Harman Bhangu · 2026-05

11 recorded contributions

Back to media pack

Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required

Governance: 3 contributions
2026-05-04 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Public administration

I'm here today to speak to Bill 9. I want to walk through it in a way that people
               outside this building would actually understand it, because at the end of the day,
               this is not about legal wording. This is about whether regular people in British Columbia
               can still get straight answers from their own government. I'll say this right off the bat. When you go through this bill clause by clause, this
               is not about improving access. It's about controlling access. People might not read
               the legislation front to back, but they will feel it when they try and get answers
               and are hit with a wall. Before I got here, I worked in trucking, construction, paving, building the projects
               that we need — up at four or five in the morning, long days, real pressure, real accountability.
               And in that world, things are simple. If someone asks you a question, you answer it.
               If something goes wrong, you deal with it. And if you're late, you don't argue about
               what late means. You fix it. That's how the real life works. But what I see in this bill is the exact opposite — more grey area, more wiggle room,
               more ways to delay, more ways to say no. And that matters, because freedom of information
               is one of the only tools people have to actually see what government is doing behind
               closed doors. Journalists rely on it. Citizens rely on it. We rely on it here to hold
               the government accountable. So when the rules around that start changing, we need
               to pay attention. Let's start with clauses 2 and 26. This bill says that an FOI request has to be detailed
               enough so the record can be found in a reasonable amount of time. Nobody is arguing against clarity. Of course, requests should be clear. But here's
               the issue. What is a reasonable amount of time? It's not defined, so who decides this
               — the person asking the questions or the government that might not want to go digging?
               Because now the head of the public body gets to decide whether your request is detailed
               enough. Before, that opinion didn't carry that kind of weight. Now it does. That's a gate.
               That's someone deciding whether your questions even get through the door. Once you
               start putting gates in place, fewer people get through. That's how it works. Now let's move to clause 3. This one matters. We go from without delay to without Now let's move to clause 3. This one matters. We go from "without delay" to "without
               unreasonable delay." That might sound small, but it's not, because "without delay"
               is clear. It means get moving. "Without unreasonable delay" opens the door. What's
               reasonable? A week, a month, three months, six months, a year? Now it becomes a debate,
               and when it becomes a debate, it becomes delay. People are already waiting too long.
               Instead of tightening timelines, this bill loosens them. That's backwards. Clause 5 and clause 6 keep going in the same direction. Instead of working with people
               to fix a request if it's not perfect, we move towards rejecting it. Think about that.
               Instead of helping someone get the information they're asking for, we're building
               a system that makes it easier to say no. That's not service; that's avoidance. Now, clauses 13 and 28, this is where it really starts to matter. These clauses expand
               the ability to disregard requests if they're considered frivolous, vexatious, too
               broad or if they interfere with government operations. Now, I understand the idea.
               No one wants the system abused. But here's the problem. None of those terms are clearly
               defined. What's too broad? If someone is asking big questions about spending, is it too broad?
               If a journalist digs deep, is that interference? If someone keeps asking questions
               because they're not getting answers, is that vexatious? Without clear definitions,
               those words get stretched, and when they get stretched, legitimate questions get pushed
               aside. That is the concern. Clause 7 deals with judicial communications tied to policy. Now, I understand protecting
               sensitive conversations, but again, where is the line? When lines aren't clear, they
               move, and when they move, the public sees less. Clauses 8 through 12 expand on how personal information can be collected and shared
               — more data, more sharing, more systems. I get it. Services are changing. But here
               is the reality. Every time you expand that, you increase risk. People want to know
               where their information is going, who's accessing it and what happens if something
               goes wrong. Trust doesn't come from saying: "Don't worry about it." Trust comes from
               clear rules and strong safeguards. Clause 15 removes the 90-day limit on reviews, so now it can take longer — again,
               longer timelines, more flexibility for the government, less certainty for the people,
               same pattern. Clause 20 brings this idea of a centralized system. Now, maybe that's about efficiency,
               but I've seen centralized systems before. Sometimes they help. Sometimes they just
               make things harder to access and easier to control. So the question is simple: is
               this about helping people or managing the flow of information? Clauses 21 to 22 say some records can be made available without an FOI request. That
               sounds positive, but then there are fees attached. Now we have to ask: are we opening
               access or putting a price on it? Access to your own government should not depend on
               your wallet. I'll just make one quick point here. We've already seen proactive disclosure tools
               paused, and it's still unclear when they're coming back online. When access tools
               are being taken offline on one hand and more discretion is being added on the other,
               people are going to connect those dots. Clause 19 removes early notification around privacy impact assessment. This one also
               matters, because catching problems early is how you avoid bigger problems later. Why
               remove that step? What is there to hide? Why remove an early check that protects people? When I step back and look at this bill as a whole, here's what I see. More When I step back and look at this bill as a whole, here's what I see. More discretion
               from the government, more delay, more grey areas, more ways to just say no. At the
               same time, I don't see anything that clearly makes the system faster or clearer or
               easier to use. That is the issue. Because that is not just policy; this is power.
