9 recorded contributions · Small sample
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Public finance
I rise to respond to the amendment from the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville. Frankly, this amendment is exactly the problem this motion is trying to address. The
motion before this House is simple. It says elected officials who make billion-dollar
decisions on behalf of British Columbians should have a basic understanding of economics,
public finance, debt, deficits, inflation, productivity and the cost of government
decisions. That should not be controversial to this House. But instead of debating that reasonable proposition, the government has done what
it so often does in this place. It has tried to turn a practical debate into a wedge
issue. It has tried to change the channel. It has tried to make out a basic motion
to be something far darker than it really is — the absolute horror of basic economics
education. But this motion is not about ideology. This is about competence. Nowhere is that more obvious than in health care. This government has spent years
announcing inputs — more money, more plans, more strategies, more press releases,
more ribbon cuttings. But the outputs tell a very different story. Emergency rooms
are still closing in rural British Columbia. Seniors are still stuck in hospital beds
because long-term-care capacity doesn't exist. According to the seniors advocate,
more than 7,000 British Columbians were waiting for long-term care in 2025. It is
now 7,800 this year, an average wait time of over a year. This is what happens when government confuses spending with results. A government
can spend more and deliver less. It can announce more and build less. It can hire
more administrators and still leave patients waiting, seniors stranded and families
desperate. That is why economic literacy matters, because debt has to be serviced. Deficits have
consequences. Capital delays cost money. When government mismanages major projects,
that is not government money being wasted. It is money earned by the people of British
Columbia. British Columbians do not need another amendment designed to turn a serious debate
into a partisan morality play. They need a Legislature that understands the real-world
consequences of the decisions it makes. That is what this motion is about, and that
is why I cannot support this amendment. I fully support the original motion as written.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Agri-food industry
It's my privilege today to introduce Trevor and Karen Stevenson and their son, Dash,
from the Comox Valley. They are extremely active in the agricultural community with
Comox Valley Farmers Institute. Would the House make them, please, feel very welcome.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public access, Public administration
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I think that's an excellent reminder because that is exactly
what this government should be doing with this terrible piece of legislation that
is an absolute affront to openness and transparency in the province of British Columbia. On that note, I rise in support of the motion before this House to kill this bill,
that the motion for second reading of Bill 9, entitled the Freedom of Information
and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, be amended by deleting the word "now"
and substituting "six months hence," because that is exactly what this bill deserves. Currently in the province of British Columbia, six months is not enough time to get
an FOI return back. There are bigger problems than this bill is willing to address.
What this bill does is hide the truth from British Columbians across this province.
That should make everyone in British Columbia and in this House, on both sides of
this House, extremely worried. As I said in my previous speech on Bill 9, it'll be
a very different story when the Birkenstock is on the other foot. Now, what we need to do with this bill is scrap it, because we've seen from this minister
that changes are dramatic and changes are clearly required. This amendment that she's
proposing absolutely goes to the core of why the motion is so critically important
in this House today. It tacitly admits that this government got it wrong, that this
bill does not deserve to see the light of day, that it is not worthy of consideration
in this House and it does not fix the fundamental problems with freedom of information
in this province. This bill should not proceed. If it does proceed, it should proceed six months hence.
As Madam Speaker says, that will effectively kill this bill. That's the motion, that
is the argument, and I intend to keep coming back to it because this House should
not be distracted from the central point. The question before us is not whether the minister can still stand up and pretend
this was all a misunderstanding, that this was: "It just slipped through. It was a
clerical error. I didn't see it." The question before us is whether Bill 9 should
move now or whether this government should be told to sit down, take six months and
come back with something that is workable for British Columbians, is in the benefit
of British Columbians and is in the benefit of transparency for democracy in the province
of B.C. This government doesn't need this motion to do that. This government could kill this
bill today on its own merits. They've admitted as much in their proposed amendments.
The government has already admitted the bill is a disaster, and that's what the amendments
mean. They can dress it up in whatever lipstick they like. They can call them clarifications,
they can call them targeted adjustments, they can call them minor refinements, tweaks,
nibbling around the edges, but the House knows exactly what they are. They are an admission, an admission that the bill they introduced was not ready to
see the light of day, should never have seen the light of day and was a mistake in
the first place. Now this government is desperate to try and show that they still
have the confidence of this House. I can tell you, Madam Speaker, they do not. This is an admission that this government, on a bill dealing with the public's right
to know, still couldn't get it right the first time. And when a government has to
start patching a freedom-of-information bill while second reading is still underway,
that is not a sign the House should hurry up and just pass it. It's a sign that the
House should say: "Not now. Six months hence." Six months is not some procedural gimmick. Six months is what seriousness looks like
in the development of a bill, seriousness that was clearly not considered when this
bill was in its draft form. Six months means the government stops trying to repair
a bad bill in midair. Six months means it goes back to the drawing board, gets the
proper scrutiny that it should've had on the Six months means it goes back to the drawing board, gets the proper scrutiny that
it should have had on the first pass and comes back to this House in a way that is
presentable and acceptable to both the opposition and the people of British Columbia. Six months means it finally does the work that it should have done before, dragging
Bill 9 into this chamber unready. And six months means the public gets a chance to
examine something more than a rushed first draft and a panicked set of amendments
that they only came up with after massive push-back from members likely in their own
caucus — to the affront that this bill is to the democratic process and openness and
transparency in the province of British Columbia. That is why this motion matters, because this bill was not brought here in a condition
that deserves passage. Not now, but if the government chooses, they can fix this bill
and bring it back for real consideration. We do need to address problems with the
FOI system, backlogs in FOI. Right now, that system is truly broken. This government
cannot even disclose proactive disclosure on time. They are now three months behind.
