern every member of this House. One of the most troubling changes in Bill 9 is the weakening of the response timelines.
               Under the current legislation, government is required to respond to requests "without
               delay." Bill 9 changes that standard to "without unreasonable delay." At first glance,
               this may seem insignificant, but it is not insignificant at all. Words matter, especially
               in legislation. Standards matter. This change fundamentally weakens the obligation
               placed on government. "Without delay" creates urgency. It creates accountability, and it creates a clear
               expectation. But "without unreasonable delay" introduces flexibility and also introduces
               interpretation and subjectivity. Most importantly, it gives government greater room
               to justify delays. That is not strengthening transparency. That is weakening accountability. Changes of that magnitude deserve far more scrutiny than this government appears willing
               to allow. That is exactly why this bill needs to be hoisted. Because when government
               weakens the standard for responding to information requests, this House should not
               simply wave it through. It should pause. It should examine the consequences carefully,
               and it should ensure that any reforms remain faithful to the original spirit of the
               legislation. Another deeply concerning aspect of Bill 9 is the expanded authority for government
               to reject requests. Under this bill, requests may be dismissed if they are considered
               "abusive," "malicious," "repetitious," "systematic," "excessively broad" or "interfering
               with operations." Let's think carefully about those terms. Who decides what is repetitious or systematic?
               Who decides what is excessively broad? The government does — the very institution
               being scrutinized. This is a profound problem. It makes me think of a term that we
               sometimes use, which is the fox guarding the henhouse. Freedom-of-information legislation was never intended to allow government to define
               the limits of accessible scrutiny. Yet that is precisely what Bill 9 risks doing.
               A journalist investigating a pattern of conduct could now A journalist investigating a pattern of conduct could now be described as systematic.
               An opposition member pursuing repeated follow-up questions could now be described
               as repetitious. A citizen attempting to obtain comprehensive information could now
               be described as excessively broad. Once those labels are applied, requests can be
               rejected. That is not transparency. That is control. When legislation increases government control over public access to information, that
               legislation deserves more scrutiny, not less. That is why this hoist motion is necessary.
               Kirk Lapointe warned that Bill 9 will make access to information slower, less predictable
               and more discretionary. Those words should concern every member of this House — slower,
               less predictable, more discretionary. Transparency only functions when access is timely,
               reliable and governed by clear standards. When delays increase, accountability weakens. When predictability disappears, confidence
               in the system erodes. This should be greatly concerning to government. It certainly
               is on this side of the House. When discretion expands, government gains greater power
               to decide what the public gets to know. That is not modernization. That is regression. Lapointe also warned that this legislation enables government to defer, delay and
               deny the public's right to know. Again, those are not minor criticisms. Those are
               warnings about the democratic accountability system in and of itself. When legislation
               raises concerns about democratic accountability, this House should not rush forward.
               It should pause, and it should certainly support the hoist motion. Transparency advocates have described Bill 9 as an assault on government transparency.
               Whether members agree with that exact wording or not, the fact remains that there
               is widespread concern that this legislation weakens public access rather than strengthens
               it. That concern is not isolated. It is repeated again and again across multiple sectors.
               That alone should justify a six-month pause. But legislation affecting transparency should itself be subjected to the highest possible
               level of scrutiny. That is what the hoist motion would, in fact, accomplish. More
               scrutiny, more public input, more consultation, more accountability, not less. One of the strongest arguments in favour of the hoist motion is that it would allow
               government the opportunity to return to the original principles of freedom-of-information
               legislation. I've mentioned this. The original FOI laws. introduced in the 1990s.
               were designed to expand transparency. Bill 9 risks narrowing it. The original legislation
               placed the burden on government to justify secrecy. Bill 9 risks shifting the burden
               on to citizens to justify access. The original legislation recognized that scrutiny strengthens democracy. Bill 9 risks
               treating scrutiny as interference. That is a profound philosophical shift, and philosophical
               shifts of this magnitude deserve deep public examination before legislation proceeds.
               That is why the bill should be hoisted. The government may argue that these changes are necessary for efficiency. The government may argue that these changes are necessary for efficiency, but the
               public is not the problem. Citizens asking questions are not the problem. Journalists
               seeking accountability are not the problem. Opposition members demanding answers are
               not the problem. The problems are internal. Record management systems need improvement.
               Resources need investment. And instead of addressing those issues directly, Bill 9
               shifts the burden onto the public. That is the wrong approach. And wrong approaches should not be rushed through the
               Legislature. They should be paused and reconsidered. And that is precisely what a
               hoist motion would allow. Let us also consider the cumulative effect of these changes. One change weakens timelines.