               FOIs are how people keep government honest. It's how stories come out. It's how decisions
               get questioned. When you make that harder, you shift that balance. People back home aren't asking
               for perfection. They're asking for straight answers. They're asking for transparency.
               They're asking for a system that works. They're asking for a government that doesn't
               hide behind wording, process, when simple questions get asked. Right now this bill
               moves us in the wrong direction. More control, less clarity, more delays, less accountability. I'll say this. This
               bill is really about improving the system, then show people it's going to make responses
               faster. Show people it is going to make access easier. Show people it strengthens
               accountability, because right now that's not clear. What's clear is the government
               gets more room to decide, more room to delay, more room to refuse. That is not what
               people expect. That is not how trust is built, and that is not how accountability
               works. The question is simple: are we making it easier for people to get answers or easier
               for the government to avoid them? Because that's what it's coming down to. I just want to share a little bit about how open information has been a benefit for
               me as an opposition MLA. I have been able to go and track calendars, briefing notes,
               meetings and search them, and you can go back even further. Even when I came into
               this Legislature.... I was elected October 19 of 2024. There was an issue happening
               with the ferry strike at Kootenay Bay in Balfour. I was actually able to, after a
               couple months being elected and in here, and when that situation arose.... I was able
               to go back and look at what ministers, what meetings were happening. I knew there
               was actually a real situation happening there. I actually could get on the ground, go out there, visit those areas and get that information.
               It was very important that that information was accessible. You can also go on there
               and see who ministers have met in the previous weeks, months, after the 60-90 day
               delay when it actually gets posted on open information. You can actually go back and
               research it a bit and figure out who were these ministers meeting with. It can tell
               you what bills might come on the floor, what might happen in certain projects, certain
               situations, and that is very key as an opposition MLA. You need to have access to
               these means because that is how we do our work. When this is restricted, it causes
               more delay in our work. The work that I have is important to British Columbians who have elected me to represent
               them, keep the government to account. This is where the grey area hits in. This is
               where the roadblocks hit. This actually restricts the work as an opposition MLA. It
               slows you down on figuring out what's important in your file, what information you
               need to dig up in certain projects, certain fields that you are actually researching.
               When I came in here, this was a huge tool for me to get in and hit the ground running.
               I was able to research transportation projects. Being the Transportation critic, I could go in there and figure out if there's a project
               that's coming up in the future. I was able to see if the minister has met with people
               who are part of that project. It lets the opposition actually have an insight into
               what the government is doing. Now that is being taken away or delayed. What else is
               it? Maybe we would uncover some more limo rides for ministers. Maybe that is the fear
               on the other side. Maybe it's to hide, who knows.... The World Cup is coming around. There are going to
               be tickets handed out. This would be a way that we could figure out that. But now
               it is being taken away on this side of the aisle. It makes me beg. I've been making a lot of.... I'm very active on my social media. I actually have posted
               the calendar notes. I have posted the briefing notes. At times I feel like this bill
               is to restrict me personally in the work that I am doing This is a real issue. This is something that.... British Columbians, a lot of my friends,
               when I came into this place, said: "Hey, how are you going to hold the government
               to account?" This was one of the main tools. This was a very important tool. I have
               actually gone out and helped explain to my constituents where I get my information
               from, because I think being transparent to British Columbians is a huge reason why
               a lot of the people on this side of the aisle actually stepped up, put their name
               on a ballot and wanted to be in this place. Now all that's been taken away by this government that's afraid of their incompetence,
               the things that they want to hide from us as the opposition, which is really concerning
               to me. You can look at a lot of issues like the Highway 1 project. You can go in there
               and figure out who the ministers are meeting, what's going to happen in the next phase
               of that job. This is very important information. Even on the SkyTrain stuff I've been able to go on there and see who they're meeting
               so I know the progress of it. I know what phase they'll be entering. Are they talking
               to people from phase 2 to phase 3? How is that all connected? You can figure this
               stuff out by looking at the calendar. Now there's a pause on a lot of it, and I wonder why that pause happened. Was it because
               of my colleague from Abbotsford-Mission, who did an amazing job in estimates? The next thing you know, the next day, it's
               shut down. That raises serious concerns on this side of the aisle, because we're here
               to represent the people of our ridings, British Columbians, and now we're not being
               able to do that fully. Every step of the way, where we're trying to make progress and get more efficient,
               actually hold this government to account on some of the stuff that they're trying
               to push through, this creates a serious roadblock on this side. That is something that we really need to think about when bills are being put in place
               through this Legislature. How does it help everyone? How does it help the people at
               home who are wondering why they can't put food on the table? They already feel this
               is the most secretive government. Then when situations like this arise, when bills
               like this get put on the floor, their thoughts and feelings feel confirmed. They are
               afraid of what's going on. This really, really.... At the deep of this bill, I am really just blown away that we
               are actually dealing with a government that wants to hide what they're doing from
               British Columbians and the opposition. It is gravely disturbing. We have known the
               Finance Minister taking limo rides — $6,000. Now I want to know: was there more? This
               putting a pause on it, closing this, would actually restrict us from gaining that
               information. With World Cup around the corner, who knows what kind of frivolous spending is going
               to be done by the other side. We've seen it time and time again, tax dollars wasted
               over and over. This access was a way for us to do our work, figure out.... Maybe if
               there's a delay, so be it. At least the truth would come to light at some point. That is the key here. We want to keep this place accountable. We want bills that pass
               through this House to be vetted and debated and actually have good purpose for British
               Columbians. I don't see that with this bill. All I see is another roadblock, more
               bureaucracy, more red tape, when British Columbians are already facing enough of this.