Ministerial calendars — hidden. Non-compete contracts — hidden. This is not a government acting in good faith in the best interests of British Columbians.
This is a government that is desperate to change the channel. They think that these
amendments may do that. I am sorry to say to everybody in this House that that is
not the case. What needs to happen is this motion needs to be voted on. It needs to
pass, and this bill needs to be taken off the table and treated exactly the way it
should — shoved in a closet or taken to a draft table and started again. This bill proves the government thought it could get away with broad, vague, overreaching
language, slip it through the net, and only when people pushed back did the government
begin to retreat on this bill. That is not thoughtful law-making. That is a government
desperate to hide its failures. That is political damage control in a state I have
not seen since taking this House. And there has been some truly flawed legislation
put before this House. This bill takes the cake. That is why this House should tell the government: "You do not get to salvage this
on the fly. You get to come back in six months and try again." Let us remember what freedom of information actually is. It is not some annoying administrative
burden. It is not some nuisance process for troublesome citizens. It is not an inconvenience
for ministers who would rather hide their calendars and their non-compete contracts
and internal records that may be damaging to the narrative that the government has
decided to spin. It is one of the only real tools the public has, and the opposition has, to force
truth out of the government. That is what it is. It is how journalists get past the
talking points and partial truths of press releases. It's how researchers get past
the spin and partial statistics of press releases. It's how opposition members get
beyond the press conference and into the actual documents, where the rubber meets
the road, where the promises meet results. It's how British Columbians find out what
government knew, when they knew it and what they were trying to hide. That is why governments that are short on answers are often tempted to tighten control,
especially as we see the end of a reign coming. All of those decisions are now on
the government of the day. And when the government of the day was the government also
of yesterday, the chickens tend to come home to roost. That's what Bill 9 looked like from the start, and that's why the answer is not passage
now. The answer is six months hence. If this bill were sound, the amendments proposed
by the minister would not be appearing in the order papers today. If this bill were
careful, these amendments would not be appearing today. If this bill were well drafted,
well-thought-out, and well rounded, these amendments would not be appearing today. If this bill sought to remedy the description that we heard initially from this minister,
we would not be having this discussion today. But it did not do that. This bill attacked the democratic process, openness and transparency in the province
of British Columbia, and now this government is desperately trying to change the channel
and turn the page. If this bill genuinely reflected the kind of transparency regime this government claims
that it wants, then this House would not be watching ministers scurry around trying
to sand down the roughest edges before a critical vote. And that is the point. The
amendment does not save this bill. That is the point. The amendment does not save this bill. They condemn this bill.
This motion condemns this bill. They tell this House the government itself knows the
original version couldn't withstand basic scrutiny. And if the original version could
not withstand scrutiny, then this House should not move it now. It should send it
away six months hence. One of the clearest examples of why six months is necessary is health care. Because
if there's one field in this province where freedom of information is not theoretical,
it is certainly health care. In health care, freedom of information is often the only
way to get past the slogans and net numbers. It is the only way to get past the ministerial
talking points. It is the only way to compare what government says publicly with what
its own internal records say privately. It casts a light on the state of the system.
That is information that should be the right of all British Columbians to access. Now what is the reality in health care today? Not timely access, not openness, not
a system functioning the way the law says it should. We are seeing health care FOIs
take roughly eight months to come back. Some, years. Eight months is not a modern
system of FOI disclosure. That is not a responsive, open, and transparent government
that is responsible to those that pay their bills and elected them to be here. That
is not transparency. That is a backlog so severe that the truth arrives after the
damage is done. What did this government decide to do in the face of that compounding failure? Did
it prove it could meet the standard already in the law before trying to change the
law itself? No. It brought forward Bill 9. That is exactly why this bill should not
proceed now. It should go away six months hence. The bill was already offensive enough on the formal FOI side, but even proactive disclosure,
as I described earlier, is falling behind. Three months behind in areas where government
is supposed to be proactively putting information into the public domain so that the
FOI system, which isn't collapsed, which is the point of this bill, can be avoided. If the government comes out and gives you the data, guess what goes away? The need
for freedom of information requests. Transparency should be the default setting of
government. We should not have to kick, pull and scream for basic disclosure out of
government. What did this government decide to do in the face of the failure of these backlogs?
Three months behind. This government now wants to tell the House that what it really needs to do is a new
bill touching access law. Nope. What it needs is six months to go back and explain
why it cannot even operate the system that it already has. That is why the motion
says "six months hence." It kills this horrible, undemocratic bill. Health care is where we have used FOI again and again to shine a light on what this
government would rather leave in the dark. FOI is how both this opposition and members
of the public have brought records forward on emergency room closures. FOI is how
briefing materials, internal warnings, staffing realities and operational failures
come into clear focus. FOI is how the public gets beyond the stagecraft and the politics
and into the substance. Without FOI, people get the headline. With FOI, they get the truth behind the headline,
which is why this bill is so dangerous and needs to be killed today. And that is why
these amendments, even now, are simply not good enough. Because the government has
already shown us the instinct behind the bill. The instinct was not openness. The
instinct was not humility. The instinct was not to strengthen trust in our institutions.
The instinct was to manage scrutiny. A government with that instinct should not be rewarded with the passage of a damaging
bill like that now. It should be sent away for six months hence and killed. If this
House needs one more reason why Bill 9 should not proceed, but should be sent away,
the government cannot even manage the freedom of information system that it already
has. And that is not some abstract concern. That is not a theoretical concern. That
is not an opposition invention designed to grab headlines. It's not just us. The Green Party agrees with us. The press agrees with us. What's the saying? Don't pick a fight with people that buy ink by the barrel. Well,
you certainly have picked a fight with a group of people that buy ink by the barrel.
