1 recorded contribution · Small sample
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Constitutional law
I want to start, with regards to the motion, just addressing some of the things that
the hon. member from the Green Party has brought forward. I understand the reluctance
and his suspicion around this. The actions of opposition often use things like hoists
to delay projects, to try to talk things out, to eat up time, these types of things.
But in this particular case, when you're looking at what the intent was here, there
are serious issues associated with overlap. Now, when modern treaties were first brought in — and I remember debating some of
these treaties in the Legislature — the issue of overlap was there as well, but it
wasn't as acute. Because of DRIPA, UNDRIP, the court cases that have come forward,
the issue of overlap is far more critical today than it was in the original treaties,
whether it was the Maa-nulth treaty or whether it is some of the treaties that failed
— ɬəʔamɛn. Tsawwassen, of course, had been successful. I'm thinking particularly about the Lheidli T'enneh treaty, which did not get ratified because of overlap issues. So what we are seeing today is a significant difference between those treaties that
were brought in and this treaty here and the other two treaties yet to come, being
the Kitselas and Kitsumkalum. Because of the significance of the environment that's
changed in B.C. because of what's happened with DRIPA, with the introduction of UNDRIP
as part of that, the expectations are much higher. The legal ramifications are much
more significant, and we are seeing that playing out. For those reasons, I think it's important that we send this to a committee, that we
have an opportunity to actually play these things out, to talk about this, to understand
how this goes in, to have the input and try to find a path forward. Because the world
has changed from 30 years ago, from 20 years ago, from ten years ago. The world has
changed. It has changed intentionally by this government, for better or for worse. I would
say for worse. But it has intentionally changed, and so we need to take that into
context when we're talking about treaty and the advancement of treaty. I've been a proponent of treaty for many, many years, and I've come to the conclusion
that we need to be talking much more about how we conclude reconciliation entirely,
but that's a different conversation. There needs to be this avenue to be able to address this because of how things have
changed in British Columbia, and how else can you do that? Because in committee stage,
we can have this discussion back and forth, but it's not the opportunity of time and
to be able to have the input and engagement between the nations, giving them the ability
to actually work this thing through with the help of government and opposition, through
committee, working these things through.... After all, as the member of the Green Party said, this is the whole purpose of why
they're there. We want to be able to pass and bring things forward that make sense,
that can achieve results, that are going to improve the opportunities for First Nations
— self-determined, self-governance, these types of things. If we're going to do that, if we're going to do that right, let's find a way to avoid
the huge pitfalls that, quite frankly, have become major barriers, major stumbling blocks to how we
advance modern treaties today. It's not just about the K'ómoks treaty, because we have the other treaties and other nations of the province who
are looking at it. The issue of overlaps is far more significant right across this province. So if we
can get it right here, if we can find a way to be able to address it and deal with
it today, through a process, we're not only helping to solidify and strengthen the
opportunity for the K'ómoks People, but we're also setting the stage for how we might be able to do things across
this province in addressing this. So this is a very timely and important discussion to be able to bring forward in terms
of this motion, and I really thank the member for Langley–Walnut Grove for So this is a very timely and important discussion to be able to bring forward in terms
of this motion, and I really thank the member for Langley–Walnut Grove for opening up this debate around moving it to a committee, creating that avenue
to deal with it. Now, there are some things that the Green Party and I may agree on. There are some things that we may not agree on. One of the things,
of course, is UNDRIP and the implementation of UNDRIP. When I first looked at the treaty, and it says
it's an authoritative source, I kind of looked at it and went: "Well, is this huge?
Is this significant? What does this mean?" But I've come to the conclusion that with the problems of DRIPA.... And we don't even
know exactly what they all are because government isn't forthcoming with these issues.
They haven't brought forward legislation and the changes that they believe are necessary to be able to resolve these things. Cementing UNDRIP into a constitutional document creates a tremendous amount of unknown
factors. And so I went to all the sources I could find. I've talked to First Nations about it. I've talked to lawyers about it. I've talked to judges and former judges
about it. What does it mean, an authoritative source? It doesn't say it's the authoritative
source; it says it's an authoritative source. What it means is that it is authoritative. In other words, it is at the same equivalent law to all other law in this country, including section 35 of our constitution. It is an authoritative source. When you go back and look at the original debate of UNDRIP in the United Nations, that was never what the intention was. It was never the intention of that as it
was passed, and certainly not in the context of Canada, which has Aboriginal rights protected in the constitution. So the importance of this motion to move this to committee is to be able to create
that venue, that opportunity for discussion of overlap, but it's also to allow for
more information to come forward of the unintended consequences of having UNDRIP directly
in this treaty. Because as I'm sure you know, the member who spoke before me from the Green Party,
other members have talked about — what's the purpose of doing treaty in the first
place? The purpose of doing treaty is to find a path forward, for nations to be successful,
to prevent things from going to court, to create that sort of stability or certainty
that we've all talked about. That's the intent of doing treaty. It's a way to address these long outstanding issues and be able to move forward in a good way as partners — not as divorced but
as partners, married, going forward, moving this forward to be successful. But how
do you do that when there's this kind of uncertainty that is being created, and how
do you do that with these issues of overlaps with their neighbours? You think about this. It's been 30 years working on to get this treaty to this point
— 30 years. Multiple generations have been working at this to get this thing passed. And I know the K'ómoks People are excited about moving this forward. They want to see their opportunity to
advance. We've seen the success of other modern treaties that have come forward for
this. I believe that the First Nations want this to be successful and they don't want this to generate conflict or they
don't want this to generate court cases. They don't want to have the conflict of unintended
consequence as well. There's a simple change that could have happened. Instead of making it an authoritative
process, they could have done it like UNDRIP was supposed to be. They could have just
said it is a guiding principle. How does...?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: First Nations
I want to start, with regards to the motion, just addressing some of the things that
the hon. member from the Green Party has brought forward. I understand the reluctance
and his suspicion around this. The actions of opposition often use things like hoists
to delay projects, to try to talk things out, to eat up time, these types of things.
