9 recorded contributions
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Hockey
This coming Sunday is my wonderful grandson Fraser's seventh birthday. He is such
a keener and an absolute duck to water with ice hockey. Passionate about it. Will the House please help me wish him a very happy birthday on Sunday.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Marriage
I am delighted to introduce Ella Van Enta, my newest CA, who is beginning in June. How much does she love the Legislature? Well, there was a newscast being filmed right in front of the Legislature, in front of the fountain. All of
a sudden, the camera got diverted because Ella's fiancé was down on bended knee, asking for her hand in marriage. And she said yes.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Recreation
Imagine it is a gorgeous summer's day with the sun shining down on exquisite flowers
dotted around lovely gardens, pristine greens, graceful trees and all overlooked by
a gracious heritage clubhouse, with a wide veranda filled with onlookers, laughing
and having fun, children as young as nine years old and seniors in their 90s all sharing
the same greens, all enjoying the simple pleasures of lawn bowling together. The West Vancouver Lawn Bowling Club has been a cherished part of the West Vancouver
community for generations. Since the early 20th century, it has grown alongside West
Vancouver itself, not just as a sporting club but as a gathering place where friendships
are formed, neighbours connect and people of all ages feel welcome. What makes this club so special is not only its history but its spirit of inclusion.
Through lessons, tournaments, open houses and youth programs, it has kept a proud
tradition alive while making it accessible to new generations. It is a place where
young people learn from seniors, where seniors remain active and engaged, and where
everyone feels a sense of belonging. In a fast-changing world, the West Vancouver Lawn Bowling Club reminds us of the importance
of community, of connection and of healthy living. It enriches West Vancouver not
simply as a place to play a sport but as a place where people truly come together,
where friendships are born, stories are shared, laughter echoes across the greens
and generations connect with one another. It is a welcoming home away from home, where
everyone is greeted with kindness, everyone is valued and everyone belongs.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Privacy
Ah, that was lively. I appreciate the words of my colleague before me, making it very
clear what the hoist motion is all about. I rise today to speak in support of the hoist motion that the motion for second reading of Bill (No. 9) intituled Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026 , be amended by deleting the word "now" and substituting "six months hence." This is a straightforward procedural change in wording, but it carries profound legislative
significance. It is, in essence, a motion to defer consideration of Bill 9 for six
months, and that deferral is both necessary and justified. This motion to delay for six months is not about obstruction. It is about responsibility.
It asks this House to recognize that when we amend legislation in real time, when
government itself brings forward corrections to its own bill, it is, by definition,
acknowledging that the original version was incomplete or even flawed. That reality alone supports the logic of a six-month pause. We are not being asked
to perfect a finished product here. We are being asked to continuously repair one.
A six-month deferral allows this House to step back, assess the full scope of those
deficiencies and ensure that what ultimately proceeds is sound in law, clear in meaning
and durable in practice. Once legislation is enacted, it ceases to be theoretical. It becomes operational.
It governs real decisions, real disclosures and real consequences for British Columbians
seeking access to information and protection of privacy. That is precisely why this
motion to defer for six months is so critical. In this field of law — and it is in the field of law — errors are not abstract drafting
problems. They are barriers to transparency, barriers to accountability and, most
importantly, barriers to public trust. When the stakes are access to information and
privacy rights, rushed correction is not good governance. It is risk accumulation. As Benjamin Franklin wisely said, and it's a very old saying: "An ounce of prevention
is worth a pound of cure." That principle is really accurate today, and it's not rhetorical.