Or bandwidth at this point. And that is the lived reality of people who actually use
the system. The journalists that file those requests, the researchers who track That is the lived reality of people who actually use the system — the journalists
that file those requests, the researchers who track ministries, the advocates who
are trying to get records. The ordinary citizen is just trying to find out what the
government is doing in their name with their dollars. They're actively tracking these
delays. Many people have reached out to me over the FOI requests. Many people who do deep
dives into the state of health care in British Columbia and rely on a functional,
efficient and reasonably expedient FOI system so that we can have eyes on what is
going on in our province. What are they finding? That FOI returns are not coming back
in anything close to a reasonable time — not 30 days, not promptly, not in a way that
makes the right to freedom of access meaningful. They are stretching out towards a
year — eight months, on average. Just stop to think about what eight months are. We're only asking for a six-month
delay with this motion. Eight months to get records from a government in a system
that is supposed to be built around timely public access. Eight months is not a delay.
Eight months is a culture that has been built by this government. Eight months is
not a hiccup; eight months is a management failure. Eight months means the truth arrives
after the decision is made, after the damage is done, after the 24-7 headline has
moved on, and after the minister has already stood up in this House, delivered talking
points, and hopes that that information doesn't get out in time to damage them further. That is not access to information; that is access to stale information. It does not
help steer decisions, it does not improve transparency, and it needs to be fixed.
That is a government making sure that by the time the records arrive, they're no longer
politically dangerous. I refer back to many conversations about limousine rides, gift cards and the like.
I know it's a sensitive topic in this time of austerity with a $13.3 billion budget.
Now the same government wants this House to believe that what we really need is Bill
9. No, what the system needs is not Bill 9. What the system needs is a six-month delay
— and as the Speaker so rightly pointed out — which would, in effect, kill this terribly
damaging bill in the province of B.C., to the benefit of all British Columbians. Six months to ask a very basic question. If returns are stretching to eight months
already, why is the government touching the law before it fixes the administration?
Perhaps that's the real issue here. Perhaps what this government should be looking
at is not how to give the department more tools, more language and more direction
for cover. Perhaps what we should be looking at is the management of the department
itself, because if the people using the system are telling us that requests are taking
the better part of a year, then something is clearly wrong with the FOI system. That is how this bill was sold to this House. "We're going to fix the system. This
will speed it up." What was buried in there was: "We're going to speed it up by just
doing less, because you don't deserve the information. We are not willing to be transparent
with the province of British Columbia. We are ashamed of our record, and we are going
to hide from it." Very, very shocking, very sad, but very telling of a government
that is out of ideas and running from its very own record. If people are using the system are telling you that these requests are going wrong,
you need to deal with it. Is it staffing? Is it workflow? Is it prioritizing FOIs?
Badly wrong — something is badly wrong with the basic administrative culture of our
freedom-of-information system here in B.C., because the default setting on government
should be transparency, not obfuscation. That is before we even get to proactive disclosure. I'm going to keep hitting on that,
because I know it's a sensitive subject for many ministers here. Proactive disclosure
is supposed to reduce the pressure on the formal FOI system. That is the theory of
proactive disclosure. If a government proactively releases materials in a timely way,
then fewer people need to file far-reaching requests in the first place. And the people
that do have an idea of where to start looking. If there's a questionable meeting in a ministerial calendar, they can request those
records. If there is a meeting with a drug company, they can specify they would like
information on that meeting, not go on a broad, sweeping, dragnet search, wasting
people's time. I will agree with you. I have gotten many, many FOIs back myself that were a complete
waste of both my and the bureaucrats' time. You know why? Because the document I knew
was there that I had a copy of, which was handed to me by a concerned citizen, was
covered in nothing but black lines. That If government proactively releases materials in a timely way, then fewer people need
to find those requests in the first place. But what's happening there? That is behind,
too, not by a few days, not by a harmless little lag, again, by nearly three months.
Three months behind on proactive — and I'll say the word again — proactive disclosure. We've got the front door jammed up, the side door is now jammed up, and the formal
FOI process is bogged down. The proactive disclosure stream is bogged down, and the
government's answer is not to clean the house, not to tighten management, not to restore
performance, not to properly resource the department, not to ask what on earth is
happening — in a department run by a former deputy minister, I might add, from Newfoundland
— who clearly understands the troublesome, pesky annoyance of what can happen when
disclosure is set to open as a default. This government's answer was Bill 9, which is why this motion — and I'll come back
to it so I do not get called out of order — looks to push this six months hence and
kill this terrible, destructive bill. That is one more reason that this House should
support this motion and say that this bill should not proceed now, because six months
would allow this House and the public to ask the questions that really matter. Consult
the stakeholders that have been affected. Do the actual work on this bill to get it
right. If we have a problem with the process and the bureaucracy operating behind this bill
and the function of this bill in reality, let's have that conversation. But let's
not do it behind closed doors. Having a closed-door conversation on a freedom-of-information
bill is, to say the least.... I'll leave it there. Why are the requests taking eight months? That's a question that this government should
ask. Who is tracking that performance? Again, we should be asking that. Who is accountable
for that performance? Well, actually, in fact, it is this government that is responsible
for that performance. And that performance is that proactive disclosure is now taking
three months. Ministerial calendars, non-compete contracts and the like, all forcibly
and legislatively required to be disclosed, are now being dragged. That is not including
FOIs that are just in the queue taking eight months. That is ministers hiding. Hiding from public scrutiny. You should be ashamed, truly,
truly ashamed. Before any of that has been honestly dealt with, is this government asking for legislative
changes instead of managerial compliance? Are we trying to legislate changes onto
a department that what they really need is new management? I think that's a question
we should ask, and I believe six months may be the appropriate time required to answer
that question. I did google a few things on my way over here. I was looking for some good examples
of things that would take six months to do. I've got some very interesting examples.