               I have calls from constituents non-stop asking: "What's going on with Bill 9?" What
               is going on? We've had this project right in the middle of our backyard, Highway 1, forever. We
               want to find out information. Do they even have a proper crossing on 264? How is that going to work? How are the lanes going to work? You can actually try
               and access some of that information through this process, and now that's being taken
               away as well. There area lot of situations here, like FOIs that you can put on certain projects.
               My colleague talked about the bridge in Quesnel. I've been there. I've visited that
               bridge. I'm surprised it's even in operation. That FOI came back, and it showed numerous
               things that are not up to date, up to par. Even with the Taylor Bridge, there were
               FOIs that came in there. There have been numerous FOIs that have come out that have shown there have been situations,
               issues with what's going on, and there is no accountability. When you get rid of this
               process, you're pretty much giving them a free cheque to do whatever you want. That
               is not what British Columbians want. It's not what my constituents want. They want When you get rid of this process, you're pretty much giving them a free cheque to
               do whatever you want. That is not what British Columbians want. It's not what my constituents
               want. They want accountability. They want transparency, especially out of the most
               secret government that they've seen to date in British Columbia. I think these are
               legitimate concerns that people have. I can go on and on, and there's more here. The situation here is British Columbians
               are sick and tired of things being hidden from them, having to go jump through hoops.
               Life is already busy, as it is. People have kids they need to drop off at school,
               pick them up, go do their jobs, take them to sports and everything. And now when they're
               trying to figure out maybe something that might be in someone's line of work, what
               government's doing, you go on there, and there are more delays, more delays, more
               delays. This doesn't help a lot of British Columbians. And in a lot of the situations here
               I have seen the reasoning for, I don't buy it. I know if they were on this side of
               the aisle, they'd be screaming and yelling from the rooftops, saying: "This is a way
               to hide what the Conservatives are doing." We've heard it time and time again from
               the other side. This raises serious concerns, and that's why I'm here to speak on this. It's to actually
               bring some accountability for British Columbians and my constituents who are deeply,
               deeply troubled. I was just at an event on Friday, and I had six people come up to
               me and ask me what is going on with Bill 9. To us, this seems a lot of parallel to
               what the federal government is doing, restricting things on social media and other
               aspects, so it is a big concern. Now, I know there are some amendments coming that we'll debate in the next stage.