It is structural. The motion before us to substitute "six months hence" for the word "now" is the legislative
expression of prevention. It recognizes that it is far easier to correct deficiencies
before enactment than to repair or band-aid systemic issues after implementation. Let's be frank. This is not delay for its own sake. It is discipline in the service
of better law. The central question before this House is not whether Bill 9 proceeds, but whether
it proceeds in a form that is complete, in a form that is coherent, in a form that
is consistent with its own stated objectives. The government's willingness to bring forward amendments already signals that refinement
is definitely required. That fact strengthens, it does not weaken, the case for a
six-month deferral. If amendments are necessary today, then it is reasonable to conclude
that deeper issues may still remain beneath the surface. This motion to defer for six months ensures that those critical issues are addressed
comprehensively rather than incrementally under pressure. Now, modernization has been cited as justification for urgency. This is not logical
because modernization is not defined by speed. It is defined by clarity This motion to amend second reading of Bill 9 by substituting "six months hence" for
the word "now" reflects that understanding. Taking additional time now is what ensures
that modernization is meaningful rather than superficial. Without that time, we risk
producing legislation that may be modern in appearance but definitely unstable and
lacking in application. This motion to defer for six months is justified by the extensive work already completed
by the 2022 Special Committee on the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy
Act. I refer back to that. It was in 2022. That committee produced a multiparty....
All people giving their input. It also produced an evidence-based roadmap, very important
here. It called for stronger timelines, it called for improved access, it called for
enhanced oversight, and it called for proactive disclosure — all laudable and important
enhancements. If the current bill already requires amendment, this raises a reasonable concern that
those recommendations issued in 2022 have not been fully applied or integrated. A
six-month pause would allow this House to properly align Bill 9 with that existing
body of work rather than attempting to retrofit alignment after the fact. This concern is underscored when we examine the substance of this Bill 9. The 2022
Special Committee on the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act emphasized
clear, duty-driven standards. Yet, clause 3 replaces the requirement to respond "without
delay" with "without unreasonable delay." This is not a minor drafting change. It
represents a fundamental shift from a clear obligation to a more subjective, justification-based
standard. "Without delay" provides a firm directive whereas "without unreasonable
delay" introduces ambiguity, subtly shifting the burden from the government, to justify
delays, onto applicants, to challenge them. A six-month deferral would allow the House to reconcile this departure and ensure
consistency with the committee's recommendations. Why not? Why reinvent the wheel
when it is going to fall off? Why not use this committee's recommendations to make
sure that this bill is the best it can be? Another compelling reason for this motion lies in the need for precision in legislative
language. I want to come back to that in a little while too. When statutes rely on
open-ended or subjective terms such as "reasonable amount of time" or "experienced
employee" or "abusive" conduct without clear definitions of any of those terms, they
create subjective interpretive instability and ambiguity. This is not merely theoretical. It leads to uneven application across public bodies,
where identical requests may be treated differently depending on the individual looking
at them and reading them, and their interpretation. Clause 2 illustrates this risk by introducing a subjective threshold for what constitutes
a valid request, based on the opinion of the head of a public body, regarding what
constitutes a "reasonable" time to locate records. Well, to me, reasonable Well, to me, reasonable is two days to get back to a constituent who is asking for
information, two days. But maybe someone says that a month is reasonable time. There
is no definitive clarification on what is reasonable time, and that's open-ended.
What is reasonable to one official may not be reasonable to another. By making reasonableness
a matter of opinion rather than an objective standard or definition, the balance of
power shifts toward the gatekeeper and away from the citizen. This concern is reinforced in clause 13, which expands the grounds....Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public service
In a democracy, accountability does not end on election night. It begins there. The
decisions made in this Legislature affect every family, every worker and every future
generation. They shape taxes, spending, debt, health care, infrastructure and human
rights. That is why it is both reasonable and responsible that newly elected members
of the Legislative Assembly receive mandatory training in economics, public finance
and numeracy. These are not partisan ideas. They are essential tools for informed decision-making.
We would never expect a pilot to fly without training or an engineer to design a bridge
without understanding physics. Yet elected officials are asked to make enormously
complex decisions involving billions of public dollars and the well-being of millions
of people, without being informed. Good intentions alone are not enough. Public service requires preparation, humility
and a willingness to learn. As former South African President Nelson Mandela said:
"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Mandatory orientation courses would not dictate ideology or political belief. They
would simply ensure that all members, regardless of background or party, possess a
basic understanding of the responsibilities of governing in the public interest. At
a time when misinformation and distrust are rising, strengthening the knowledge and
competence of elected officials is not elitist. It is democratic. Citizens deserve
leaders who are prepared not only to speak passionately but to govern responsibly.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Law
Ah, that was lively. I appreciate the words of my colleague before me, making it very
clear what the hoist motion is all about. I rise today to speak in support of the hoist motion that the motion for second reading of Bill (No. 9) intituled Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026 , be amended by deleting the word "now" and substituting "six months hence." This is a straightforward procedural change in wording, but it carries profound legislative
significance. It is, in essence, a motion to defer consideration of Bill 9 for six
months, and that deferral is both necessary and justified. This motion to delay for six months is not about obstruction. It is about responsibility.