But in this particular case, when you're looking at what the intent was here, there
are serious issues associated with overlap. Now, when modern treaties were first brought in — and I remember debating some of
these treaties in the Legislature — the issue of overlap was there as well, but it
wasn't as acute. Because of DRIPA, UNDRIP, the court cases that have come forward,
the issue of overlap is far more critical today than it was in the original treaties,
whether it was the Maa-nulth treaty or whether it is some of the treaties that failed
— ɬəʔamɛn. Tsawwassen, of course, had been successful. I'm thinking particularly about the Lheidli T'enneh treaty, which did not get ratified because of overlap issues. So what we are seeing today is a significant difference between those treaties that
were brought in and this treaty here and the other two treaties yet to come, being
the Kitselas and Kitsumkalum. Because of the significance of the environment that's
changed in B.C. because of what's happened with DRIPA, with the introduction of UNDRIP
as part of that, the expectations are much higher. The legal ramifications are much
more significant, and we are seeing that playing out. For those reasons, I think it's important that we send this to a committee, that we
have an opportunity to actually play these things out, to talk about this, to understand
how this goes in, to have the input and try to find a path forward. Because the world
has changed from 30 years ago, from 20 years ago, from ten years ago. The world has
changed. It has changed intentionally by this government, for better or for worse. I would
say for worse. But it has intentionally changed, and so we need to take that into
context when we're talking about treaty and the advancement of treaty. I've been a proponent of treaty for many, many years, and I've come to the conclusion
that we need to be talking much more about how we conclude reconciliation entirely,
but that's a different conversation. There needs to be this avenue to be able to address this because of how things have
changed in British Columbia, and how else can you do that? Because in committee stage,
we can have this discussion back and forth, but it's not the opportunity of time and
to be able to have the input and engagement between the nations, giving them the ability
to actually work this thing through with the help of government and opposition, through
committee, working these things through.... After all, as the member of the Green Party said, this is the whole purpose of why
they're there. We want to be able to pass and bring things forward that make sense,
that can achieve results, that are going to improve the opportunities for First Nations
— self-determined, self-governance, these types of things. If we're going to do that, if we're going to do that right, let's find a way to avoid
the huge pitfalls that, quite frankly, have become major barriers, major stumbling blocks to how we
advance modern treaties today. It's not just about the K'ómoks treaty, because we have the other treaties and other nations of the province who
are looking at it. The issue of overlaps is far more significant right across this province. So if we
can get it right here, if we can find a way to be able to address it and deal with
it today, through a process, we're not only helping to solidify and strengthen the
opportunity for the K'ómoks People, but we're also setting the stage for how we might be able to do things across
this province in addressing this. So this is a very timely and important discussion to be able to bring forward in terms
of this motion, and I really thank the member for Langley–Walnut Grove for So this is a very timely and important discussion to be able to bring forward in terms
of this motion, and I really thank the member for Langley–Walnut Grove for opening up this debate around moving it to a committee, creating that avenue
to deal with it. Now, there are some things that the Green Party and I may agree on. There are some things that we may not agree on. One of the things,
of course, is UNDRIP and the implementation of UNDRIP. When I first looked at the treaty, and it says
it's an authoritative source, I kind of looked at it and went: "Well, is this huge?
Is this significant? What does this mean?" But I've come to the conclusion that with the problems of DRIPA.... And we don't even
know exactly what they all are because government isn't forthcoming with these issues.
They haven't brought forward legislation and the changes that they believe are necessary to be able to resolve these things. Cementing UNDRIP into a constitutional document creates a tremendous amount of unknown
factors. And so I went to all the sources I could find. I've talked to First Nations about it. I've talked to lawyers about it. I've talked to judges and former judges
about it. What does it mean, an authoritative source? It doesn't say it's the authoritative
source; it says it's an authoritative source. What it means is that it is authoritative. In other words, it is at the same equivalent law to all other law in this country, including section 35 of our constitution. It is an authoritative source. When you go back and look at the original debate of UNDRIP in the United Nations, that was never what the intention was. It was never the intention of that as it
was passed, and certainly not in the context of Canada, which has Aboriginal rights protected in the constitution. So the importance of this motion to move this to committee is to be able to create
that venue, that opportunity for discussion of overlap, but it's also to allow for
more information to come forward of the unintended consequences of having UNDRIP directly
in this treaty. Because as I'm sure you know, the member who spoke before me from the Green Party,
other members have talked about — what's the purpose of doing treaty in the first
place? The purpose of doing treaty is to find a path forward, for nations to be successful,
to prevent things from going to court, to create that sort of stability or certainty
that we've all talked about. That's the intent of doing treaty. It's a way to address these long outstanding issues and be able to move forward in a good way as partners — not as divorced but
as partners, married, going forward, moving this forward to be successful. But how
do you do that when there's this kind of uncertainty that is being created, and how
do you do that with these issues of overlaps with their neighbours? You think about this. It's been 30 years working on to get this treaty to this point
— 30 years. Multiple generations have been working at this to get this thing passed. And I know the K'ómoks People are excited about moving this forward. They want to see their opportunity to
advance. We've seen the success of other modern treaties that have come forward for
this. I believe that the First Nations want this to be successful and they don't want this to generate conflict or they
don't want this to generate court cases. They don't want to have the conflict of unintended
consequence as well. There's a simple change that could have happened. Instead of making it an authoritative
process, they could have done it like UNDRIP was supposed to be. They could have just
said it is a guiding principle. How does...?Open source reference