Dostoyevsky wrote The Gambler in 26 days. That's a fairly considerable and lengthy classic. The Apollo 8 planning
and training mission to the moon was completed in four months, much less than the
six months we're asking for here. The Alaska Highway took just over six months, at
7.7, 1,700 kilometres from border to border. They got an entire highway built. I believe we can probably fix this flawed legislation in six months, bring it back
and pass it. Because if we've got enough time to fight a war, land on the moon, negotiate
an armistice, write a novel, we should probably be able to fix a fairly simple, straightforward
housekeeping bill that should have been a fairly straightforward housekeeping bill.
But that is not what this bill was. This bill tried to backdoor opaqueness and remove scrutiny on a government desperate,
desperate to change the page. If that's the case, this bill should not proceed now. It should come back, if it comes back at all, six months hence, after the government
has demonstrated that it can manage the system it already controls before it dares
ask this House for more breathing room and room to manoeuvre, more ability to cover
up what they're already covering up, more ability to hide from their own performance
problems. If the existing system is taking eight months to over a year to produce basic records
of government and proactive disclosure is now three months behind, then the first
reform this government should undertake is not If the existing system is taking eight months to over a year to produce basic records
of government, and proactive disclosure is now three months behind, then the first
reform this government should undertake is not legislative; it's managerial, it's
administrative, and it is cultural. Until that work is done, this House should be
very wary of letting this government touch this important law at all — again, not
now; six months hence. Another reason we need six months is because this file was already studied. This is
not a new issue to this House. There was a special committee. There was a 2022 report
by that special committee. There were already recommendations on how to improve British
Columbia's access and privacy laws, while strengthening transparency and accountability. What possible excuse does this government have? This government issued that 2022 report.
This House loves to use the Wayback Machine, so let's go way back to 2022 and ask
ourselves who the government was in 2022. Certainly, I feel dusting that off might
be a start. It cannot say there was no roadmap. It cannot say there was no prior work. It cannot
say no one had thought seriously about FOI reform. All of that had already existed,
which means the case for six months is even stronger. The problem was not a lack of
time before introduction; the problem was that the government had used that time badly. Even if some of those recommendations made it into Bill 9, this government decided
to try and back-door the ability to hide more information from British Columbians,
not allow more visibility on that information to British Columbians. That is why this
government needs to be punished for their poor decision-making. You don't go to war
with people that buy ink by the gallon. So when the government uses its time badly, this House should not reward it. It should
let that government take another six months to try and do the job properly. I want
to keep tying this back to the original motion, because I know the government members
will try to pull the debate somewhere else. They will want to say, "Well, surely the member agrees that some reform is needed."
Yes, I don't disagree. I don't disagree that reform is needed, but that reform needs
to improve transparency, not reduce transparency. "Well, surely the member sees some merit in in parts of the bill." That's not the
question before us today. The question is whether this bill should proceed now in
the shape that it's in, and that answer is clearly no. The minister has admitted that
that's clearly no, by tabling amendments before committee has even started, trying
desperately to get an independent or two to jump on board and prop this government
up. We're not going to let you do that. We're not going to let you do that. The amendments prove the concerns of this side of the House were real. The concerns
of all the stakeholders were real. Because those concerns were real, this House should
not proceed now; it should proceed six months hence. That is the motion, that is the
test, and that is the standard. One of the most revealing things here has been tone. The government's tone has not
been grateful that people read the bill carefully. It has not been reflective; it
has not been humble; it has been irritated that people noticed, irritated that people
objected, irritated that the broad overreach in this bill was actually recognized
for exactly what it was — a government trying to hide from their terrible, decades-long
record and hide from British Columbians. Now having tabled amendments, the government still wants to act like it's no big deal:
"Nothing serious here, nothing to see." This pretty much describes Bill 9 in a nutshell:
"Nothing to see here, just a simple housekeeping bill, just affecting the transparency
that we're terrible at, by default, and that now we're not even doing by legislated
proactive disclosure. No, no, we'll just try to slide a few more so we can delay and
defer longer." That is why, Madam Speaker, the six months' delay, as you said, kills this bill. That is exactly what this House needs to do. This House needs to accept this motion,
kill this bill, go back to the drawing board and come back to British Columbians with
something that works in the benefit of all British Columbians, not just government,
because this side of the House believes that the default setting of government should
be open and transparent. You are responsible for the finances and the decisions being
made here, but it is the people of British Columbia that will keep you honest. Honesty is driven by the ability for the citizens to access information in a timely,
meaningful way, to ensure that you're not hiding behind press releases; you're hiding
behind deliverables. On that, this government has failed. By every measure in health care, things are going backwards in health care. Things
are going backwards in affordability. Food bank use is probably the only By every measure in health care, things are going backwards in health care. Things
are going backwards in affordability. Food bank use is probably the only metric that
is rising rapidly under this British Columbian government currently. So in conclusion, I fully support this motion, and I believe that this government
has the opportunity to not take a step forward that they ring a bell that they will
be unable to ring should they pass this terrible bill. You will wear that, and the
worst part about it is the next government will have the same lack of transparency
applied do it and you will be the ones that laid the trap.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Indigenous governments
I think we may have a different definition of clear. Another court case is in front of the courts now due to this government's inaction
on DRIPA. The Lillooet First Nation owns the Rockford hydro project near Whistler
and are unhappy with the terms brought by this government. They claimed B.C. Hydro
failed to consult and are now taking this government to court again. Using DRIPA, the Lillooet are demanding a whopping 48 percent increase in their power
generation payment because they are First Nation–owned. DRIPA is consistently being
used as a weapon in courts in this province when talks break down with this government. To the Minister of Indigenous Relations, because we now have to guess, is this one of the 20 court cases amended due to the