               Another expands refusal powers. Another increases discretion. Another narrows access.
               Individually, the government may attempt to portray each change as modest, but collectively,
               the direction becomes unmistakable. The cumulative effect is reduced transparency,
               reduced accountability and reduced public access. And when legislation moves us steadily away from openness and toward control, this
               House has a duty to intervene. That is why the hoist motion is so important, because
               it allows us to stop before those changes become law. It allows us to reassess. It
               allows us to ensure that democratic accountability remains the guiding principle. This bill does not simply affect journalists or opposition members. It affects ordinary
               citizens — citizens trying to understand decisions that impact their lives; citizens
               trying to obtain records about services, policies or actions affecting them personally;
               citizens who rely on freedom of information laws, because they have nowhere else to
               turn. And what will happen under Bill 9? Requests will take longer, requests will
               face more barriers, and they will be subject to more discretion. And eventually, some
               people will simply give up. You have to wonder if that's not part of the purpose here. That is how transparency erodes, not suddenly but gradually, through delay, through
               frustration, through exhaustion. That is why the House must proceed carefully, and
               that is why this bill must be hoisted. A six-month hoist is not unreasonable. In fact, given the scale of concern surrounding
               this legislation, it is the minimum responsible course of action. Six months would
               allow more public hearings; more expert testimony; more consultation with journalists,
               watchdogs and transparency advocates; more examination of how these changes compare
               to the original principles of the FOI legislation; more consideration of whether this
               bill truly strengthens access or weakens it. Most importantly, six months would allow
               for more public scrutiny, not less, because transparency legislation should never
               move forward without maximum transparency in its own review process. If this government truly believes Bill 9 strengthens access to information, then it
               should welcome a six-month pause, it should welcome scrutiny, it should welcome debate,
               and it should welcome public input, because good legislation only improves over scrutiny.
               Only weak legislation fears it. And if this bill cannot withstand six more months
               of public examination, then perhaps that tells us everything we need to know about
               the legislation itself. When I was on the school board, I used to say: "Public scrutiny and complaints contain
               improvement information." And that is what we truly need to be looking after and looking
               for. This debate is, ultimately, about trust — trust between government and citizens, trust
               that government remains accountable, trust that transparency is being strengthened,
               not weakened. And trust cannot be built through secrecy. It cannot be built through
               delay. It cannot be built through expanded discretion and increased barriers. Trust
               is built through openness, through accountability and transparency. Those principles
               shape the original freedom-of-information legislation in British Columbia, and those
               principles should continue to guide us today. That is why the House must support this hoist motion, because the concerns surrounding
               Bill 9 remain unresolved; because the public deserves more scrutiny, not less; because
               democratic accountability deserves stronger protection, not weaker standards; and
               because legislation that reshapes public access to information should never be rushed
               through legislature without full and proper examination. Transparency is not a nuisance, and scrutiny is not interference. Accountability is
               not optional. Those principles mattered in the 1990s when British Columbia first established
               its FOI legislation, and they matter just as much, if not more, today. Once transparency is weakened, it becomes very difficult to restore. Once accountability
               erodes, public trust declines. And once public trust is lost, democracy itself suffers.
               That is why this House must pause, must reconsider why this House must support the
               hoist motion before us, not to obstruct accountability but to strengthen it, certainly
               not to reduce scrutiny but to ensure more scrutiny, more consultation and more public
               examination before this legislation proceeds any further. To conclude, for those reasons, I will support Bill 9 be read a second time this day,
               six months hence.
Open source reference
Housing & Development: 1 contributions
2026-05-21 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Housing, Housing assistance

This government has been keeping a 140-unit hotel, SRO, open for just two tenants
               over the past two months. One left, but the last remaining tenant, Robert, has been
               offered multiple different housing options but is refusing to leave. Atira, the operator
               of the Colonial Hotel, said the contract to operate expired at the end of April. This is costing taxpayers $550,000 for two months. How can the Minister of Housing
               justify spending over half a million dollars to house one person?
Open source reference
Community Life: 0 contributions
Defence & Foreign Affairs: 0 contributions
Economy & Employment: 0 contributions
Education: 0 contributions
Environment & Resources: 0 contributions
Health: 0 contributions
Public Finance: 0 contributions
Public Safety & Justice: 0 contributions
Rights & Inclusion: 0 contributions
Science & Technology: 0 contributions
Social Services: 0 contributions
Transportation: 0 contributions