3 recorded contributions · Small sample
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Public access, Public administration
I rise today to speak on Bill 9. As someone who has used the Canadian public system
as an important and now represent the people of Surrey North, I see access to information as a basic test of how open and accountable government
is. This bill is being This bill is being presented as an improvement, but it is not. It is a shift of power
away from the public and towards the B.C. NDP government. This bill is not really
about better access to information. It is about more control over who can get information,
when they can get it and how. Once this kind of change happens, it is very hard to
reverse. Freedom of information is not just a rule or process. It is how the public checks
what the government is doing. If this system becomes weaker, accountability also becomes
weaker. Let's look at the facts. In 2024-2025, 7,063 FOI requests were received, and 6,818
requests were completed. This shows thousands of people are using this system every
year. These requests are not small. They involved about 2.18 million pages of government
records. So this is a large detailing dealing with a huge amount of information. Now let's look at how the system is working. The average time to complete a request
is 65 business days, but the legal standard is 30 business days. So it takes more
than double the expected time. Also 81 percent of requests can be completed on time.
That means one out of five is late. This shows the system is already under pressure. Now let's talk about Bill 9. It may be called a modern update, but the effect is what
matters. It makes delay easier to justify, gives more power to refuse requests, adds
more rules before people can ask, allows a fee in more situations, gives more choice
to government officers. Overall, it makes access harder. The bill changes "without delay" to "without unreasonable delay." This means delays
are more acceptable now. People must now give more detailed requests, but what counts
as enough detail is not clearly defined. So government officers can decide more easily
to reject or delay requests. Government can refuse requests if they are called abusive,
repetitive or too broad, but these words are not clearly defined. This gives a lot
of power to reject requests. The bill also allows a fee even for the records that are already public. So people
may now have to pay for information that should already be available. In 2024-2025,
3,592 documents were shared publicly. But in earlier years, that number was higher.
So fewer things are being shared automatically. This means public must now file more
FOI requests to get information. In 2024-2025, 6,186 privacy breaches were reported, and 5,641 were confirmed. But
only a very small number were reported to the public. This raises concerns about transparency
and data safety. In 2024-2025, 70,000 was collected in processing fees, and 214 requests had extra
charges. This shows access is becoming more expensive. Bill 9 continues this trend. Other provinces are moving forward — faster access, more open data, fewer barriers.
British Columbia is moving in the opposite direction — more delays, more rules, more
fees, less Think about a parent. If someone goes wrong in the public system, they want answers.
They file an FOI request. Under this bill, they may be told: "Your request is too
broad. It needs more detail. It takes too long." Or it may be refused. Eventually,
many people will stop trying, not because they got answers but because the process
is too hard. If this bill is about transparency, why make access harder? If it is about efficiency,
why are delays still so long? If it is about openness, why add more features? So I
ask the government, will you remove this fee on public records, yes or no? This bill does improve more administrative parts, but it also makes access harder.
A faster system that gives less information is not better. Good reform should make
timelines enforceable, clearly define refusal rules, reduce fees, improve oversight.
Bill 9 does not do this. Public trust depends on access to information. When access becomes harder, trust goes
down. Freedom of information is not a burden. It is a key part of government accountability. For these reasons, I cannot support Bill 9 in its current form.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Information
I rise today to speak on Bill 9. As someone who has used the Canadian public system
as an important and now represent the people of Surrey North, I see access to information as a basic test of how open and accountable government
is. This bill is being This bill is being presented as an improvement, but it is not. It is a shift of power
away from the public and towards the B.C. NDP government. This bill is not really
about better access to information. It is about more control over who can get information,
when they can get it and how. Once this kind of change happens, it is very hard to
reverse. Freedom of information is not just a rule or process. It is how the public checks
what the government is doing. If this system becomes weaker, accountability also becomes
weaker. Let's look at the facts. In 2024-2025, 7,063 FOI requests were received, and 6,818
requests were completed. This shows thousands of people are using this system every
year. These requests are not small. They involved about 2.18 million pages of government
records. So this is a large detailing dealing with a huge amount of information. Now let's look at how the system is working. The average time to complete a request
is 65 business days, but the legal standard is 30 business days. So it takes more
than double the expected time. Also 81 percent of requests can be completed on time.
That means one out of five is late. This shows the system is already under pressure. Now let's talk about Bill 9. It may be called a modern update, but the effect is what
matters. It makes delay easier to justify, gives more power to refuse requests, adds
more rules before people can ask, allows a fee in more situations, gives more choice
to government officers. Overall, it makes access harder. The bill changes "without delay" to "without unreasonable delay." This means delays
are more acceptable now. People must now give more detailed requests, but what counts
as enough detail is not clearly defined. So government officers can decide more easily
to reject or delay requests. Government can refuse requests if they are called abusive,
repetitive or too broad, but these words are not clearly defined. This gives a lot
of power to reject requests. The bill also allows a fee even for the records that are already public. So people
may now have to pay for information that should already be available. In 2024-2025,
3,592 documents were shared publicly. But in earlier years, that number was higher.
So fewer things are being shared automatically. This means public must now file more
FOI requests to get information. In 2024-2025, 6,186 privacy breaches were reported, and 5,641 were confirmed. But
only a very small number were reported to the public. This raises concerns about transparency
and data safety. In 2024-2025, 70,000 was collected in processing fees, and 214 requests had extra
charges. This shows access is becoming more expensive. Bill 9 continues this trend. Other provinces are moving forward — faster access, more open data, fewer barriers.
British Columbia is moving in the opposite direction — more delays, more rules, more
fees, less Think about a parent. If someone goes wrong in the public system, they want answers.
They file an FOI request. Under this bill, they may be told: "Your request is too
broad. It needs more detail. It takes too long." Or it may be refused. Eventually,
many people will stop trying, not because they got answers but because the process
is too hard. If this bill is about transparency, why make access harder? If it is about efficiency,
why are delays still so long? If it is about openness, why add more features? So I
ask the government, will you remove this fee on public records, yes or no? This bill does improve more administrative parts, but it also makes access harder.
A faster system that gives less information is not better. Good reform should make
timelines enforceable, clearly define refusal rules, reduce fees, improve oversight.
Bill 9 does not do this. Public trust depends on access to information. When access becomes harder, trust goes
down. Freedom of information is not a burden. It is a key part of government accountability. For these reasons, I cannot support Bill 9 in its current form.Open source reference