Gitxaała decision?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Elderly care, Health care, Health care facilities
I rise to respond to the amendment from the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville. Frankly, this amendment is exactly the problem this motion is trying to address. The
motion before this House is simple. It says elected officials who make billion-dollar
decisions on behalf of British Columbians should have a basic understanding of economics,
public finance, debt, deficits, inflation, productivity and the cost of government
decisions. That should not be controversial to this House. But instead of debating that reasonable proposition, the government has done what
it so often does in this place. It has tried to turn a practical debate into a wedge
issue. It has tried to change the channel. It has tried to make out a basic motion
to be something far darker than it really is — the absolute horror of basic economics
education. But this motion is not about ideology. This is about competence. Nowhere is that more obvious than in health care. This government has spent years
announcing inputs — more money, more plans, more strategies, more press releases,
more ribbon cuttings. But the outputs tell a very different story. Emergency rooms
are still closing in rural British Columbia. Seniors are still stuck in hospital beds
because long-term-care capacity doesn't exist. According to the seniors advocate,
more than 7,000 British Columbians were waiting for long-term care in 2025. It is
now 7,800 this year, an average wait time of over a year. This is what happens when government confuses spending with results. A government
can spend more and deliver less. It can announce more and build less. It can hire
more administrators and still leave patients waiting, seniors stranded and families
desperate. That is why economic literacy matters, because debt has to be serviced. Deficits have
consequences. Capital delays cost money. When government mismanages major projects,
that is not government money being wasted. It is money earned by the people of British
Columbia. British Columbians do not need another amendment designed to turn a serious debate
into a partisan morality play. They need a Legislature that understands the real-world
consequences of the decisions it makes. That is what this motion is about, and that
is why I cannot support this amendment. I fully support the original motion as written.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Health care
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I think that's an excellent reminder because that is exactly
what this government should be doing with this terrible piece of legislation that
is an absolute affront to openness and transparency in the province of British Columbia. On that note, I rise in support of the motion before this House to kill this bill,
that the motion for second reading of Bill 9, entitled the Freedom of Information
and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, be amended by deleting the word "now"
and substituting "six months hence," because that is exactly what this bill deserves. Currently in the province of British Columbia, six months is not enough time to get
an FOI return back. There are bigger problems than this bill is willing to address.
What this bill does is hide the truth from British Columbians across this province.
That should make everyone in British Columbia and in this House, on both sides of
this House, extremely worried. As I said in my previous speech on Bill 9, it'll be
a very different story when the Birkenstock is on the other foot. Now, what we need to do with this bill is scrap it, because we've seen from this minister
that changes are dramatic and changes are clearly required. This amendment that she's
proposing absolutely goes to the core of why the motion is so critically important
in this House today. It tacitly admits that this government got it wrong, that this
bill does not deserve to see the light of day, that it is not worthy of consideration
in this House and it does not fix the fundamental problems with freedom of information
in this province. This bill should not proceed. If it does proceed, it should proceed six months hence.
As Madam Speaker says, that will effectively kill this bill. That's the motion, that
is the argument, and I intend to keep coming back to it because this House should
not be distracted from the central point. The question before us is not whether the minister can still stand up and pretend
this was all a misunderstanding, that this was: "It just slipped through. It was a
clerical error. I didn't see it." The question before us is whether Bill 9 should
move now or whether this government should be told to sit down, take six months and
come back with something that is workable for British Columbians, is in the benefit
of British Columbians and is in the benefit of transparency for democracy in the province
of B.C. This government doesn't need this motion to do that. This government could kill this
bill today on its own merits. They've admitted as much in their proposed amendments.
The government has already admitted the bill is a disaster, and that's what the amendments
mean. They can dress it up in whatever lipstick they like. They can call them clarifications,
they can call them targeted adjustments, they can call them minor refinements, tweaks,
nibbling around the edges, but the House knows exactly what they are. They are an admission, an admission that the bill they introduced was not ready to
see the light of day, should never have seen the light of day and was a mistake in
the first place. Now this government is desperate to try and show that they still
have the confidence of this House. I can tell you, Madam Speaker, they do not. This is an admission that this government, on a bill dealing with the public's right
to know, still couldn't get it right the first time. And when a government has to
start patching a freedom-of-information bill while second reading is still underway,
that is not a sign the House should hurry up and just pass it. It's a sign that the
House should say: "Not now. Six months hence." Six months is not some procedural gimmick. Six months is what seriousness looks like
in the development of a bill, seriousness that was clearly not considered when this
bill was in its draft form. Six months means the government stops trying to repair
a bad bill in midair. Six months means it goes back to the drawing board, gets the
proper scrutiny that it should've had on the Six months means it goes back to the drawing board, gets the proper scrutiny that
it should have had on the first pass and comes back to this House in a way that is
presentable and acceptable to both the opposition and the people of British Columbia. Six months means it finally does the work that it should have done before, dragging
Bill 9 into this chamber unready. And six months means the public gets a chance to
examine something more than a rushed first draft and a panicked set of amendments
that they only came up with after massive push-back from members likely in their own
caucus — to the affront that this bill is to the democratic process and openness and
transparency in the province of British Columbia. That is why this motion matters, because this bill was not brought here in a condition
that deserves passage. Not now, but if the government chooses, they can fix this bill
and bring it back for real consideration. We do need to address problems with the
FOI system, backlogs in FOI. Right now, that system is truly broken. This government
cannot even disclose proactive disclosure on time. They are now three months behind.
Ministerial calendars — hidden. Non-compete contracts — hidden. This is not a government acting in good faith in the best interests of British Columbians.