               We'll see how things are going to roll out, and we'll have some discussion around
               it. But the thing is that British Columbians are looking for transparency in a time
               where it seems to be nonexistent. That's why I feel this bill has been brought in
               to hide what the government is doing. It's been brought in to mitigate the work the opposition has been doing. We have been
               doing great work on this side of the aisle. Right now the reason why we were able
               to do a lot of that work is by looking up the details of what's happened. Who are
               these ministers meeting? What are their briefing notes? What are they actually doing? Now we can go in.... Right now we have accessibility, but in the future if we don't, this is going to hinder
               the work that the opposition MLAs are here to do. That is why I will not support this
               bill. I cannot support this bill, and a lot of issues continue to rise. Every time
               one of these amendments gets put in that they say they will do, you can't take it
               at face value here, because we just do not get how this government wants to continuously
               hide things from British Columbians, hide things from us on the opposition. I know there was a word said,  "Hey, that never happened, limo rides," but let's be
               clear. The Canadian Taxpayers Federation has pulled the FOIs. They have made this
               public knowledge, and we know it was a fact. We know it happened, but what are we
               going to do in the future to try and mitigate these situations? That is the question
               at hand here. In final, I cannot support this bill that would restrict the opposition. It would
               make it harder for British Columbians to access information. That is just not a bill
               that I can actually support in this House. I came into this House to bring transparency,
               to change the way politics has been done, to talk to constituents, educate them on
               bills, let them know what is coming down the pipeline in this chamber. I've seen it time and time again. Before I was a politician, I always wondered how
               decisions are made here. Are British Columbians even consulted? This bill clearly
               shows you they are not being consulted. They are being left in the dust. They are
               being left to wonder what's going on, what their government is doing. Pretty soon they'll be wondering what their opposition is doing, because the opposition
               won't have the information to access everything that the government is doing so we
               can actually hold them to account. That is why I cannot support this bill, and I'm
               really against this bill. I honestly, at times, feel like this bill was brought in place to restrict the work
               that I've been doing, like I've said before on my social medias. I have brought in
               threads. I've posted threads. I've put in all the work. The reason why I do that work
               is because I truly believe British Columbians deserve to know what's going on. When
               there are certain The reason why I do that work is because I truly believe British Columbians deserve
               to know what's going on. When there are certain people being brought in the House,
               and they're being introduced, then later on, a few weeks later, we see bills being
               tabled. It's a great concern. That is why, once again, I will say it time and time again, for the record. I cannot
               support this bill. I will not support this bill. This bill should never have been
               put in place by the government.
Open source reference
2026-05-19 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Public service

I am pleased to welcome today Joseph Latam to the House. Joe serves as my constituency
               assistant, where he does excellent work supporting constituents, helping ensure that
               people in our community are heard, assisted and served well. He is thoughtful, and
               he is dedicated to public service and the future of this province. But he will unfortunately be leaving at the end of the summer. This fall, Joe will
               be beginning his master of public policy at the University of Calgary — an impressive
               achievement, and the next step in what I am certain will be a bright future. It's
               always encouraging to see young, talented people continuing to commit themselves in
               major studies and policy. Would the House really make Joe feel welcome?
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Public sector

I want to follow up on something from the transportation estimates. When we left that discussion, the Minister of Transportation made it that clear long-term
               funding for TransLink is being worked on by the Ministry of Finance. That's why I'm
               here asking today. Right now, there's been a short-term fix, but everyone knows there still needs to
               be a real plan to pay for this going forward. That is supposed to be in place by 2027.
               People want to know, especially with talk around a potential election later this year,
               whether this is going to mean a road tax. My question  is: can the Minister outline what specific revenue tools are currently
               under consideration by the Ministry of Finance to address TransLink long-term funding
               requirements?
Open source reference
Transportation: 2 contributions
2026-05-04 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Driving, Trucking industry, Trucks, Vehicles

I rise today to speak in favour of the private member's Bill M217. One thing I want to clarify is.... On the weight stage that the member from Ladysmith-Oceanside had brought up, that was actually agreed upon, and there was an amendment made that
               covered that aspect about gross weight. Being someone that came from the trucking industry, this bill will help. It will help
               with ICBC if there are any accidents, and it helps with safety in a lot of ways. As
               a trucker, you'd be driving straight ahead, and a lot of cars do drive erratically.
               They would cut right in front of you. Most of the time, that would always be "hey,
               blame the trucker" every single time. This would bring clarity. This would actually help the process of ICBC and everything
               else that way. And I feel this bill does cover a lot of issues and a lot of erratic
               driving. It does make people more honest when they're driving. I had a dashcam in mine, and it always reminded you that you need to be a professional
               as a trucker, and this bill does bring professionalism to trucking and the process
               that it is if there was any accident to happen. So I strongly speak in support of
               this bill. As someone that comes from the industry, someone that's lived the life
               of a trucker, this bill helps. I think all members in this House should be supporting a bill like this that actually
               brings transparency if issues arise. It helps trucker safety and, most importantly,
               helps all British Columbians' safety. That is the missing piece here that I would
               like to highlight. This would bring a lot of clarity if anything was to go wrong. I really would like the whole House to support this bill.
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Public transit, Transport, Transport industry

I want to follow up on something from the transportation estimates. When we left that discussion, the Minister of Transportation made it that clear long-term
               funding for TransLink is being worked on by the Ministry of Finance. That's why I'm
               here asking today. Right now, there's been a short-term fix, but everyone knows there still needs to
               be a real plan to pay for this going forward. That is supposed to be in place by 2027.
               People want to know, especially with talk around a potential election later this year,
               whether this is going to mean a road tax. My question  is: can the Minister outline what specific revenue tools are currently
               under consideration by the Ministry of Finance to address TransLink long-term funding
               requirements?