It asks this House to recognize that when we amend legislation in real time, when
government itself brings forward corrections to its own bill, it is, by definition,
acknowledging that the original version was incomplete or even flawed. That reality alone supports the logic of a six-month pause. We are not being asked
to perfect a finished product here. We are being asked to continuously repair one.
A six-month deferral allows this House to step back, assess the full scope of those
deficiencies and ensure that what ultimately proceeds is sound in law, clear in meaning
and durable in practice. Once legislation is enacted, it ceases to be theoretical. It becomes operational.
It governs real decisions, real disclosures and real consequences for British Columbians
seeking access to information and protection of privacy. That is precisely why this
motion to defer for six months is so critical. In this field of law — and it is in the field of law — errors are not abstract drafting
problems. They are barriers to transparency, barriers to accountability and, most
importantly, barriers to public trust. When the stakes are access to information and
privacy rights, rushed correction is not good governance. It is risk accumulation. As Benjamin Franklin wisely said, and it's a very old saying: "An ounce of prevention
is worth a pound of cure." That principle is really accurate today, and it's not rhetorical.
It is structural. The motion before us to substitute "six months hence" for the word "now" is the legislative
expression of prevention. It recognizes that it is far easier to correct deficiencies
before enactment than to repair or band-aid systemic issues after implementation. Let's be frank. This is not delay for its own sake. It is discipline in the service
of better law. The central question before this House is not whether Bill 9 proceeds, but whether
it proceeds in a form that is complete, in a form that is coherent, in a form that
is consistent with its own stated objectives. The government's willingness to bring forward amendments already signals that refinement
is definitely required. That fact strengthens, it does not weaken, the case for a
six-month deferral. If amendments are necessary today, then it is reasonable to conclude
that deeper issues may still remain beneath the surface. This motion to defer for six months ensures that those critical issues are addressed
comprehensively rather than incrementally under pressure. Now, modernization has been cited as justification for urgency. This is not logical
because modernization is not defined by speed. It is defined by clarity This motion to amend second reading of Bill 9 by substituting "six months hence" for
the word "now" reflects that understanding. Taking additional time now is what ensures
that modernization is meaningful rather than superficial. Without that time, we risk
producing legislation that may be modern in appearance but definitely unstable and
lacking in application. This motion to defer for six months is justified by the extensive work already completed
by the 2022 Special Committee on the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy
Act. I refer back to that. It was in 2022. That committee produced a multiparty....
All people giving their input. It also produced an evidence-based roadmap, very important
here. It called for stronger timelines, it called for improved access, it called for
enhanced oversight, and it called for proactive disclosure — all laudable and important
enhancements. If the current bill already requires amendment, this raises a reasonable concern that
those recommendations issued in 2022 have not been fully applied or integrated. A
six-month pause would allow this House to properly align Bill 9 with that existing
body of work rather than attempting to retrofit alignment after the fact. This concern is underscored when we examine the substance of this Bill 9. The 2022
Special Committee on the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act emphasized
clear, duty-driven standards. Yet, clause 3 replaces the requirement to respond "without
delay" with "without unreasonable delay." This is not a minor drafting change. It
represents a fundamental shift from a clear obligation to a more subjective, justification-based
standard. "Without delay" provides a firm directive whereas "without unreasonable
delay" introduces ambiguity, subtly shifting the burden from the government, to justify
delays, onto applicants, to challenge them. A six-month deferral would allow the House to reconcile this departure and ensure
consistency with the committee's recommendations. Why not? Why reinvent the wheel
when it is going to fall off? Why not use this committee's recommendations to make
sure that this bill is the best it can be? Another compelling reason for this motion lies in the need for precision in legislative
language. I want to come back to that in a little while too. When statutes rely on
open-ended or subjective terms such as "reasonable amount of time" or "experienced
employee" or "abusive" conduct without clear definitions of any of those terms, they
create subjective interpretive instability and ambiguity. This is not merely theoretical. It leads to uneven application across public bodies,
where identical requests may be treated differently depending on the individual looking
at them and reading them, and their interpretation. Clause 2 illustrates this risk by introducing a subjective threshold for what constitutes
a valid request, based on the opinion of the head of a public body, regarding what
constitutes a "reasonable" time to locate records. Well, to me, reasonable Well, to me, reasonable is two days to get back to a constituent who is asking for
information, two days. But maybe someone says that a month is reasonable time. There
is no definitive clarification on what is reasonable time, and that's open-ended.