This is a government that is desperate to change the channel. They think that these
amendments may do that. I am sorry to say to everybody in this House that that is
not the case. What needs to happen is this motion needs to be voted on. It needs to
pass, and this bill needs to be taken off the table and treated exactly the way it
should — shoved in a closet or taken to a draft table and started again. This bill proves the government thought it could get away with broad, vague, overreaching
language, slip it through the net, and only when people pushed back did the government
begin to retreat on this bill. That is not thoughtful law-making. That is a government
desperate to hide its failures. That is political damage control in a state I have
not seen since taking this House. And there has been some truly flawed legislation
put before this House. This bill takes the cake. That is why this House should tell the government: "You do not get to salvage this
on the fly. You get to come back in six months and try again." Let us remember what freedom of information actually is. It is not some annoying administrative
burden. It is not some nuisance process for troublesome citizens. It is not an inconvenience
for ministers who would rather hide their calendars and their non-compete contracts
and internal records that may be damaging to the narrative that the government has
decided to spin. It is one of the only real tools the public has, and the opposition has, to force
truth out of the government. That is what it is. It is how journalists get past the
talking points and partial truths of press releases. It's how researchers get past
the spin and partial statistics of press releases. It's how opposition members get
beyond the press conference and into the actual documents, where the rubber meets
the road, where the promises meet results. It's how British Columbians find out what
government knew, when they knew it and what they were trying to hide. That is why governments that are short on answers are often tempted to tighten control,
especially as we see the end of a reign coming. All of those decisions are now on
the government of the day. And when the government of the day was the government also
of yesterday, the chickens tend to come home to roost. That's what Bill 9 looked like from the start, and that's why the answer is not passage
now. The answer is six months hence. If this bill were sound, the amendments proposed
by the minister would not be appearing in the order papers today. If this bill were
careful, these amendments would not be appearing today. If this bill were well drafted,
well-thought-out, and well rounded, these amendments would not be appearing today. If this bill sought to remedy the description that we heard initially from this minister,
we would not be having this discussion today. But it did not do that. This bill attacked the democratic process, openness and transparency in the province
of British Columbia, and now this government is desperately trying to change the channel
and turn the page. If this bill genuinely reflected the kind of transparency regime this government claims
that it wants, then this House would not be watching ministers scurry around trying
to sand down the roughest edges before a critical vote. And that is the point. The
amendment does not save this bill. That is the point. The amendment does not save this bill. They condemn this bill.
This motion condemns this bill. They tell this House the government itself knows the
original version couldn't withstand basic scrutiny. And if the original version could
not withstand scrutiny, then this House should not move it now. It should send it
away six months hence. One of the clearest examples of why six months is necessary is health care. Because
if there's one field in this province where freedom of information is not theoretical,
it is certainly health care. In health care, freedom of information is often the only
way to get past the slogans and net numbers. It is the only way to get past the ministerial
talking points. It is the only way to compare what government says publicly with what
its own internal records say privately. It casts a light on the state of the system.
That is information that should be the right of all British Columbians to access. Now what is the reality in health care today? Not timely access, not openness, not
a system functioning the way the law says it should. We are seeing health care FOIs
take roughly eight months to come back. Some, years. Eight months is not a modern
system of FOI disclosure. That is not a responsive, open, and transparent government
that is responsible to those that pay their bills and elected them to be here. That
is not transparency. That is a backlog so severe that the truth arrives after the
damage is done. What did this government decide to do in the face of that compounding failure? Did
it prove it could meet the standard already in the law before trying to change the
law itself? No. It brought forward Bill 9. That is exactly why this bill should not
proceed now. It should go away six months hence. The bill was already offensive enough on the formal FOI side, but even proactive disclosure,
as I described earlier, is falling behind. Three months behind in areas where government
is supposed to be proactively putting information into the public domain so that the
FOI system, which isn't collapsed, which is the point of this bill, can be avoided. If the government comes out and gives you the data, guess what goes away? The need
for freedom of information requests. Transparency should be the default setting of
government. We should not have to kick, pull and scream for basic disclosure out of
government. What did this government decide to do in the face of the failure of these backlogs?
Three months behind. This government now wants to tell the House that what it really needs to do is a new
bill touching access law. Nope. What it needs is six months to go back and explain
why it cannot even operate the system that it already has. That is why the motion
says "six months hence." It kills this horrible, undemocratic bill. Health care is where we have used FOI again and again to shine a light on what this
government would rather leave in the dark. FOI is how both this opposition and members
of the public have brought records forward on emergency room closures. FOI is how
briefing materials, internal warnings, staffing realities and operational failures
come into clear focus. FOI is how the public gets beyond the stagecraft and the politics
and into the substance. Without FOI, people get the headline. With FOI, they get the truth behind the headline,
which is why this bill is so dangerous and needs to be killed today. And that is why
these amendments, even now, are simply not good enough. Because the government has
already shown us the instinct behind the bill. The instinct was not openness. The
instinct was not humility. The instinct was not to strengthen trust in our institutions.
The instinct was to manage scrutiny. A government with that instinct should not be rewarded with the passage of a damaging
bill like that now. It should be sent away for six months hence and killed. If this
House needs one more reason why Bill 9 should not proceed, but should be sent away,
the government cannot even manage the freedom of information system that it already
has. And that is not some abstract concern. That is not a theoretical concern. That
is not an opposition invention designed to grab headlines. It's not just us. The Green Party agrees with us. The press agrees with us. What's the saying? Don't pick a fight with people that buy ink by the barrel. Well,
you certainly have picked a fight with a group of people that buy ink by the barrel.