Open source reference
Community Life: 1 contributions
2026-05-26 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Family

Once again, I have my family in the House. My daughter always gets a birthday shout-out,
               but my son doesn't, having his birthday in July, so I just want to wish my son Bal
               an early birthday. Once again, I want to introduce my mom, Jasvinder Bhangu. She is literally the reason
               why I'm here, all her sacrifices. You see me working hard, staying up late, doing
               all the work I do. I get that drive from my mom. She has truly been a pillar for my
               family, especially when my father passed away — getting married and five months later
               losing my dad. She has been there for me every step of the way. Would the House please make her feel welcome.
Open source reference
Economy & Employment: 1 contributions
2026-05-26 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Public finance, Taxes

I want to follow up on something from the transportation estimates. When we left that discussion, the Minister of Transportation made it that clear long-term
               funding for TransLink is being worked on by the Ministry of Finance. That's why I'm
               here asking today. Right now, there's been a short-term fix, but everyone knows there still needs to
               be a real plan to pay for this going forward. That is supposed to be in place by 2027.
               People want to know, especially with talk around a potential election later this year,
               whether this is going to mean a road tax. My question  is: can the Minister outline what specific revenue tools are currently
               under consideration by the Ministry of Finance to address TransLink long-term funding
               requirements?
Open source reference
Education: 1 contributions
2026-05-28 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Training

There are some hard-working young men in my riding right now that are training. They're
               going to be doing two-a-days; football season is around the corner. The Langley Rams'
               season will be starting in the Canadian Junior Football League, led by head coach
               Kye Todhunter. And Dana Matheson has put together a really good program this year
               — really good coaching staff. I want to wish them the best of luck in their upcoming season. I want to wish them the best of luck in their upcoming season.
Open source reference
Public Safety & Justice: 1 contributions
2026-05-04 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Safety

I rise today to speak in favour of the private member's Bill M217. One thing I want to clarify is.... On the weight stage that the member from Ladysmith-Oceanside had brought up, that was actually agreed upon, and there was an amendment made that
               covered that aspect about gross weight. Being someone that came from the trucking industry, this bill will help. It will help
               with ICBC if there are any accidents, and it helps with safety in a lot of ways. As
               a trucker, you'd be driving straight ahead, and a lot of cars do drive erratically.
               They would cut right in front of you. Most of the time, that would always be "hey,
               blame the trucker" every single time. This would bring clarity. This would actually help the process of ICBC and everything
               else that way. And I feel this bill does cover a lot of issues and a lot of erratic
               driving. It does make people more honest when they're driving. I had a dashcam in mine, and it always reminded you that you need to be a professional
               as a trucker, and this bill does bring professionalism to trucking and the process
               that it is if there was any accident to happen. So I strongly speak in support of
               this bill. As someone that comes from the industry, someone that's lived the life
               of a trucker, this bill helps. I think all members in this House should be supporting a bill like this that actually
               brings transparency if issues arise. It helps trucker safety and, most importantly,
               helps all British Columbians' safety. That is the missing piece here that I would
               like to highlight. This would bring a lot of clarity if anything was to go wrong. I really would like the whole House to support this bill.
Open source reference
Science & Technology: 1 contributions
2026-05-04 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Information, Information dissemination, Information systems

I'm here today to speak to Bill 9. I want to walk through it in a way that people
               outside this building would actually understand it, because at the end of the day,
               this is not about legal wording. This is about whether regular people in British Columbia
               can still get straight answers from their own government. I'll say this right off the bat. When you go through this bill clause by clause, this
               is not about improving access. It's about controlling access. People might not read
               the legislation front to back, but they will feel it when they try and get answers
               and are hit with a wall. Before I got here, I worked in trucking, construction, paving, building the projects
               that we need — up at four or five in the morning, long days, real pressure, real accountability.
               And in that world, things are simple. If someone asks you a question, you answer it.
               If something goes wrong, you deal with it. And if you're late, you don't argue about
               what late means. You fix it. That's how the real life works. But what I see in this bill is the exact opposite — more grey area, more wiggle room,
               more ways to delay, more ways to say no. And that matters, because freedom of information
               is one of the only tools people have to actually see what government is doing behind
               closed doors. Journalists rely on it. Citizens rely on it. We rely on it here to hold
               the government accountable. So when the rules around that start changing, we need
               to pay attention. Let's start with clauses 2 and 26. This bill says that an FOI request has to be detailed
               enough so the record can be found in a reasonable amount of time. Nobody is arguing against clarity. Of course, requests should be clear. But here's
               the issue. What is a reasonable amount of time? It's not defined, so who decides this
               — the person asking the questions or the government that might not want to go digging?
               Because now the head of the public body gets to decide whether your request is detailed
               enough. Before, that opinion didn't carry that kind of weight. Now it does. That's a gate.