What is reasonable to one official may not be reasonable to another. By making reasonableness
a matter of opinion rather than an objective standard or definition, the balance of
power shifts toward the gatekeeper and away from the citizen. This concern is reinforced in clause 13, which expands the grounds....Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Arrests
In Ontario, the Toronto Transit Commission police are being allowed to arrest open
use of illegal drugs. We know one of the barriers to increasing ridership on public
transport is people not only feeling unsafe, but they are unsafe. Will this government follow Ontario's lead and require that transit police arrest
those that are openly using illegal drugs?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public finance
In a democracy, accountability does not end on election night. It begins there. The
decisions made in this Legislature affect every family, every worker and every future
generation. They shape taxes, spending, debt, health care, infrastructure and human
rights. That is why it is both reasonable and responsible that newly elected members
of the Legislative Assembly receive mandatory training in economics, public finance
and numeracy. These are not partisan ideas. They are essential tools for informed decision-making.
We would never expect a pilot to fly without training or an engineer to design a bridge
without understanding physics. Yet elected officials are asked to make enormously
complex decisions involving billions of public dollars and the well-being of millions
of people, without being informed. Good intentions alone are not enough. Public service requires preparation, humility
and a willingness to learn. As former South African President Nelson Mandela said:
"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Mandatory orientation courses would not dictate ideology or political belief. They
would simply ensure that all members, regardless of background or party, possess a
basic understanding of the responsibilities of governing in the public interest. At
a time when misinformation and distrust are rising, strengthening the knowledge and
competence of elected officials is not elitist. It is democratic. Citizens deserve
leaders who are prepared not only to speak passionately but to govern responsibly.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Drug laws, Narcotics
In Ontario, the Toronto Transit Commission police are being allowed to arrest open
use of illegal drugs. We know one of the barriers to increasing ridership on public
transport is people not only feeling unsafe, but they are unsafe. Will this government follow Ontario's lead and require that transit police arrest
those that are openly using illegal drugs?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues
In a democracy, accountability does not end on election night. It begins there. The
decisions made in this Legislature affect every family, every worker and every future
generation. They shape taxes, spending, debt, health care, infrastructure and human
rights. That is why it is both reasonable and responsible that newly elected members
of the Legislative Assembly receive mandatory training in economics, public finance
and numeracy. These are not partisan ideas. They are essential tools for informed decision-making.
We would never expect a pilot to fly without training or an engineer to design a bridge
without understanding physics. Yet elected officials are asked to make enormously
complex decisions involving billions of public dollars and the well-being of millions
of people, without being informed. Good intentions alone are not enough. Public service requires preparation, humility
and a willingness to learn. As former South African President Nelson Mandela said:
"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Mandatory orientation courses would not dictate ideology or political belief. They
would simply ensure that all members, regardless of background or party, possess a
basic understanding of the responsibilities of governing in the public interest. At
a time when misinformation and distrust are rising, strengthening the knowledge and
competence of elected officials is not elitist. It is democratic. Citizens deserve
leaders who are prepared not only to speak passionately but to govern responsibly.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public transit
In Ontario, the Toronto Transit Commission police are being allowed to arrest open
use of illegal drugs. We know one of the barriers to increasing ridership on public
transport is people not only feeling unsafe, but they are unsafe. Will this government follow Ontario's lead and require that transit police arrest
those that are openly using illegal drugs?Open source reference