Or bandwidth at this point. And that is the lived reality of people who actually use
the system. The journalists that file those requests, the researchers who track That is the lived reality of people who actually use the system — the journalists
that file those requests, the researchers who track ministries, the advocates who
are trying to get records. The ordinary citizen is just trying to find out what the
government is doing in their name with their dollars. They're actively tracking these
delays. Many people have reached out to me over the FOI requests. Many people who do deep
dives into the state of health care in British Columbia and rely on a functional,
efficient and reasonably expedient FOI system so that we can have eyes on what is
going on in our province. What are they finding? That FOI returns are not coming back
in anything close to a reasonable time — not 30 days, not promptly, not in a way that
makes the right to freedom of access meaningful. They are stretching out towards a
year — eight months, on average. Just stop to think about what eight months are. We're only asking for a six-month
delay with this motion. Eight months to get records from a government in a system
that is supposed to be built around timely public access. Eight months is not a delay.
Eight months is a culture that has been built by this government. Eight months is
not a hiccup; eight months is a management failure. Eight months means the truth arrives
after the decision is made, after the damage is done, after the 24-7 headline has
moved on, and after the minister has already stood up in this House, delivered talking
points, and hopes that that information doesn't get out in time to damage them further. That is not access to information; that is access to stale information. It does not
help steer decisions, it does not improve transparency, and it needs to be fixed.
That is a government making sure that by the time the records arrive, they're no longer
politically dangerous. I refer back to many conversations about limousine rides, gift cards and the like.
I know it's a sensitive topic in this time of austerity with a $13.3 billion budget.
Now the same government wants this House to believe that what we really need is Bill
9. No, what the system needs is not Bill 9. What the system needs is a six-month delay
— and as the Speaker so rightly pointed out — which would, in effect, kill this terribly
damaging bill in the province of B.C., to the benefit of all British Columbians. Six months to ask a very basic question. If returns are stretching to eight months
already, why is the government touching the law before it fixes the administration?
Perhaps that's the real issue here. Perhaps what this government should be looking
at is not how to give the department more tools, more language and more direction
for cover. Perhaps what we should be looking at is the management of the department
itself, because if the people using the system are telling us that requests are taking
the better part of a year, then something is clearly wrong with the FOI system. That is how this bill was sold to this House. "We're going to fix the system. This
will speed it up." What was buried in there was: "We're going to speed it up by just
doing less, because you don't deserve the information. We are not willing to be transparent
with the province of British Columbia. We are ashamed of our record, and we are going
to hide from it." Very, very shocking, very sad, but very telling of a government
that is out of ideas and running from its very own record. If people are using the system are telling you that these requests are going wrong,
you need to deal with it. Is it staffing? Is it workflow? Is it prioritizing FOIs?
Badly wrong — something is badly wrong with the basic administrative culture of our
freedom-of-information system here in B.C., because the default setting on government
should be transparency, not obfuscation. That is before we even get to proactive disclosure. I'm going to keep hitting on that,
because I know it's a sensitive subject for many ministers here. Proactive disclosure
is supposed to reduce the pressure on the formal FOI system. That is the theory of
proactive disclosure. If a government proactively releases materials in a timely way,
then fewer people need to file far-reaching requests in the first place. And the people
that do have an idea of where to start looking. If there's a questionable meeting in a ministerial calendar, they can request those
records. If there is a meeting with a drug company, they can specify they would like
information on that meeting, not go on a broad, sweeping, dragnet search, wasting
people's time. I will agree with you. I have gotten many, many FOIs back myself that were a complete
waste of both my and the bureaucrats' time. You know why? Because the document I knew
was there that I had a copy of, which was handed to me by a concerned citizen, was
covered in nothing but black lines. That If government proactively releases materials in a timely way, then fewer people need
to find those requests in the first place. But what's happening there? That is behind,
too, not by a few days, not by a harmless little lag, again, by nearly three months.
Three months behind on proactive — and I'll say the word again — proactive disclosure. We've got the front door jammed up, the side door is now jammed up, and the formal
FOI process is bogged down. The proactive disclosure stream is bogged down, and the
government's answer is not to clean the house, not to tighten management, not to restore
performance, not to properly resource the department, not to ask what on earth is
happening — in a department run by a former deputy minister, I might add, from Newfoundland
— who clearly understands the troublesome, pesky annoyance of what can happen when
disclosure is set to open as a default. This government's answer was Bill 9, which is why this motion — and I'll come back
to it so I do not get called out of order — looks to push this six months hence and
kill this terrible, destructive bill. That is one more reason that this House should
support this motion and say that this bill should not proceed now, because six months
would allow this House and the public to ask the questions that really matter. Consult
the stakeholders that have been affected. Do the actual work on this bill to get it
right. If we have a problem with the process and the bureaucracy operating behind this bill
and the function of this bill in reality, let's have that conversation. But let's
not do it behind closed doors. Having a closed-door conversation on a freedom-of-information
bill is, to say the least.... I'll leave it there. Why are the requests taking eight months? That's a question that this government should
ask. Who is tracking that performance? Again, we should be asking that. Who is accountable
for that performance? Well, actually, in fact, it is this government that is responsible
for that performance. And that performance is that proactive disclosure is now taking
three months. Ministerial calendars, non-compete contracts and the like, all forcibly
and legislatively required to be disclosed, are now being dragged. That is not including
FOIs that are just in the queue taking eight months. That is ministers hiding. Hiding from public scrutiny. You should be ashamed, truly,
truly ashamed. Before any of that has been honestly dealt with, is this government asking for legislative
changes instead of managerial compliance? Are we trying to legislate changes onto
a department that what they really need is new management? I think that's a question
we should ask, and I believe six months may be the appropriate time required to answer
that question. I did google a few things on my way over here. I was looking for some good examples
of things that would take six months to do. I've got some very interesting examples.