               That's someone deciding whether your questions even get through the door. Once you
               start putting gates in place, fewer people get through. That's how it works. Now let's move to clause 3. This one matters. We go from without delay to without Now let's move to clause 3. This one matters. We go from "without delay" to "without
               unreasonable delay." That might sound small, but it's not, because "without delay"
               is clear. It means get moving. "Without unreasonable delay" opens the door. What's
               reasonable? A week, a month, three months, six months, a year? Now it becomes a debate,
               and when it becomes a debate, it becomes delay. People are already waiting too long.
               Instead of tightening timelines, this bill loosens them. That's backwards. Clause 5 and clause 6 keep going in the same direction. Instead of working with people
               to fix a request if it's not perfect, we move towards rejecting it. Think about that.
               Instead of helping someone get the information they're asking for, we're building
               a system that makes it easier to say no. That's not service; that's avoidance. Now, clauses 13 and 28, this is where it really starts to matter. These clauses expand
               the ability to disregard requests if they're considered frivolous, vexatious, too
               broad or if they interfere with government operations. Now, I understand the idea.
               No one wants the system abused. But here's the problem. None of those terms are clearly
               defined. What's too broad? If someone is asking big questions about spending, is it too broad?
               If a journalist digs deep, is that interference? If someone keeps asking questions
               because they're not getting answers, is that vexatious? Without clear definitions,
               those words get stretched, and when they get stretched, legitimate questions get pushed
               aside. That is the concern. Clause 7 deals with judicial communications tied to policy. Now, I understand protecting
               sensitive conversations, but again, where is the line? When lines aren't clear, they
               move, and when they move, the public sees less. Clauses 8 through 12 expand on how personal information can be collected and shared
               — more data, more sharing, more systems. I get it. Services are changing. But here
               is the reality. Every time you expand that, you increase risk. People want to know
               where their information is going, who's accessing it and what happens if something
               goes wrong. Trust doesn't come from saying: "Don't worry about it." Trust comes from
               clear rules and strong safeguards. Clause 15 removes the 90-day limit on reviews, so now it can take longer — again,
               longer timelines, more flexibility for the government, less certainty for the people,
               same pattern. Clause 20 brings this idea of a centralized system. Now, maybe that's about efficiency,
               but I've seen centralized systems before. Sometimes they help. Sometimes they just
               make things harder to access and easier to control. So the question is simple: is
               this about helping people or managing the flow of information? Clauses 21 to 22 say some records can be made available without an FOI request. That
               sounds positive, but then there are fees attached. Now we have to ask: are we opening
               access or putting a price on it? Access to your own government should not depend on
               your wallet. I'll just make one quick point here. We've already seen proactive disclosure tools
               paused, and it's still unclear when they're coming back online. When access tools
               are being taken offline on one hand and more discretion is being added on the other,
               people are going to connect those dots. Clause 19 removes early notification around privacy impact assessment. This one also
               matters, because catching problems early is how you avoid bigger problems later. Why
               remove that step? What is there to hide? Why remove an early check that protects people? When I step back and look at this bill as a whole, here's what I see. More When I step back and look at this bill as a whole, here's what I see. More discretion
               from the government, more delay, more grey areas, more ways to just say no. At the
               same time, I don't see anything that clearly makes the system faster or clearer or
               easier to use. That is the issue. Because that is not just policy; this is power.
               FOIs are how people keep government honest. It's how stories come out. It's how decisions
               get questioned. When you make that harder, you shift that balance. People back home aren't asking
               for perfection. They're asking for straight answers. They're asking for transparency.
               They're asking for a system that works. They're asking for a government that doesn't
               hide behind wording, process, when simple questions get asked. Right now this bill
               moves us in the wrong direction. More control, less clarity, more delays, less accountability. I'll say this. This
               bill is really about improving the system, then show people it's going to make responses
               faster. Show people it is going to make access easier. Show people it strengthens
               accountability, because right now that's not clear. What's clear is the government
               gets more room to decide, more room to delay, more room to refuse. That is not what
               people expect. That is not how trust is built, and that is not how accountability
               works. The question is simple: are we making it easier for people to get answers or easier
               for the government to avoid them? Because that's what it's coming down to. I just want to share a little bit about how open information has been a benefit for
               me as an opposition MLA. I have been able to go and track calendars, briefing notes,
               meetings and search them, and you can go back even further. Even when I came into
               this Legislature.... I was elected October 19 of 2024. There was an issue happening
               with the ferry strike at Kootenay Bay in Balfour. I was actually able to, after a
               couple months being elected and in here, and when that situation arose.... I was able
               to go back and look at what ministers, what meetings were happening. I knew there
               was actually a real situation happening there. I actually could get on the ground, go out there, visit those areas and get that information.
