10 recorded contributions · Small sample
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Parks
Joffre Lakes is not the only provincial park on the block for potential closure for
exclusive cultural events. The minister indicated that she has had requests for Juan
de Fuca and Dunn Lake provincial parks for closure as well. To the Minister of Environment and Parks: how many B.C. provincial parks will be closed
this summer for exclusive cultural events?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Propane
Today I rise to welcome representatives from the Canadian Propane Association who
are joining us here in the gallery. Propane is a vital part of British Columbia's
energy future, a reliable, low-emission fuel produced right here in Canada which helps
power our farms, industries, businesses and communities, especially in rural, remote
and Indigenous regions, where dependable energy access matters the most. We appreciate the opportunity to meet with members of the Canadian Propane Association
over lunch today and to discuss practical, commonsense energy solutions that support
affordability, energy security and economic growth across our province. I also want to thank the members of the Canadian Propane Association for once again
hosting a fantastic food truck lunch reception behind the Legislature, and for reminding
all of us that propane helps keep goods moving, food on our tables, and hard-working
British Columbians employed. Will the House please join me in making that delegation from the CPA most welcome?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Foreign affairs
I, too, would like to welcome the Consular Corps. I would also like to welcome those
delegates from Ethiopia, who I had the honour of meeting at the doorway this morning
outside when they were coming in. The Ambassador of the Federal Republic of Ethiopia,
Tewodros Girma Abebe; the Diaspora Affairs Minister for Ethiopia, Tarifa Echijima-Hundi; and the
president of the Ethiopian-Canadian Human Rights Association of British Columbia,
Kibibi Abate. Would you please make these folks feel most welcome.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Contracting, Contracts
The question that I have might take a little bit of additional research, so I understand
that. I'll just let fly and see how it goes. On May 7, 2026, during estimates for the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, the
minister stated that the On May 7, 2026, during estimates for the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, the minister stated that the improvements to the Kersley-Dale Landing Road washout,
the project near Quesnel, will cost $40 million. It is our understanding that the contract value of the project was $6,073,906.70 when
it was awarded to West Horizon Contracting Inc. on 9 April, 2025, by the ministry. My question is: why is there a roughly $34 million difference between the contract
value and the updated cost estimate provided by the minister earlier this month?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public administration
I want to begin my opposition to Bill 9 with a simple principle. There is a social
contract that exists that is the essence of legitimacy of government. In a democracy,
information produced by government does not belong to government. It belongs to the
public. The people of British Columbia pay for government. They fund the decisions
that are made in ministries. They fund the infrastructure projects that are built.
They fund the policy work that shapes our province. And because they pay for it, they have a right. They have a right, not a privilege
— a right to know how those decisions are made. That is why freedom of information
laws exist. They are not a bureaucratic inconvenience. They are one of the most important
accountability tools available to citizens. These tools allow journalists to investigate.
They allow citizens to hold government accountable. They allow opposition members
in this House to examine decisions that affect communities throughout British Columbia. That is why legislation that weakens freedom of information should concern every member
of this chamber. Unfortunately, Bill 9 challenges that Unfortunately, Bill 9 challenges that social contract. It moves us in the wrong direction.
Transparency is the foundation of accountability, and freedom-of-information laws
exist for a reason. They exist because governments control vast amounts of information
— information about spending, information about decision-making, information about
communications between ministers and bureaucrats. They contain information about projects
that affect communities across this province. Without access to that information, accountability becomes impossible. And without
accountability, public trust erodes. Transparency builds trust; secrecy destroys it.
It breaks down that social contract, and that is really the fundamental issue before
us today, because Bill 9 lowers the standard for transparency. One of the most troubling changes in this bill is the replacement of the duty to respond
to requests "without delay" with the much weaker standard of "without reasonable delay."
Now, on the surface, that might seem like a small wording change. But as I've been
told over many years, words matter. Words matter. Grammar matters. All of it matters,
and it's particularly important in legislation. Freedom of information requests in British Columbia already take far too long. Applicants
routinely wait months, sometimes years. In fact, statistical data shows that in recent
years, applicants waited an average of 192 additional business days beyond the legislated
timeline to receive responses. That's more than nine months, and we all know that
nine months is a pretty long time, and a lot of things can happen in nine months.
That's nine months beyond the deadline that already exists in law. So instead of strengthening the requirement to respond promptly, the government is
weakening it. Instead of fixing the problem, they are lowering the standard. That
is not improving transparency. That is merely redefining delay. I have some experience with the current system. As a sitting MLA representing the
area where the Quesnel Bridge is located, I submitted a freedom-of-information request
last year seeking documents related to that bridge. It was not an unusual request.