Dostoyevsky wrote The Gambler in 26 days. That's a fairly considerable and lengthy classic. The Apollo 8 planning
and training mission to the moon was completed in four months, much less than the
six months we're asking for here. The Alaska Highway took just over six months, at
7.7, 1,700 kilometres from border to border. They got an entire highway built. I believe we can probably fix this flawed legislation in six months, bring it back
and pass it. Because if we've got enough time to fight a war, land on the moon, negotiate
an armistice, write a novel, we should probably be able to fix a fairly simple, straightforward
housekeeping bill that should have been a fairly straightforward housekeeping bill.
But that is not what this bill was. This bill tried to backdoor opaqueness and remove scrutiny on a government desperate,
desperate to change the page. If that's the case, this bill should not proceed now. It should come back, if it comes back at all, six months hence, after the government
has demonstrated that it can manage the system it already controls before it dares
ask this House for more breathing room and room to manoeuvre, more ability to cover
up what they're already covering up, more ability to hide from their own performance
problems. If the existing system is taking eight months to over a year to produce basic records
of government and proactive disclosure is now three months behind, then the first
reform this government should undertake is not If the existing system is taking eight months to over a year to produce basic records
of government, and proactive disclosure is now three months behind, then the first
reform this government should undertake is not legislative; it's managerial, it's
administrative, and it is cultural. Until that work is done, this House should be
very wary of letting this government touch this important law at all — again, not
now; six months hence. Another reason we need six months is because this file was already studied. This is
not a new issue to this House. There was a special committee. There was a 2022 report
by that special committee. There were already recommendations on how to improve British
Columbia's access and privacy laws, while strengthening transparency and accountability. What possible excuse does this government have? This government issued that 2022 report.
This House loves to use the Wayback Machine, so let's go way back to 2022 and ask
ourselves who the government was in 2022. Certainly, I feel dusting that off might
be a start. It cannot say there was no roadmap. It cannot say there was no prior work. It cannot
say no one had thought seriously about FOI reform. All of that had already existed,
which means the case for six months is even stronger. The problem was not a lack of
time before introduction; the problem was that the government had used that time badly. Even if some of those recommendations made it into Bill 9, this government decided
to try and back-door the ability to hide more information from British Columbians,
not allow more visibility on that information to British Columbians. That is why this
government needs to be punished for their poor decision-making. You don't go to war
with people that buy ink by the gallon. So when the government uses its time badly, this House should not reward it. It should
let that government take another six months to try and do the job properly. I want
to keep tying this back to the original motion, because I know the government members
will try to pull the debate somewhere else. They will want to say, "Well, surely the member agrees that some reform is needed."
Yes, I don't disagree. I don't disagree that reform is needed, but that reform needs
to improve transparency, not reduce transparency. "Well, surely the member sees some merit in in parts of the bill." That's not the
question before us today. The question is whether this bill should proceed now in
the shape that it's in, and that answer is clearly no. The minister has admitted that
that's clearly no, by tabling amendments before committee has even started, trying
desperately to get an independent or two to jump on board and prop this government
up. We're not going to let you do that. We're not going to let you do that. The amendments prove the concerns of this side of the House were real. The concerns
of all the stakeholders were real. Because those concerns were real, this House should
not proceed now; it should proceed six months hence. That is the motion, that is the
test, and that is the standard. One of the most revealing things here has been tone. The government's tone has not
been grateful that people read the bill carefully. It has not been reflective; it
has not been humble; it has been irritated that people noticed, irritated that people
objected, irritated that the broad overreach in this bill was actually recognized
for exactly what it was — a government trying to hide from their terrible, decades-long
record and hide from British Columbians. Now having tabled amendments, the government still wants to act like it's no big deal:
"Nothing serious here, nothing to see." This pretty much describes Bill 9 in a nutshell:
"Nothing to see here, just a simple housekeeping bill, just affecting the transparency
that we're terrible at, by default, and that now we're not even doing by legislated
proactive disclosure. No, no, we'll just try to slide a few more so we can delay and
defer longer." That is why, Madam Speaker, the six months' delay, as you said, kills this bill. That is exactly what this House needs to do. This House needs to accept this motion,
kill this bill, go back to the drawing board and come back to British Columbians with
something that works in the benefit of all British Columbians, not just government,
because this side of the House believes that the default setting of government should
be open and transparent. You are responsible for the finances and the decisions being
made here, but it is the people of British Columbia that will keep you honest. Honesty is driven by the ability for the citizens to access information in a timely,
meaningful way, to ensure that you're not hiding behind press releases; you're hiding
behind deliverables. On that, this government has failed. By every measure in health care, things are going backwards in health care. Things
are going backwards in affordability. Food bank use is probably the only By every measure in health care, things are going backwards in health care. Things
are going backwards in affordability. Food bank use is probably the only metric that
is rising rapidly under this British Columbian government currently. So in conclusion, I fully support this motion, and I believe that this government
has the opportunity to not take a step forward that they ring a bell that they will
be unable to ring should they pass this terrible bill. You will wear that, and the
worst part about it is the next government will have the same lack of transparency
applied do it and you will be the ones that laid the trap.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Courts, Legal issues
I think we may have a different definition of clear. Another court case is in front of the courts now due to this government's inaction
on DRIPA. The Lillooet First Nation owns the Rockford hydro project near Whistler
and are unhappy with the terms brought by this government. They claimed B.C. Hydro
failed to consult and are now taking this government to court again. Using DRIPA, the Lillooet are demanding a whopping 48 percent increase in their power
generation payment because they are First Nation–owned. DRIPA is consistently being
used as a weapon in courts in this province when talks break down with this government. To the Minister of Indigenous Relations, because we now have to guess, is this one of the 20 court cases amended due to the
Gitxaała decision?Open source reference