               It was very important that that information was accessible. You can also go on there
               and see who ministers have met in the previous weeks, months, after the 60-90 day
               delay when it actually gets posted on open information. You can actually go back and
               research it a bit and figure out who were these ministers meeting with. It can tell
               you what bills might come on the floor, what might happen in certain projects, certain
               situations, and that is very key as an opposition MLA. You need to have access to
               these means because that is how we do our work. When this is restricted, it causes
               more delay in our work. The work that I have is important to British Columbians who have elected me to represent
               them, keep the government to account. This is where the grey area hits in. This is
               where the roadblocks hit. This actually restricts the work as an opposition MLA. It
               slows you down on figuring out what's important in your file, what information you
               need to dig up in certain projects, certain fields that you are actually researching.
               When I came in here, this was a huge tool for me to get in and hit the ground running.
               I was able to research transportation projects. Being the Transportation critic, I could go in there and figure out if there's a project
               that's coming up in the future. I was able to see if the minister has met with people
               who are part of that project. It lets the opposition actually have an insight into
               what the government is doing. Now that is being taken away or delayed. What else is
               it? Maybe we would uncover some more limo rides for ministers. Maybe that is the fear
               on the other side. Maybe it's to hide, who knows.... The World Cup is coming around. There are going to
               be tickets handed out. This would be a way that we could figure out that. But now
               it is being taken away on this side of the aisle. It makes me beg. I've been making a lot of.... I'm very active on my social media. I actually have posted
               the calendar notes. I have posted the briefing notes. At times I feel like this bill
               is to restrict me personally in the work that I am doing This is a real issue. This is something that.... British Columbians, a lot of my friends,
               when I came into this place, said: "Hey, how are you going to hold the government
               to account?" This was one of the main tools. This was a very important tool. I have
               actually gone out and helped explain to my constituents where I get my information
               from, because I think being transparent to British Columbians is a huge reason why
               a lot of the people on this side of the aisle actually stepped up, put their name
               on a ballot and wanted to be in this place. Now all that's been taken away by this government that's afraid of their incompetence,
               the things that they want to hide from us as the opposition, which is really concerning
               to me. You can look at a lot of issues like the Highway 1 project. You can go in there
               and figure out who the ministers are meeting, what's going to happen in the next phase
               of that job. This is very important information. Even on the SkyTrain stuff I've been able to go on there and see who they're meeting
               so I know the progress of it. I know what phase they'll be entering. Are they talking
               to people from phase 2 to phase 3? How is that all connected? You can figure this
               stuff out by looking at the calendar. Now there's a pause on a lot of it, and I wonder why that pause happened. Was it because
               of my colleague from Abbotsford-Mission, who did an amazing job in estimates? The next thing you know, the next day, it's
               shut down. That raises serious concerns on this side of the aisle, because we're here
               to represent the people of our ridings, British Columbians, and now we're not being
               able to do that fully. Every step of the way, where we're trying to make progress and get more efficient,
               actually hold this government to account on some of the stuff that they're trying
               to push through, this creates a serious roadblock on this side. That is something that we really need to think about when bills are being put in place
               through this Legislature. How does it help everyone? How does it help the people at
               home who are wondering why they can't put food on the table? They already feel this
               is the most secretive government. Then when situations like this arise, when bills
               like this get put on the floor, their thoughts and feelings feel confirmed. They are
               afraid of what's going on. This really, really.... At the deep of this bill, I am really just blown away that we
               are actually dealing with a government that wants to hide what they're doing from
               British Columbians and the opposition. It is gravely disturbing. We have known the
               Finance Minister taking limo rides — $6,000. Now I want to know: was there more? This
               putting a pause on it, closing this, would actually restrict us from gaining that
               information. With World Cup around the corner, who knows what kind of frivolous spending is going
               to be done by the other side. We've seen it time and time again, tax dollars wasted
               over and over. This access was a way for us to do our work, figure out.... Maybe if
               there's a delay, so be it. At least the truth would come to light at some point. That is the key here. We want to keep this place accountable. We want bills that pass
               through this House to be vetted and debated and actually have good purpose for British
               Columbians. I don't see that with this bill. All I see is another roadblock, more
               bureaucracy, more red tape, when British Columbians are already facing enough of this.
               I have calls from constituents non-stop asking: "What's going on with Bill 9?" What
               is going on? We've had this project right in the middle of our backyard, Highway 1, forever. We
               want to find out information. Do they even have a proper crossing on 264? How is that going to work? How are the lanes going to work? You can actually try
               and access some of that information through this process, and now that's being taken
               away as well. There area lot of situations here, like FOIs that you can put on certain projects.