There's nothing malicious about it. There's nothing abusive, nothing frivolous. It
was merely an attempt by this member as a Member of the Legislative Assembly to understand
decisions surrounding a piece of infrastructure affecting not merely the community
I represent but the entire province. Yet what happened next speaks volumes about the state of the system in British Columbia.
The request disappeared. It went into the abyss of requests. Months passed, then more
months. Requests for extensions of time. Eventually, a full year later, the response
finally surfaced. But when it did, it came with a hefty bill attached. After waiting
for about a year for information about a project in my own riding, I was told that
if I wanted the documents, I had to first pay the bill. Think about that for a moment. An elected Member of the Legislative Assembly trying
to obtain information about a public infrastructure project in their community has
to wait a year and then has to pay for the privilege of seeing it. Now, this raises an obvious question. If a member of this assembly has to have this
kind of difficulty to get information, how difficult is it already for ordinary citizens?
How difficult is it for journalists or for researchers? As an academic, I submitted
other freedom-of-information requests, and I had that request blocked. They didn't
want to give me the information. I thought to myself: "Okay." I look at this bill. This bill actually talks about that,
and it would make that kind of blocking even more easy to do. That is not okay. How easy would this be for community advocates trying to understand How easy would this be for community advocates trying to understand decisions that
affect their lives? And those experiences raise even more troubling questions when
we consider the legislation before us today. If my requests were to be resubmitted under the provisions of Bill 9, would they even
be processed? Would they be simply dismissed out of hand? Or could somebody claim
that the requests lacked enough detail? Could someone say that it's going to take
too long to locate the records? Could it be argued that responding would interfere
with the operations of government? Well, these are precisely the kinds of new powers
this bill introduces, and that is why this legislation is so concerning. Freedom of information is already slow. It is already expensive. It already requires
persistence. But Bill 9 risks making it easier for government to delay requests, reject
requests or simply discourage someone from making a request altogether. That represents
a breakdown of that social contract. Accountability disappears, for it expands the
grounds to reject requests. It doesn't just expand them in a little way. It dramatically expands them. You can
disregard requests as being abusive, malicious, excessively broad or something that
would unreasonably interfere with the operations of the government of British Columbia.
Let us pause for a moment on that. Interfere with the operations of government — wow
— that's an incredibly broad concept. Responding to any request requires staff time.
Searching records requires effort. Reviewing documents requires resources. By that
definition, almost any request could be said to interfere with operations. What makes this change particularly concerning is that the language now refers to
interference with the operations of the government of British Columbia as a whole,
rather than the operations of a specific public body. That dramatically widens the
scope. When legislation creates vague categories like that, it inevitably raises the
question of how broadly they might be interpreted. This gives the government a tremendous
amount of power over requests. Another change in this bill gives the head of a public body the authority to determine
whether a request contains "enough detail." It also allows them to determine whether
records can be located within a reasonable amount of time. Again, those phrases are
not defined. What qualifies has enough detail? What qualifies has reasonable time?
Those determinations will now be made by the very institutions being asked to release
the information. Well, that doesn't make any sense. It makes that body of government
both the judge and the gatekeeper of access to information. That is precisely the
concern raised by people advocating for transparency. Now, another problem here is that there were a number of expert recommendations made.
It's puzzling to me that it ignores many of the recommendations made in the 2022 special
legislative committee report titled FIPPA for the Future . That committee produced 34 recommendations to improve and modernize the freedom
of information system. Among those recommendations were creating a duty to document, requiring government
to properly record decisions and extending freedom of information rules to the administrative
functions of the Legislative Assembly. Those reforms would have strengthened transparency. Yet, where do we see them in this
bill? Well, we don't see them in this bill. Instead of strengthening accountability,
Bill 9 focuses on administrative convenience. There are a lot of people talking about this bill, folks advocating for transparency. There are a lot of people talking about this bill. Folks advocating for transparency
have been incredibly clear about their concerns. The Freedom of Information and Privacy
Association has warned that this legislation fails to address the real problems in
the system. Their executive director, Jason Woywada, put it plainly. "Access delays
are often a symptom of recordkeeping failures. You cannot fix systemic information
management problems by weakening public access rights." That statement goes to the
heart of the issue. The solution to delays is not to weaken access. The solution is
to improve recordkeeping and provide adequate resources to process requests.Open source reference