               My colleague talked about the bridge in Quesnel. I've been there. I've visited that
               bridge. I'm surprised it's even in operation. That FOI came back, and it showed numerous
               things that are not up to date, up to par. Even with the Taylor Bridge, there were
               FOIs that came in there. There have been numerous FOIs that have come out that have shown there have been situations,
               issues with what's going on, and there is no accountability. When you get rid of this
               process, you're pretty much giving them a free cheque to do whatever you want. That
               is not what British Columbians want. It's not what my constituents want. They want When you get rid of this process, you're pretty much giving them a free cheque to
               do whatever you want. That is not what British Columbians want. It's not what my constituents
               want. They want accountability. They want transparency, especially out of the most
               secret government that they've seen to date in British Columbia. I think these are
               legitimate concerns that people have. I can go on and on, and there's more here. The situation here is British Columbians
               are sick and tired of things being hidden from them, having to go jump through hoops.
               Life is already busy, as it is. People have kids they need to drop off at school,
               pick them up, go do their jobs, take them to sports and everything. And now when they're
               trying to figure out maybe something that might be in someone's line of work, what
               government's doing, you go on there, and there are more delays, more delays, more
               delays. This doesn't help a lot of British Columbians. And in a lot of the situations here
               I have seen the reasoning for, I don't buy it. I know if they were on this side of
               the aisle, they'd be screaming and yelling from the rooftops, saying: "This is a way
               to hide what the Conservatives are doing." We've heard it time and time again from
               the other side. This raises serious concerns, and that's why I'm here to speak on this. It's to actually
               bring some accountability for British Columbians and my constituents who are deeply,
               deeply troubled. I was just at an event on Friday, and I had six people come up to
               me and ask me what is going on with Bill 9. To us, this seems a lot of parallel to
               what the federal government is doing, restricting things on social media and other
               aspects, so it is a big concern. Now, I know there are some amendments coming that we'll debate in the next stage.
               We'll see how things are going to roll out, and we'll have some discussion around
               it. But the thing is that British Columbians are looking for transparency in a time
               where it seems to be nonexistent. That's why I feel this bill has been brought in
               to hide what the government is doing. It's been brought in to mitigate the work the opposition has been doing. We have been
               doing great work on this side of the aisle. Right now the reason why we were able
               to do a lot of that work is by looking up the details of what's happened. Who are
               these ministers meeting? What are their briefing notes? What are they actually doing? Now we can go in.... Right now we have accessibility, but in the future if we don't, this is going to hinder
               the work that the opposition MLAs are here to do. That is why I will not support this
               bill. I cannot support this bill, and a lot of issues continue to rise. Every time
               one of these amendments gets put in that they say they will do, you can't take it
               at face value here, because we just do not get how this government wants to continuously
               hide things from British Columbians, hide things from us on the opposition. I know there was a word said,  "Hey, that never happened, limo rides," but let's be
               clear. The Canadian Taxpayers Federation has pulled the FOIs. They have made this
               public knowledge, and we know it was a fact. We know it happened, but what are we
               going to do in the future to try and mitigate these situations? That is the question
               at hand here. In final, I cannot support this bill that would restrict the opposition. It would
               make it harder for British Columbians to access information. That is just not a bill
               that I can actually support in this House. I came into this House to bring transparency,
               to change the way politics has been done, to talk to constituents, educate them on
               bills, let them know what is coming down the pipeline in this chamber. I've seen it time and time again. Before I was a politician, I always wondered how
               decisions are made here. Are British Columbians even consulted? This bill clearly
               shows you they are not being consulted. They are being left in the dust. They are
               being left to wonder what's going on, what their government is doing. Pretty soon they'll be wondering what their opposition is doing, because the opposition
               won't have the information to access everything that the government is doing so we
               can actually hold them to account. That is why I cannot support this bill, and I'm
               really against this bill. I honestly, at times, feel like this bill was brought in place to restrict the work
               that I've been doing, like I've said before on my social medias. I have brought in
               threads. I've posted threads. I've put in all the work. The reason why I do that work
               is because I truly believe British Columbians deserve to know what's going on. When
               there are certain The reason why I do that work is because I truly believe British Columbians deserve
               to know what's going on. When there are certain people being brought in the House,
               and they're being introduced, then later on, a few weeks later, we see bills being
               tabled. It's a great concern. That is why, once again, I will say it time and time again, for the record. I cannot
               support this bill. I will not support this bill. This bill should never have been
               put in place by the government.
Open source reference
Defence & Foreign Affairs: 0 contributions
Environment & Resources: 0 contributions
Health: 0 contributions
Housing & Development: 0 contributions
Public Finance: 0 contributions
Rights & Inclusion: 0 contributions
Social Services: 0 contributions